Showing posts with label Top-Notch Comics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Top-Notch Comics. Show all posts

Sunday, July 22, 2012

July 1940: Top-Notch Comics #8

Cover by Edd Ashe

'The Wizard' (by Harry Shorten and Edd Ashe): The Wizard takes on Mayor Beadle and his crooked politics, but of much more importance is the introduction of Roy the Super-Boy. Roy is a bootblack and orphan who the Wizard takes under his wing and trains. By the end of that training Roy is supposedly just as good as the Wizard, which seems a bit odd. I've seen the Wizard tear battleships apart with his bare hands!  I hate kid sidekicks at the best of times (Robin excepted) and I'm wondering what makes this kid so special. Can the Wizard train just anybody to be as strong as he is? Why not recruit an army of super-strong kids? It doesn't make sense, and I'm very sceptical as to whether Roy's presence will improve the strip.

'The Firefly' (by Harry Shorten and Bob Wood): Harley Hudson has devoted his life to becoming a crime-fighter, and after two years of studying insects he is able to replicate their amazing muscular feats. He dons a uniform, becomes the Firefly, and battles a mad scientist who is trying to create his master-race. It does have a certain energy to it, and mad scientists at this point are a welcome break from racketeers and spies. It's a decent enough beginning.

'Shanghai Sheridan' (by Joe Blair and Irv Novick): Sheridan helps smuggle arms and ammunition to the rebels in China. This is the strip's final appearance. It was underwhelming throughout, and its only notable trait was a questionable portrayal of the various Asian peoples involved.

'Streak Chandler on Mars' (by Harry Shorten and William Wills): Streak Chandler and his friends have been captured by the space pirate Quantus, and are being held on one of Jupiter's moons. They manage to escape and destroy Quantus's fleet, but Streak is betrayed by the alien Lura, who captures them all. This is the final appearance of this strip, so one can only assume that Lura has them all executed. So long Streak, I'll never forget that time you fought a weird horse-headed octopus.

'Dick Storm' (by Harry Shorten and Mort Meskin): Dick and his friends are trapped on an island with pirates, who they manage to defeat, despite the cowardice of Jessup.  This is the final installment of this very boring strip.

In other stories:

'Galahad' (by Harry Shorten and Lin Streeter) helps King Arthur fight the King of Ireland. 'Wings Johnson of the Air Patrol' (by Joe Blair and Ed Smalle) locates and destroys a secret Nazi airbase. 'Bob Phantom, Scourge of the Underworld' (by Harry Shorten and Gerry Thorpe) tackles a gang of cop kidnappers.  And 'Kardak the Mystic Magician' (by Harry Shorten and Bernard Klein) battles the Master of the Valley of Death in an effectively creepy story.

Wednesday, January 18, 2012

April 1940: Top-Notch Comics #6

Cover by Edd Ashe

'The Wizard, the Man with the Super Brain' (by Edd Ashe): We're back with the modern day Wizard, who is still foiling plots by the Mosconians. First they try to kill him with a bombing raid on his rocket car, then they try to destroy Boulder Dam in Colorado. Both sequences are action-packed, and I found myself quite impressed to see the Wizard hold up the breached dam all by himself. It's the sort of thing I wouldn't bat an eyelid over in a modern super-hero comic, but over the course of this blog I've become accustomed to the very low key powers of the Golden Age.  I think that I prefer it this way.

'Galahad' (by Harry Shorten and Lin Streeter): Galahad must retrieve the stolen Golden Chalice from the Earl of Pellam. There's plenty of derring-do and sword-fighting to keep me entertained, but it all feels a little hollow. There's a plot strand about the Earl's wife wanting the Chalice so that it can make her more beautiful than Queen Guinevere, and that's a set-up for a proper story if ever there was one. But it goes nowhere, and what we get instead is pages and pages of Galahad fighting other knights.

'Shanghai Sheridan' (by Joe Blair and Irv Novick): Sheridan meets an American named Scary Dee, saves the crew of an American yacht from the Japanese, and survives an attack from the evil Wu Fang's men. This is very piecemeal, and never gels coherently. It also has some terribly primitive speech patterns for the Japanese. I don't mind this so much in situations where they are obviously speaking in English, because a lot of people have trouble speaking foreign languages. But when they're talking amongst themselves? It's unforgivable.

'Streak Chandler on Mars' (by Harry Shorten and William Wills): The tyrant Kalox was deposed by Streak Chandler in the last issue, but in this story he steals a powerful radium crystal, capable of destroying planets. Not that he does much with it; Kalox spends most of the strip fleeing from Streak, before Streak destroys his ship with a disintegrator ray. It's always disappointing when a villain doesn't live up to the hype.

'Wings Johnson of the Air Patrol' (by Joe Blair and Ed Smalle): Having finally killed his mortal enemy Von Schiller, Wings is reassigned. He helps fight a naval battle against the Nazis, then helps defend attacks on South American military bases. I appreciate his dedication in having two adventures in one issue, but it does make things very cramped and unsatisfying.

'Dick Storm' (by Harry Shorten and Mort Meskin): In this story Dick topples a South American dictator who has taken over a region in Honduras. One of the central points of the story is that the dictator has no ammunition for his guns. And I'm supposed to believe that he led and maintained a successful coup? It's preposterous.

'Bob Phantom, Scourge of the Underworld' (by Harry Shorten and Gerry Thorp): The villainous Ah Ku is back, leading an opium smuggling operation. Bob Phantom takes down her operation in a terribly average story.

'West Pointer' (by Harry Shorten and Ed Wexler): This strip is supposed to be about army cadets, but somehow it always ends up as a sport comic. In this story Keith Kornell is chosen to pitch in a baseball match against Midvale, but ends up getting in a fight with the opposition's star hitter. Later on he saves the same guy from a fire, then goes on to pitch a winning game despite an injured leg. I'm just happy that there were no crooked gamblers involved.

'Kardak the Mystic Magician' (by Harry Shorten and C.A. Winter): Kardak goes up against Hindu mystics who plan to release a plague of locusts in the Mississippi delta for reasons that are not entirely clear. The cliffhanger ending has Kardak and his fiancee trapped in quicksand, which is about as exciting as the rest of the story.

Sunday, December 4, 2011

March 1940: Top-Notch Comics #5, Detective Comics #38

 Cover by Edd Ashe

'The Wizard, The Man With the Super-Brain' (by Edd Ashe): It's crossover central again, as the Wizard battles Mosconian agents while meeting the Shield, Keith Kornell (aka the West Pointer) and Lee Sampson (aka the Midshipman). To be honest, these cameos add nothing to the story. The Shield was utterly superfluous, and the other two could just as easily have been any random cadet or member of the navy. Even so, it's a good bit of fun.

'Galahad' (by Harry Shorten and Lin Streeter): This new strip features the titular knight of the Round Table. Galahad goes to King Arthur's court and is made a knight after defeating Sir Kay in a joust. Soon after he helps Lady Lynette stop the evil Sir Gilbert from seizing her lands. I am a sucker for any thing with a sword in it, and this does have a pretty good fight scene between Galahad and Gilbert. But in the end that's all it comes down to, and Galahad triumphs through his prowess and nothing more. I expect something a little more meaningful from a story drawing on the Arthurian mythos.

'Shanghai Sheridan' (by Joe Blair and Irv Novick): Jack Sheridan's father was killed by invaders in 1931, leaving him in the care of family friend Chan Sing-Tan. (The invaders aren't specified, but given that the strip is set in China I can only assume that it's a reference to Japan's invasion of China in 1931.) Sheridan vows to drive out the invaders, and so as he grows he dedicates himself to learning things like science, escape artistry and jiu-jitsu. In the main plot he takes on a warlord who has kidnapped the rightful ruler of China. This is all quite generic stuff, made remarkable only because of some questionable portrayals of the Chinese characters.

'Streak Chandler on Mars' (by Harry Shorten and William Wills): Streak is captured by the Gas Men, but after a few days of slavery he overthrows their ruler and restores their rightful king. This is all done with the aid of the ultra-creepy Brontauris from last issue, a horse-headed octopus that gives me the heebie-jeebies. I want to post a picture of it, but there aren't any really good ones here. There's a good deal of imagination here, but the storytelling is so choppy that I can't enjoy it.

'Wings Johnson of the Air Patrol' (by Joe Blair and Ed Smalle): Wings Johnson is still trying to kill the German U-boat commander Von Schiller, as vengeance for the murder of his childhood friend. I swear that he has killed him at least twice so far, but the guy just keeps coming back. This time he dies again, riddled full of bullet holes. Johnson even inspects the corpse, but I don't believe it for a second. To be honest, I don't even care. Johnson has taken his vengeance so many times already that it no longer matters.

'Dick Storm in the Island of the Devil Devil Doctor' (by Harry Shorten and Mort Meskin): Dick Storm is fishing for pearls, but a member of his crew blows up their boat and flees into the jungle, intending to keep the pearls for himself. Dick pursues him, and they must both deal with the native tribesmen. It's all standard island adventure stuff.

'Bob Phantom, Scourge of the Underworld' (by Harry Shorten and Gerry Thorp): Bob Phantom foils a kidnapping plot. Not even a scene where he wrestles a pride of lions can save this.

'The West Pointer' (by Ed Wexler): This story follows on from 'The Wizard' strip earlier in the issue, in which Keith Kornell had helped that hero defeat the Mosconians. Now Keith must stop another Mosconian plot to blow up a whole load of US officials. I did like the way this dovetails out of the Wizard's story, but the rest of it is utterly generic.

'Kardak the Mystic Magician' (by C.A. Winter): Kardak helps the Fishtails to invade the supposedly villainous Mochans. Just based on this story, the Mochans never do anything particularly evil, and it seems as though the Fishtails are just attacking for the hell of it. It's not even a very exciting invasion.

Cover by Bob Kane

'The Batman Presents the Sensational Character Find of 1940.... Robin - The Boy Wonder' (by Bill Finger and Bob Kane): As that understated title may have clued you in, this is the first appearance of Robin, and it marks an instant change in tone for the strip. The story starts with Robin's origin: kid trapeze star Dick Grayson, parents murdered by racketeers, taken in and trained by Batman, you know how it goes. It's a classic origin that echoes Batman's very well. From there we go to Batman and Robin taking on Boss Zucco, the gangster in charge of the racketeers who killed Dick's parents. Batman spends a few pages smashing mobsters and wrecking a casino, and he's exceedingly polite during the whole affair, always sure to apologize before punching some crook's teeth in. We even see him smile for the first time. The skulking Batman that stuck to the shadows is gone, replaced by an adventurous swashbuckler who seems to be really enjoying his work. Robin then takes his turn, with an acrobatic battle in a construction site, where he takes on Zucco's goons before he and Batman team up to get the evidence they need to put Zucco away.

But it's not all light-hearted adventure. During his battle, Robin kicks a thug off a building, and the height of the fall leaves little doubt in my mind that the guy is killed. Batman even allows ZuccoZucco, but will happily allow another crook to be murdered in the name of gathering evidence.

This is a fun story, though. As much as I enjoyed the stories with Batman as a grim loner, I think I'm going to enjoy them more now that the focus is on action and adventure.

'Spy' (by Jerry Siegel and Maurice Kashuba): Bart takes on a mad scientist who has invented a machine that can hit targets with lightning. I quite enjoyed seeing Bart dodging lightning bolts wherever he went. I was also surprised at the end that the US Defense Department takes control of the machine. It will never be referred to again, but usually these types of machines get destroyed before anyone can get their hands on them.

'Red Logan' (by Ken Ernst): Red investigates a murder that appears to have been the work of a vampire. It's actually just a mad scientist who is trying to use the blood of the living to resurrect the dead. The premise is a good one, but it never follows through on the creepiness.

'The Crimson Avenger' (by Jack Lehti): The Crimson Avenger deals with some jewel thieves, and discovers that their victims have paid them off to steal the jewels so that they can collect the insurance money. It's a very tired plot, and telegraphed the instant that the insurance was mentioned.

'Speed Saunders Ace Investigator and the Kidnapped Singer' (by Gardner Fox and Fred Guardineer): Speed investigates the kidnapping and ransom of a singer, and discovers that the culprit is a man pretending to be her fiance. It's solid enough, and rather than Speed Saunders being the hero, that honour goes to the pilot who was flying the kidnapper's plane.

'Steve Malone, District Attorney' (by Don Lynch): Steve tackles gambling racketeers and the crooked politician who is protecting them. It's decent enough.

'Cliff Crosby' (by Chad Grothkopf): Cliff and his friend Dr. Broussard are explorers. They inexplicably find a tribe of African natives in the Arctic, who are surviving due to a serum that protects them from the cold. Cliff helps the rightful king regain control of the tribe, and along the way he fights a polar bear (breaking its jaw with his hands) and a cobra (covered in the serum as well, I guess). This is pretty crude stuff, but fun all the same.  It never does explain how those tribesmen got to the Arctic, though.

'The Case of the Vanishing Train' (by Richard Martin): A train robbery is foiled by an FBI agent. Dull.

'Slam Bradley' (by Jerry Siegel and Dennis Neville): Slam and Shorty rescue a whole bunch of people from a fire, and capture the janitor who set it deliberately. New artist Dennis Neville can't quite draw Shorty correctly, which is an essential part of the comedy for this strip. The story itself is pretty humourless, and lays the Slam Bradley hero worship on very thick. It's one of the weakest installments of this series.

Thursday, November 3, 2011

January 1940: Pep Comics #3, Top-Notch Comics #4

Cover by Irv Novick

'The Shield, G-Man Extraordinary' (by Irv Novick): Mystery planes are dropping mines into New York harbour, and the Shield investigates. Exiled munitions magnate Count Zongarr is behind the whole thing, and the Shield soon wrecks his operation in the usual two-fisted manner. At least in this one the Shield shows some vulnerability, specifically to poison gas. I was also quite struck by Count Zongarr's multiracial army; just seeing a panel of white, black and Asian soldiers standing together all on equal terms is startling for this time period. The art is also strong, as Novick shows off his story-telling chops. This is a great showing all around.

'The Comet' (by Jack Cole): The Comet is captured by his enemy from last issue, a mobster called Satan. Satan has the Comet hypnotised (by a hypnotist named Zadar) and uses him to steal loads of money, and kill a whole bunch of people in the process.  Seriously, he's blasting cops point blank in the face with his eye-beams. Eventually the bad guys turn on each other over the money, Zadar has the Comet kill Satan, and the Comet kills Zadar by accidentally leaving his visor open. Super-hero mind control stories are a dime a dozen in the modern age, but this is early days for the genre, and it follows none of the usual tropes. The Comet doesn't try to resist killing people, and he doesn't triumph through his own force of will.  It's mostly dumb luck and the treacherous nature of the villains that saves the day, which is pretty refreshing from a modern perspective.

'The Press Guardian' (by Abner Sundell and Mort Meskin): The Moronia Bund villains from last issue kidnap the daughter of the bank manager who holds the mortgage on the Daily Express, and forces him to close down the newspaper's funding. The Press Guardian (really the newspaper owner's son) rescues her in a story that has plenty of dynamic action, but not much else going for it. I was surprised to see that the girl has learned the Press Guardian's identity, though, and that it's going to have future ramifications.

'Fu Chang. International Detective' (by Joe Blair and Lin Streeter): Fu Chang goes up against Ghor, a drug kingpin. Ghor is bad news as far as villains go; he actually walks up to Fu Chang's fiancee on the street and injects her with drugs that make her his slave. And when Fu Chang rescues her later, she's completely naked under a sheet. It's all implicit, but by the time Fu Chang sends one of his magic chessmen to inject Ghor with the drug, you know he has it coming to him.

'Sergeant Boyle' (by Abner Sundell and Charles Biro): If you like to see guys punching Nazis, this is the story for you. Boyle is captured and must escape, and that's as complicated as the plot gets. His biggest obstacle comes when he runs out of grenades to throw at the German planes chasing him, and tricks one plane by throwing an apple at them. Followed by the immortal line:


I think I've just given you all the information you need to know whether you like this story.

'The Midshipman' (possibly by Bob Wood): Midshipman Lee Sampson stops some foreign agents from stealing submarine plans. It's generic and uninspired.

'The Rocket and the Queen of Diamonds' (by Abner Sundell and Lin Streeter): The Rocket and the queen decide to visit the Rocket's homeland together, but the queen's guards think she's being kidnapped and shoot their ship down. They land in a subterranean world where they are captured by "Batmen", and the Rocket spends a good few pages just killing giant spiders, turtles and snakes. It's pretty crazy stuff.

'The Shield Meets the Wizard and the Midshipman Meets the West Pointer': This is an ad for a crossover between the four characters mentioned, the first major event of its kind so far as I know. The first two participants have me kind of excited, but I don't know what the Midshipman and the West Pointer are going to contribute. Still, it ought to be very interesting.

'Kayo Ward' (by Phil Sturm): Kayo Ward is fighting Socker Benson, and a gambler named Ace Brady tries every trick in the book to get Kayo to throw the fight, even down to shooting him in the arm during the match. It's all stuff that's been done to death by this point.

'Bentley of Scotland Yard' (by Joe Blair and Sam Cooper): Bentley investigates the murder of a man who was part of a World War I unit that is planning to enlist again for World War II. The story is adequate, but made more interesting by the contemporary London setting, right in the middle of the Blitz.  It lends the story a sense of urgency it otherwise wouldn't have.

Cover by Edd Ashe

'The Wizard, the Man With the Super-Brain' (by Will Harr and Edd Ashe): The Wizard tackles Bundonian spies and stops their submarine fleet from destroying US ships. It's basically the same plot that every Wizard story has had so far, with the same scenes of him wrecking enemy soldiers and vehicles. There's a glimmer of interest when the Wizard's fiancee leaves him, and I thought it was going somewhere when she came back into the story later, but no such luck. The only really interesting thing here is that every time the Wizard uses one of his gadgets there is a blueprint showing its component parts. It's pretty nifty.



'Dick Storm in South America' (by Harry Shorten and Mort Meskin): First the country of ChilanPruvia invades, and Dick Storm helps defeat them. The opening here has absolutely nothing to do with the rest of the story, which is pretty poor.  Presumably the people of Chilan are still dying of the plague, no?

'Moore of the Mounted' (by Creators Unknown): This new strip is about Sergeant Terry Moore, a Mountie who has to track down two murderers. I was rather hoping for 'Lesse of the Mounted', and it looks as though I'll get my wish, as this is the strip's only appearance.

'The Devil is a Mule' (by Creator Unknown): Buffalo Bill Cody must deliver a message to a garrison besieged by Injuns, and fails because of his mule. Which he then promptly shoots in the head. This is just blatant anti-mule propaganda.

'Streak Chandler on Mars' (by Harry Shorten and William Wills): Streak is kidnapped by gangsters so that he can't play in a football game. Through sheer happenstance they take him to the home of a professor who has just finished building his rocket, and they force the professor to fly Streak to Mars. (Looks like he won't make it back in time for the game, which means the gangsters win!) Once on Mars, Streak is menaced by the baby-like Red Men, the bird-like Lokis, and a horse-headed octopus. I like the way this mashes up the standard sports genre story and crazy sci fi, and it is pretty crazy once they reach Mars. But the characters are bland, and there's no plot to speak of.

'Wings Johnson of the Air Patrol: Sky Raiders of the Western Front' (by Joe Blair and Ed Smalle): Wings must land in England in a stolen Nazi plane without being killed. After that he fights off some Nazi planes, then he gets caught behind enemy lines. And after all that, he finds out that his arch-enemy Von Schiller has survived yet again. A lot happens here, but it never gels into a coherent story.  And Von Schiller's continued survival is getting ridiculous at this point.

'Bob Phantom, The Scourge of the Underworld' (by Harry Shorten and Irv Novick): Bob Phantom takes on a smuggling ring that is bringing Chinese men into the USA. It's very dull, and the villain's identity (a Chinese princess) doesn't make a lot of sense.

'Stacey Knight, M.D.' (by Lin Streeter): Knight tackles a gambling ring that has fixed a boxing match by doping one of the fighters. This is really dull, and the last we ever see of Stacey Knight.

'The West Pointer' (by Ed Wexler): After Keith Kornell saves his girlfriend from drowning in icy water, he is declared unfit to play in an important basketball match. But because he is super-awesome he plays anyway and wins the game for his team before collapsing. It's the same old routine.

'Kardak the Mystic Magician' (by C.A. Winter): Kardak's girlfriend is kidnapped by fish people, as they have a prophecy that says they can only defeat their enemies if they have a white Earth Queen. Kardak helps them against their enemies, the spider-like Mocha Men. This could have been epic, but the art is stiff, and unable to convey the necessary scope.

Monday, October 10, 2011

December 1939: Top-Notch Comics #3

Cover by Edd Ashe

I recently discovered that the excellent Mike of www.dcindexes.com, the site that I use as a guide to release dates, has started listing the information for Archie. A look at the dates showed me that I'm a month out in my own estimations, so I'll be doing the December 1939 Archie books as well as the January 1940 ones to catch up. Luckily there are only three in total, because I haven't been enjoying the Archie comics thus far.

'The Wizard, the Man with the Super-Brain' (by Edd Ashe): This story is off to a bad start when it compares Blane Whitney's exploits on the polo field with his great-great-grandfather's part in the Civil War. Once he becomes the Wizard and starts smashing a plot by the fake country of Borental to blow up the Panama Canal things pick up, with some dynamic, fast-paced action scenes. But he also gets arrested for driving too fast, and for reasons unexplained he can't just tell the police that he's on the way to save the Panama Canal.  Come on, his brother is the head of naval intelligence!  The story ends with two newspaper stories, one praising the Wizard for stopping the Borentals, and the other condemning Blane Whitney for getting arrested. It's almost like a Spider-Man story in that regard, but the Wizard is far too awesome at everything for it to resonate.

'Dick Storm in China' (by Mort Meskin): Dick Storm is hired by the Chinese government to help recruit Warlord K'ang the Terrible to fight for them against a vicious invader. It's weird to see a story like this in which China is depicted as a force for law and order. But this is pretty solid stuff. Dick executes a plan that sets the invaders and K'ang at each others throats, and wraps up the story in a reasonably plausible manner.

'Bob Phantom, The Scourge of the Underworld' (by Irv Novick): Kidnappers take the son of a wealthy oilfield owner, and Bob Phantom goes to his rescue. I still can't figure out Bob Phantom's deal. He feels really out of place in his own stories, just popping up out of nowhere and displaying whatever power seems necessary at the time. If he looked cool there might be a sense of mystery about him, but as you can see he is completely ridiculous.


'Biscuits and Six-Guns' (by Creators Unknown): This prose story is about Pearl Hart, a female stagecoach robber trying to make money to send back to her baby. While I was reading this it felt more like a synopsis of events than a story, and that's because it is very loosely based on actual events. Even so, it fails as an entertaining story. You might as well read her Wikipedia entry. (Admittedly, that won't have the same level of nigh-incomprehensible cowboy speak.)

'Stacey Knight, M.D.' (by Lin Streeter): If you're a doctor in comic books, it's inevitable that at some point you will be kidnapped by gangsters to patch up their leader from a bullet wound. This is what happens to Stacey Knight, but he quickly turns the tables and has the crooks killed or arrested. He runs around carrying a tommy gun, and even shoots a crook in the face at point blank range. Surely it's all against the Hippocratic oath?

'Wings Johnson of the Air Patrol: Sky Raiders of the Western Front' (by Creators Unknown): Last issue, Johnson killed his enemy Von Schiller, and I wondered where it could go from there. The answer is much more interesting than I suspected, as Johnson goes crazy, convinced that Von Schiller is still alive. Of course he's right, as he escapes from hospital. What follows is a series of captures, escapes, and aerial dogfights, and at the end Von Schiller is really dead. Although his method of death is exactly the same as it was last time, so I have my doubts. This was actually pretty good.

'Swift of the Secret Service' (by Creators Unknown): Swift goes up against some jewel smugglers. The plot is very well worn, but the art is great. It even manages to depict an exciting car chase, something comics often have a difficult time with.

'Scott Rand on Mars' (by Otto Binder and Jack Binder): Scott and his buddy Thor go to Mars and stop the warlike Kruzzo, Ice King of Mars, from conquering the whole planet. The only enjoyment I got out of this was seeing Thor fighting aliens and being stereotypically Norse, but for the moment that's enough.

'The West Pointer' (by Ed Wexler): Keith Kornell is annoyed that his teammate Seymour is taking all the credit. But when Seymour is shot during a robbery, Keith must step up and win the Army-Navy game despite the rest of the team blaming him. This at least has a more novel premise than most sport comics, but it's still terrible. Forget car chases, I've never seen football done well in a comic.

'Manhunters' (by Jack Cole): In this true story the police hunt down a murderer and robber. This series is yet to have a compelling tale to tell, and this is no exception. It looks pretty good, though, with some very solid storytelling.

Sunday, October 2, 2011

December 1939: Pep Comics #2, Top-Notch Comics #2, Action Comics #20, More Fun Comics #51

Cover by Irv Novick

'The Shield, G-Man Extraordinary' (by Irv Novick): The Shield goes up against a fleet of "Nordic" ships that is raiding US oil rigs near Porto Rico. This is pretty bland stuff, except for one scene where the Shield beats some sharks to death with a chain. But he's still very boring, and completely immune to harm. Hell, even Superman can be hurt.  The Shield needs a weakness of some sort.

'The Comet' (by Jack Cole): In the city of Tampa, a giant devil face has been appearing in the sky, uttering threats to those who disobey it and drawing cars full of loot into the sky. The Comet investigates, and finds a gang of crooks who have set the whole thing up with blimps, magnets and projectors. The Comet uses his disintegrator eyes to destroy the blimps and end their plot. This one had an intriguing set-up and some good action, but it wasn't quite as much gonzo fun as the first chapter.

'The Press Guardian' (by Abner Sundell and Mort Meskin): The Daily Express newspaper is threatened by a Moronian bundist group, and the Press Guardian puts a stop to them. This is fairly average, but the strip has been improved greatly by switching its hero's identity from the Falcon to the Press Guardian. At the very least his costume (now a suit and mask) is much better than the weird rainbow bird outfit he had before.

'Fu Chang, International Detective' (by Joe Blair and Lin Streeter): Fu Chang is targeted by devil worshippers who are trying to take over Chinatown. They summon an actual demon, but Fu Chang's magical chessmen defeat it. I enjoyed this one, mostly because it's got a premise that is so far unique.

'Sergeant Boyle' (by Abner Sundell and Charles Biro): This is a fairly stock standard tale in which Boyle exposes a messenger who is actually a German spy. It's all fairly boring until the last page, which is an impressive double page spread of a sprawling battle scene. I think it might be the first double page spread that I've seen in this blog so far, and it certainly had the desired impact.

'When the Red Men Rode' (by Creators Unknown): This prose piece about the death of the Apache chief Geronimo is closer to non-fiction than anything else. I rather enjoyed it. Geronimo sounds like a pretty bloodthirsty character, and I'd like to read more about him. (Admittedly, this story does not have an unbiased portrayal.)

'The Midshipman' (possibly by Bob Wood): Midshipman Lee decides to put himself ahead of the Navy in an army vs. navy race. But he has to turn back to help an injured team-mate, and the race ends as a draw. Lee learns a valuable lesson about teamwork, and I learn a valuable lesson about the crapness of sport-based comics.

'The Rocket and the Queen of Diamonds' (by Abner Sundell and Lin Streeter): A villain named Retlek wants the Rocket out of  the way, so he injects him with dope and pushes him at the queen with a knife in his hand. The Rocket is thrown in the dungeon, but once the drug wears off he escapes and wrecks the bad guys. The Rocket has lost all of the humility he had last issue, and now he's just another typical Golden Age hero.

'Kayo Ward' (by Bob Wood): Kayo Ward quits boxing to please his girl, but goes back after everyone starts calling him a coward. There's a great dirty trick played by the opposing trainer, when he sends Kayo a telegram telling him that a guy he punched in the street is now dying. But apart from that little bit of subterfuge I didn't find much to enjoy here.

'Bentley of Scotland Yard' (by Sam Cooper): A man is killed by a vampire, and Bentley has three suspects - his uncle, his fiancee, and his cousin. The story stops and asks the reader to guess who is the culprit (it was the uncle, who loved the fiancee, and is also not really a vampire) but to solve it you'll need a knowledge of the properties of leech saliva. This was alright despite some slight cheating with the mystery.

Cover by Edd Ashe

'The Wizard' (by Will Harr and Ed Ashe): The army of Sybernia (a stand-in for Japan) is massing to attack Alaska, and the Wizard must hold them off single-handedly until the US fleet arrives. This involves page after page of the Wizard just tearing through troops, tanks and a battleship. I had thought he was just super-smart, but when he tore the ship's mast down I figured he's got a bit of super-strength to go with it. I was all set to give this story a pass mark based on its crazy action sequences, but it ends with the Wizard leaving a calling card that says, "Our country, right or wrong our country", which to me is just a reprehensible sentiment.  (Actually, it's not so bad now that I look at the origin and meaning of it in context.  Knee-jerk anti-patriotism retracted!)

'Scott Rand in the Worlds of Time' (by Jack Binder): Scott Rand, with his new allies Thor and Princess Elda, travel to the super-futuristic year of 2000 AD, where New York is besieged by a martian army. They help turn the tide, and I enjoyed this if only for the scene of Thor piloting a spaceship and blasting martians.

'Swift of the Secret Service' (by Creators Unknown): Swift tackles a gang of counterfeiters in a story that couldn't be more generic.

'Dick Storm in the Foreign Legion' (by Harry Shorten and Mort Meskin): Dick Storm is asked to join the Legion to ferret out some spies that are giving information to a local tribe of hostile Arabs. This is okay, but the action scenes are a bit stiff.

'Air Patrol: Sky Raiders of the Western Front' (by Joe Blair and Ed Smalle): Ben Johnson is still seeking revenge on German U-boat captain Von Schiller, and he gets his chance when the captain starts sinking Allied ships. There's a terrific full page aerial dogfight, and the conclusion is reasonably satisfying. It's hard to see where this strip can go now that Von Schiller is dead. (Although, there was no body...)

'Drum Language' (by Creators Unknown): A college graduate is sent to an island of hostile natives to replace the current person in charge of dealing with them. It's a classic "experience vs. education" set-up in which experience supposedly wins out. In truth, all it's saying is that being shockingly racist is the best way to deal with native tribesmen. Actual dialogue from our hero directed at the native chieftain: "Make one cry and ketcham bang-bang from gun! March, you imp of Satan!"

'The West Pointer' (by Ed Wexler): Keith Kornell is contacted by a spy trying to get a look at his new rifle, but foils the plan with the help of some friends. It might have worked if there was any chance at all that he would take their offer, but that sort of moral ambiguity is foreign to the Golden Age.

'Stacey Knight, M.D.' (by Lin Streeter): Stacey Knight is a doctor and a detective, which I'm sure keeps him busy. In this story, he infiltrates a gang that is smuggling dope into the USA. The story isn't particularly interesting, but it does have some decent action scenes.

'The Mystic' (by C.A. Winter): The Mystic exposes some fraudulent psychics, who send some thugs after him. I'm quite amused by the way he uses simple magicians' tricks to battle them, but the way he refers to them as "boys" in every single panel is beyond camp. Also, the Mystic has his phone set up to ring police headquarters regardless of the number that is dialled, which is absurdly impractical.

'Manhunters' (by Jack Cole): In this true story, the police track down a kidnapper and cop killer. The action scenes that bookend this are quite good, but the actual police work in the middle is beyond tedious. When even the narration is telling you it's boring, something is wrong.

Cover by Joe Shuster

'Superman' (by Siegel and Shuster): On holiday in Hollywood, Clark Kent saves starlet Dolores Winters from an assassin. He's invited to her house for an interview, but when he gets there she gives him the cold shoulder. Things get weirder when she announces her retirement, and during a yacht party kidnaps all of the stars and holds them to ransom. At this point in the story I was getting bored, but things perk up when Superman goes to the rescue and discovers that Dolores Winters is actually the Ultra-Humanite, revived from the dead and transferred into her body. One wonders what perversions drove the Ultra-Humanite to pick her body in particular. Anyway, he escapes, still in the body of Dolores Winters, so when the Ultra-Humanite inevitably returns I expect him to still be a hot girl.

'Pep Morgan' (by Gardner Fox and Fred Guardineer): Pep saves a pilot from a burning plane, and ends up becoming his co-pilot in an airshow race. A gambler spikes the pilot's drink, and Pep has to win the race and land the plane alone. Looks like Pep is back to being insufferably great at everything, except starring in good stories.

'Chuck Dawson' (by Homer Fleming): Chuck finds a dead body, and the real killers blame him. There's a shootout, but Chuck escapes and vows to deal with them later. I seriously doubt he will, given how self-contained Fleming's work has been of late.

'Clip Carson, Soldier of Fortune' (by Bill Finger and Bob Kane): Clip is still hauling a load of ivory through the jungle. Last issue he befriended some cannibals by giving them harmonicas. In this issue, after being captured by the evil Wolf Lupo, Clip asks to play his harmonica as a last request, and the cannibals come to his rescue in a fairly brutal battle. One can only assume that Wolf Lupo and his cronies are eaten by the cannibals afterwards.

'Tex Thomson and the Zombies' (by Bernard Baily): Tex and his buddies are still captives of an African tribe that tries to turn them into zombies. It turns out that salt is a cure for the zombie formula (which ties well into some zombie mythology), so Tex revives the zombie army and they all escape. It's not bad, but doesn't do a lot with the premise.

'Five Star Trap' (by Frank Thomas): A kid newspaper salesman who witnesses a murder is used to flush out the killer. It's very dull.

'Three Aces' (by Bert Christman): Gunner, Whistler and Fog come across a distress signal written in the snow. Gunner bails out and finds an old man and a girl who were shot by fur trappers. Because no planes can land in a blizzard, Gunner and the girl are forced to survive for a week in the snow, fighting off wolves with bullets and gun butts. Eventually they're rescued, and just when I was setting myself for a good survival horror story.

'Zatara the Master Magician and the Moon Men' (by Gardner Fox and Fred Guardineer): When a mysterious mist arises on coasts all over the world, killing anyone who inhales it, Zatara is led to the culprits by a winged girl named Nala. Alien Moon Men are to blame, and Zatara kills them with their own gas before unleashing deadly winged snakes on the survivors. He is very ruthless for a man in a top hat. This is tons of fun, as usual, and next issue's story promises to see him on the moon with his new winged girl ally.

Cover by Sheldon Moldoff

'Wing Brady in Paris' (by Tom Hickey): Wing and Frenchy get something of a peaceful interlude, as their section of the French Foreign Legion is in Paris to take part in the Bastille Day celebrations. As the two of them lounge around in a bar they get into a brawl with a purse snatcher, talk to a pretty American girl, then foil an ambush from the same purse snatcher. It doesn't hold together as a story at all, and it doesn't seem to be leading into anything. But despite that, I enjoyed this as a change of pace. This strip is almost always some sort of life-and-death struggle, and it's nice to see the characters get to relax once in a while.

Also, I have learned that an Apache is what they call ruffians or gangsters in Paris, and not just a Native American tribe. It would have saved me a lot of confusion if I had known that before reading this story.

'Biff Bronson' (by Al Sulman and Joseph Sulman): Biff and Dan investigate the hatchet killings of seven Chinese men, and manage through dumb luck to find the culprit: the mayor of Chinatown. The protagonists display a very unpleasant racist streak throughout this story, culminating in Dan's mocking line of dialogue: "And that goes double, my fliend!"

'King Carter' (by Paul J. Lauretta): King and Red go to a South Seas tropical island to take pictures of the volcano-worshipping natives. As is the way of things in the Golden Age, said natives are vicious savages who try to kill the interlopers, and then out of nowhere the volcano comes to life and the whole island sinks. King and Red exchange quips with the ship captain while presumably hundreds of people drown to death no more than a few hundred metres away. Luckily for this story King fights a shark with a knife, and I'm always a sucker for a good bit of shark-fightin'.

'The Buccaneer' (by Bernard Baily): This strip spends a lot of time setting up a storyline about a man found cast adrift, and his treasure map, but then it veers into an unrelated plot in which Dennis Stone must rescue his love Regina's father from the pirate Jorgens. After the rescue, Regina's father says that he will pardon Dennis and allow him to marry Regina if he gives up his life on the seas. He happily does so. This would have been a fitting end to this series if not for the superfluous treasure map stuff at the start.

The final panel of the story is a promo for the Spectre. "Who is he?? What is he??" I'm happy to see that More Fun Comics, the last DC hold-out, is finally getting its own super-hero.

'"Kit" Strong' (by Maurice Kashuba): Kit Strong is a private investigator, supposedly the "greatest manhunter of all times". In his debut story he is called in to investigate the kidnapping and ransom of a wealthy man's daughter. Having been billed as a great detective, Kit starts his clue-gathering impressively, but in the end he triumphs mainly through dumb luck and punching. Kashuba's art is cursory, and only comes alive when he's drawing women, particularly women being manhandled or tortured. I don't hold high hopes for this as a series, and luckily for me this is its only appearance.

'Gambler's Luck' (by Jack Anthony): In this prose story, Truck Farel goes after a gambler called Ace Tripone to get him to stop dating his sister. During their scuffle Ace is accidentally shot and killed. I'm really not sure what the author was going for here. Ace is presented as the bad guy, but all we ever see him do is defend himself, and on his deathbed he doesn't tell the police that Truck shot him. I've yet to see anything particularly nuanced from Jack Anthony, so I'm going to assume the straightforward approach: that Ace was a bad dude who got what was coming to him. If that's the intended story, then it's an utter failure.

'Lieutenant Bob Neal of Sub 662' (by B. Hirsch and Russ Lehman): Bob and the crew of Sub 662 find gold at the bottom of the ocean, and must mine it while avoiding foreign spies. It's fairly dull as a spy story, and the main antagonist never really gets an ending to her story.

'The Flying Fox' (by Terry Gilkison): Rex Darrell investigates the disappearance of a wealthy aviator, and finds a plot involving a gang of crooks, an island, and some buried treasure. The villain, Bayou Borg, escapes with the treasure at the end, with the dreaded To Be Continued. This would have been adequate, but the deluge of exposition at the beginning sucked all of the life out of it.  And despite the cliffhanger, this is the last we see of Rex Darrell, who I'm going to assume is killed in his attempts to capture Bayou Borg.  Given the villain's name, I expect that Darrell's corpse will be dumped in a swamp somewhere, missed by no one.

'Detective Sergeant Carey and the Wheels of Death' (by Joe Donohoe): Carey and Sleepy are called in to investigate death threats against a champion race car driver. If only they had seen that one of his rival drivers was a baron they could have solved the mystery before he got murdered.

'Sergeant O'Malley of the Red Coat Patrol' (by Jack Lehti): O'Malley goes up against a gang of gold thieves in a lacklustre story. Lehti pretty strongly establishes a realistic setting, then expects us to believe that a man thrown off a cliff can be lassoed to safety by an Indian.

'Bulldog Martin' (by Bart Tumey): Bulldog investigates a haunted house, and discovers that it's really the work of someone trying to scare off potential buyers while he looks for the treasure inside. This one pulls out all the cliches, but it does have an amusing conclusion when Bulldog tries to knock a secret door down with a sledgehammer and clobbers the crook standing behind it.

Sunday, September 11, 2011

November 1939: Pep Comics #1, Top-Notch Comics #1

Cover by Irv Novick

'The Shield, G-Man Extraordinary' (by Harry Shorten and Irv Novick): After Joe Higgins' father was killed during the infamous Black Tom explosion in World War I, he vowed to protect his country from further attacks, and designed a special suit to become the Shield. It makes him super-strong and super-fast, and basically unkillable.  He's also an FBI agent, and the first overtly patriotic super-hero. In his first outing he smashes a spy ring. I couldn't find a lot to get excited about in this story. The Shield himself is bland, and his invulnerability got annoying after a while.

'The Comet' (by Jack Cole): Scientist John Dickering discovers a gas that allows him to jump great heights when injected into his bloodstream, but it also causes his gaze to disintegrate anything he looks at (except for glass). He decides to use his power for good as the Comet, wearing a glass visor to control his eye beams, and in his first outing he takes on a gang of crooks who are distributing poison so that the beneficiaries of large insurance policies can bump of the insured party and claim the money. This one started off fairly dull as well, but around the time the Comet started disintegrating every crook in sight it got a lot more interesting. The conclusion made no sense, but the Comet himself is so ruthless that I want to see more of him.

I'm wondering now whether this story influenced the creation of Cyclops from the X-Men.  It's probably unlikely that Lee ripped it off directly, because this comic came out over 20 years before the X-Men debuted, but it's not out of the realm of possibility that the idea was subconsciously floating around in his head.

'Sergeant Boyle' (by Creators Unknown): Boyle is an American who has joined the British army. In this story he and his men get caught behind enemy lines, then kill Germans for six pages. This is the trend for Archie war comics. It's basically Nazi-killing pornography.

'The Queen of Diamonds' (by Lin Streeter): In the hidden Diamond Empire, a strange man calling himself The Rocket crash lands and is taken prisoner. Struck by the queen's beauty he submits to becoming her slave, and ends up fighting off a rebellion on her behalf. The lead character, known only as The Rocket, has a nobility and humility that is rare in the Golden Age. He also punches a lion unconscious, which is always a plus.

'Fu Chang, International Detective' (by Joe Blair and Lin Streeter): Fu Chang is a Chinese detective in San Francisco, His gimmick is that he has a set of magic chessmen that he can bring to life to aid him in his cases, which so far amounts to nothing more than sending the miniature men to spy on his suspects. In this story he goes up against a man who murdered a sailor, then framed the father of the woman he wants to marry. It's not great, but the chessmen angle is interesting.

'Murderer's Brew' (by Will Harr): In this prose story, a doctor is caught in a cabin with murderous fur thieves, and poisons them with some spiked whiskey. This isn't bad, and the twist at the end was logical and satisfying.

'Bentley of Scotland Yard' (by Maurice Gutwirth): This one starts promisingly, with Bentley saving a young heiress from a werewolf. But in the end it turns out that the werewolf is just her godfather in a costume, which is less than satisfying.

'The Press Guardian' (by Jack Binder): Ace reporter Flash Calvert is assigned to cover the robbery of a cafe. He is captured by the crooks, but rescued by the Falcon, an absurdly dressed hero. The story is dull, and the Falcon may have the worst super-hero costume yet.


'The Midshipman' (by Will Harr and Edd Ashe): Midshipman Lee Samson rescues a girl from a plane crash in the water, then ends up in a bitter rivalry with her boyfriend. It culminates in a boat race that Samson wins despite his rival smashing his boat with an oar. Normally I would hate this sort of thing, but I was surprised to see Samson collapse with exhaustion after winning the race. It's a small touch, but not the sort of thing I've seen much of in this type of comic, where the heroes are usually infallibly masculine.

'Kayo Ward' (by Phil Sturm): Eddie Ward stops a fight manager from being beaten up, and then becomes a boxer. It's not very interesting, though Ward is kind of endearingly thick.

Cover by Creators Unknown

This issue opens with a full-page ad of Rang-a-Tang the Wonder Dog fighting a giant squid. I think he's becoming my new favourite character.

'The Wizard, The Man With the Super Brain' (by Edd Ashe): The Wizard is Blane Whitney, a super genius in service to his country. His super smarts were evident from a young age, and he was brought to the attention of the president, who gave him the following contradictory advice: "You must be careful never to use it for bad, only for good... Dedicate your life, as your ancestors dedicated theirs, to the service of your country!" At this point I should mention that Blane Whitney's ancestors were all great patriots, some of whom I assume to be genuine real-life dudes (my knowledge of US history is cursory at best). After the origin story is out of the way, the Wizard uses his many gadgets and his super brain to stop agents of Jatsonia from blowing up a US submarine fleet. This isn't terrible, but the Wizard is so sickeningly brilliant at everything that I hate him completely. When the captions tell me "He is a clean cut young man, and is also popular with the ladies," that's when I mentally check out.

'Scott Rand in the Worlds of Time' (by Otto Binder and Jack Binder): Any strip that begins with a time car already in motion has got to be good. Scott Rand and Professor Meade travel back to Rome in 200 AD during a Viking attack, and save a Viking from death. Of course, in true Bill and Ted fashion, he joins their crew. Then in ancient Egypt they rescue a princess who was about to be sacrificed, and she joins as well. Then they teach the new crew members English. Then they go back to prehistoric times and blow up some dinosaurs. This is really just a string of events rather than a story, but it's still very enjoyable. I hope they just keep on picking up new crew members wherever they land.

'Swift of the Secret Service' (by Creators Unknown): Swift, a secret service agent, helps his dad investigate a murder. The killer was the victim's nephew, and also the beneficiary of his insurance payout. There's a nice bit where the killer murders his uncle with a sand-filled sock, then washes it out and wears it the next day. Aside from that, it's fairly generic stuff.

'Air Patrol: Sky Raiders of the Western Front' (by Joe Blair and Ed Smalle): Ben Johnson is an RAF pilot seeking vengeance against a German U-Boat captain for the murder of his childhood friend, in what may very well be the most implausible origin story I've ever seen. Seriously, Ben and his friend Jack are fishing in a schooner when a German submarine just happens to surface and shoot Jack for no reason. It's absurd. The rest of the story is fairly poorly executed aerial dogfight, and Ben still hasn't caught Von Schiller at the end.

'Murder Rap' (by Ken Fitch): Police detective "Lucky" Coyne rescues a woman from racketeers. This is loaded with action, but the characters don't explain why they're doing anything until the very end. Sometimes that can work, but it didn't here.

'Lucky Coyne, Undercover Man' (by Ken Fitch): Okay, so Lucky Coyne is in the comics as well. In this story, he and his female partner infiltrate a gang of jewel thieves. The story doesn't identify them at first, and the fact that they are undercover agents is presented as a twist ending. It's at least a little more experimental than most other Golden Age stories, but it doesn't have much else to offer.

'The Mystic' (by C.A. Winter): The Mystic is a crime-fighting stage magician. In this story, a gang of racketeers seeks revenge on him. They throw the Mystic and his fiancee into the river in a coffin, and he escapes. And that's it. The crooks get away, and are not dealt with. It's a very unsatisfying conclusion. The Mystic himself has no special powers; he really is just a stage magician.

'The West Pointer' (by Ed Wexler): Keith Kornell grows up in poverty, but because he is awesome at everything, he becomes a cadet at West Point. After a training montage, he gets in a fight with an upperclassman and wins his respect by punching him a lot. I struggle to think why I'd ever be interested in reading about cadets.

'Manhunters' (by Jack Cole): This is another series by Jack Cole about true crime stories. Here the focus is on the scientific techniques used to capture some crooks who are forging checks. I have zero interest in this sort of thing.