Showing posts with label Detective Comics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Detective Comics. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 25, 2012

July 1940: Detective Comics #42

Cover by Bob Kane

'Batman' (by Bill Finger and Bob Kane): Batman investigates a case in which portraits are being altered in such a way that predicts the murder of their owners. It turns out to be the work of a guy trying to drive up the price of the paintings. It's not the most original of motivations, but he does wear an awesome skull mask/beret ensemble to liven things up. And Bruce Wayne's feigned vanity when he goes to get his own portrait painted is hilarious.

In other stories:

In 'Spy' (by Jerry Siegel and Maurice Kashuba) Bart Regan helps track down the thief who stole the plans to a new gas mask. 'Red Logan, Ace Reporter' (by Ed Winiarski) exposes a jewellery store owner who is reporting his goods stolen, collecting the insurance, then re-cutting the gems and selling them in the store. 'The Crimson Avenger' (by Jack Lehti) beats up a gang of red-robed cultists intent on world domination. 'Speed Saunders, Ace Investigator' (by Fred Guardineer) deals with a pyromaniac. 'Steve Malone, District Attorney' (by Don Lynch) solves the murder of a newspaperman killed by protection racketeers. 'Cliff Crosby' (by Chad Grothkopf) tackles the Chinese people smuggling racket.  And 'Slam Bradley' (by Jerry Siegel and Howard Sherman) stops a gang of jewel thieves from discrediting his friend officer Callahan.

Thursday, April 12, 2012

June 1940: Detective Comics #41

 Cover by Bob Kane

'Batman with Robin the Boy Wonder' (by Bill Finger and Bob Kane): It's another story with Robin as the star, as he's enrolled in a school to investigate a string of murders. It's set up well, and ticks all the boxes in the conclusion; this is a mystery that plays fair. Even so, I kept wishing for more Batman. Robin has taken over the strip at this point. I wonder if there were kids in 1940 yearning for the Robin-less glory days of just a few months ago?

'Spy' (by Jerry Siegel and Maurice Kashuba): Bart puts a stop to a US military clerk who is selling secret plans to foreign spies. Straightforward and dull.

'Red Logan' (by Ed Winiarski): Criminal Bugsie Goron is sentenced to death, but vows to come back and kill the judge and jury. He's killed, but he has a twin brother that that starts killing disguised as his brother's ghost. The potential is there, but the execution is lacking in excitement.

'The Crimson Avenger' (by Jack Lehti): The Crimson Avengers smashes a ring of people smugglers. It's pretty dull.

'Speed Saunders Ace Investigator and the Railroad Mystery' (by Fred Guardineer): Speed investigates the murder of a telegraph operator, and finds that it is the work of a gang of train saboteurs. Speed certainly enjoys beating the hell out of them, but his exuberance is the only thing of note in this story.

'Theft at the Fair' (by Gardner Fox): This prose story is continued from last issue, but to be honest the first chapter was superfluous. It's about a jewel thief, who is caught because of some curious notion that a real workman never strikes a match on the bottom of his shoe. And if he's not a real workman, by golly he must be a crook! It's a hell of a logical leap, regardless of whether it works.

'Steve Malone, District Attorney' (by Don Lynch): An expert on Incan history and relics murders an academic who has been debunking theories about the Incas. Steve investigates, and catches the killer, and there's not much else to say. This really is a boring issue of Detective Comics.

'Cliff Crosby' (by Chad Grothkopf): Cliff tackles the Invisible Man, a spy who is trying to steal an experimental submarine. Again this is very dull, and the villain's plan doesn't make much sense. I still can't figure out why he was posing as a scientist and working with Cliff.

'Slam Bradley' (by Jerry Siegel and Howard Sherman): Slam helps an heiress who is being swindled and threatened with murder by her guardian. It's a solid enough story, but it's completely lacking in the elements that made Slam Bradley great. Shorty is completely sidelined, there's no humour, and the action scenes are pedestrian. It's very disappointing.

Monday, February 27, 2012

May 1940: Detective Comics #40

Cover by Bob Kane

'Batman, with Robin the Boy Wonder' (by Bill Finger and Bob Kane): There's a murder on the set of a movie that Bruce Wayne's fiancee is starring in, and Batman must solve the case. This story gets off on the right foot by providing a whole bunch of suspects. There's a racketeer trying to collect money from the director. There's the jilted lover of an actress. There's an unreliable director who was fired from the job. But the actual culprit turns out to be none other than Clayface, a name that Bat-fans may recognise. This isn't the shape-shifting mud monster of later Bat-lore. This is Basil Karlo, an old-time character actor who is incensed that a remake of one of his old movies is being made. He disguises his face with thick clay make-up, thus the moniker. He's a relatively compelling character, but I don't think he has much potential for a comeback story.

'Spy' (by Jerry Siegel and Maurice Kashuba): Bart investigates the Forgarian embassy, and gets caught up in a plot involving pens with secret messages inside, that give the location of stolen US military documents held in a bank deposit box. The pen mystery is just intriguing enough to drag this above mediocrity.

'Red Logan' (by Ken Ernst): Red and Ivan infiltrate a London boarding house that is a front for a spy ring. It's an average story, but at least Ivan is a fun character. Horribly accented, but still fun.

'The Crimson Avenger' (by Jack Lehti): The Crimson Avenger takes on a mad scientist who is using a paralysis gun to aid in bank robbery. It doesn't get much more straightforward than this, or more dull.

'Speed Saunders, Ace Investigator and the Jewel Robbers' (by Fred Guardineer): I was all set for a hackneyed jewel thief story, of the sort I've read by the hundreds. I read in boredom as Speed witnessed a robbery and jumped on the back of the getaway car, but my interest picked up when the crooks did a smart thing, and took a sharp turn near a cliff. Speed is thrown down almost to his death, and spends the rest of the story going after the crooks for revenge. It really is just another hackneyed jewel thief story, but Speed's personal motivations make it much more interesting.

'Theft at the Fair' (by Gardner Fox): Repairs are being done on the House of Jewels at the New York World's Fair, and the foreman is worried that a jewel thief might steal the jewels. It's a set-up for the continuation next issue, but as established I am mightily sick of jewel thief stories.

'Steve Malone, District Attorney' (by Don Lynch): Steve investigates the kidnapping of a boy violinist, and discovers a whole bunch of musicians that have been taken for the amusement of a man named Fuhlra. His lieutenant is a snake charmer, and Steve must deal with her and her cobras. The added snake craziness puts this ahead of the usual kidnapping stories, but only barely.

'Cliff Crosby' (by Chad Grothkopf): Cliff is testing an experimental plane, while rival interests try to destroy it. It's another potentially dull story, but the inclusion of a shark fight and some plane-to-plane acrobatics from Cliff provide some entertainment.

'Slam Bradley' (by Jerry Siegel and Howard Sherman): Slam witnesses a murder, and becomes a target for the crooks responsible. The humour and action are both quite subdued, though there is a scene where Slam fights a pack of ravenous dogs in a pit. It's not enough to save a pretty average story. I also don't care for Sherman's pencils; he has a hard time drawing Shorty, something that's integral to the comedy element of the strip.

Monday, January 23, 2012

April 1940: Detective Comics #39

Cover by Bob Kane

'Batman' (by Bill Finger and Bob Kane): A Chinese tong kidnaps two millionaires and holds them for ransom. It's also been selling opium, and Chinatown's unofficial mayor Wong calls Batman in to deal with the problem. Wong appeared once before in Detective Comics #35, where he helped Batman, but his return is an ill-fated one; he ends up being murdered with a hatchet buried in his head. Batman and Robin track the tong down to its waterfront hideout, and solve the case with a whole lot of punching. It's all topped off by a great closing scene, in which a young Chinese boy is told by his mother to pray for Batman, who delivered them from the evils of opium. This is seriously entertaining stuff.

There's more significant Batman stuff on the way. In the next issue of Detective Comics we get the debut of the villain Clayface, and there's also a house ad for Batman #1. Good times!

'Spy' (by Jerry Siegel and Maurice Kashuba): Bart is assigned to discover who is stealing papers from an inventor who has just created a top secret weapon. All evidence points to Carlgart, the office manager, and Thorpe, a shifty-eyed draftsman, but in the end the culprit turns out to be the inventor's chauffeur. It almost makes sense, except that it's never explained how the chauffeur gets into the inventor's safe. And the sheer amount of evidence piled up against Carlgart and Thorpe isn't adequately explained away either. I can see what Siegel was going for here, but those two were just acting too shiftily for them to not be up to something.

'Red Logan' (by Ken Ernst): Red Logan tackles a man who is trying to kill his niece before she gets married, so that the family inheritance will remain with him. His method is to release a cobra into her room, but after she screams the cobra returns to the man's room and kills him. I'm not entirely sure that Red accomplished anything at all in this story.

'The Crimson Avenger' (by Jack Lehti): The Crimson Avenger tackles a group of spies who destroyed a battleship in the New York harbour with some mines. The mines were placed there during World War I, and are remotely detonated from a top secret control room; the story spends a lot of its time setting up the mystery of exactly how the spies did it. The resolution is a good one, with all of the relevant clues available to the reader, and this is a very solid story that makes good use of the Crimson Avenger's super-hero identity as well as his job at the newspaper.

'Speed Saunders, Ace Investigator and the Case of the Siva Statue' (by Fred Guardineer): Speed helps a man who has been threatened by a cult for his possession of a sacred Siva statuette. The story is unremarkable. The most interesting thing about it is the introduction of Danny, a kid who Speed uses to help him track the cult down. Apparently he's going to be a regular cast member, which doesn't bode well. Kid sidekicks so very rarely work, and this one's as bland as they come. Also, the presumably Indian cultists all have blue skin for some reason.

'Steve Malone, District Attorney' (by Don Lynch): Steve tackles a gang of hijackers who are stealing cargo trucks and selling the goods through a wholesaler. Steve manages to hold them off in a tense shootout, but all of his success happens through lucky coincidence.

'Cliff Crosby' (by Chad Grothkopf): This story begins with Cliff Crosby angrily campaigning for kids to be able to play on vacant lots, and it only gets more absurd from there. The son of Al Larsen, the main guy who is against the playing kids, is kidnapped and held by Indians. Cliff goes to the kid's rescue, and their escape attempt has all of the jungle cliches: an alligator, a boa constrictor, quicksand, you name it. After the kid is rescued Larsen agrees to build playgrounds, and everyone is happy. Crosby is quite entertaining in this, as his first answer to any problem is a swift punch in the face. And the jungle scenes are gloriously cliched, but so rapid-fire they get away with it.

'White Trap' (by Whitney Ellsworth): A criminal commits a murder, but his escape plan is thwarted by a snowstorm; the footprints he leaves will lead right to him, so he gives himself up. It's quite a clever story, but I can't help thinking that he gives up too easily. Surely he could just walk to where there's a crowd, and obscure his footprints that way?

'Slam Bradley' (by Jerry Siegel and Dennis Neville): Slam is hired by a Frenchman to protect a valuable diamond from some crooks. It all turns out to be a hoax, to test Slam's competence for the French government, which wants to hire him to protect a shipment of gems in Paris. Slam ends up getting captured and impersonated by a gang of thieves, but manages to escape, clear his name and defeat them. This was all mildly entertaining, with some good banter from Slam and Shorty, but it falls short of the mark compared to other Slam Bradley stories. At least Dennis Neville has figured out how to draw Shorty now.

Sunday, December 4, 2011

March 1940: Top-Notch Comics #5, Detective Comics #38

 Cover by Edd Ashe

'The Wizard, The Man With the Super-Brain' (by Edd Ashe): It's crossover central again, as the Wizard battles Mosconian agents while meeting the Shield, Keith Kornell (aka the West Pointer) and Lee Sampson (aka the Midshipman). To be honest, these cameos add nothing to the story. The Shield was utterly superfluous, and the other two could just as easily have been any random cadet or member of the navy. Even so, it's a good bit of fun.

'Galahad' (by Harry Shorten and Lin Streeter): This new strip features the titular knight of the Round Table. Galahad goes to King Arthur's court and is made a knight after defeating Sir Kay in a joust. Soon after he helps Lady Lynette stop the evil Sir Gilbert from seizing her lands. I am a sucker for any thing with a sword in it, and this does have a pretty good fight scene between Galahad and Gilbert. But in the end that's all it comes down to, and Galahad triumphs through his prowess and nothing more. I expect something a little more meaningful from a story drawing on the Arthurian mythos.

'Shanghai Sheridan' (by Joe Blair and Irv Novick): Jack Sheridan's father was killed by invaders in 1931, leaving him in the care of family friend Chan Sing-Tan. (The invaders aren't specified, but given that the strip is set in China I can only assume that it's a reference to Japan's invasion of China in 1931.) Sheridan vows to drive out the invaders, and so as he grows he dedicates himself to learning things like science, escape artistry and jiu-jitsu. In the main plot he takes on a warlord who has kidnapped the rightful ruler of China. This is all quite generic stuff, made remarkable only because of some questionable portrayals of the Chinese characters.

'Streak Chandler on Mars' (by Harry Shorten and William Wills): Streak is captured by the Gas Men, but after a few days of slavery he overthrows their ruler and restores their rightful king. This is all done with the aid of the ultra-creepy Brontauris from last issue, a horse-headed octopus that gives me the heebie-jeebies. I want to post a picture of it, but there aren't any really good ones here. There's a good deal of imagination here, but the storytelling is so choppy that I can't enjoy it.

'Wings Johnson of the Air Patrol' (by Joe Blair and Ed Smalle): Wings Johnson is still trying to kill the German U-boat commander Von Schiller, as vengeance for the murder of his childhood friend. I swear that he has killed him at least twice so far, but the guy just keeps coming back. This time he dies again, riddled full of bullet holes. Johnson even inspects the corpse, but I don't believe it for a second. To be honest, I don't even care. Johnson has taken his vengeance so many times already that it no longer matters.

'Dick Storm in the Island of the Devil Devil Doctor' (by Harry Shorten and Mort Meskin): Dick Storm is fishing for pearls, but a member of his crew blows up their boat and flees into the jungle, intending to keep the pearls for himself. Dick pursues him, and they must both deal with the native tribesmen. It's all standard island adventure stuff.

'Bob Phantom, Scourge of the Underworld' (by Harry Shorten and Gerry Thorp): Bob Phantom foils a kidnapping plot. Not even a scene where he wrestles a pride of lions can save this.

'The West Pointer' (by Ed Wexler): This story follows on from 'The Wizard' strip earlier in the issue, in which Keith Kornell had helped that hero defeat the Mosconians. Now Keith must stop another Mosconian plot to blow up a whole load of US officials. I did like the way this dovetails out of the Wizard's story, but the rest of it is utterly generic.

'Kardak the Mystic Magician' (by C.A. Winter): Kardak helps the Fishtails to invade the supposedly villainous Mochans. Just based on this story, the Mochans never do anything particularly evil, and it seems as though the Fishtails are just attacking for the hell of it. It's not even a very exciting invasion.

Cover by Bob Kane

'The Batman Presents the Sensational Character Find of 1940.... Robin - The Boy Wonder' (by Bill Finger and Bob Kane): As that understated title may have clued you in, this is the first appearance of Robin, and it marks an instant change in tone for the strip. The story starts with Robin's origin: kid trapeze star Dick Grayson, parents murdered by racketeers, taken in and trained by Batman, you know how it goes. It's a classic origin that echoes Batman's very well. From there we go to Batman and Robin taking on Boss Zucco, the gangster in charge of the racketeers who killed Dick's parents. Batman spends a few pages smashing mobsters and wrecking a casino, and he's exceedingly polite during the whole affair, always sure to apologize before punching some crook's teeth in. We even see him smile for the first time. The skulking Batman that stuck to the shadows is gone, replaced by an adventurous swashbuckler who seems to be really enjoying his work. Robin then takes his turn, with an acrobatic battle in a construction site, where he takes on Zucco's goons before he and Batman team up to get the evidence they need to put Zucco away.

But it's not all light-hearted adventure. During his battle, Robin kicks a thug off a building, and the height of the fall leaves little doubt in my mind that the guy is killed. Batman even allows ZuccoZucco, but will happily allow another crook to be murdered in the name of gathering evidence.

This is a fun story, though. As much as I enjoyed the stories with Batman as a grim loner, I think I'm going to enjoy them more now that the focus is on action and adventure.

'Spy' (by Jerry Siegel and Maurice Kashuba): Bart takes on a mad scientist who has invented a machine that can hit targets with lightning. I quite enjoyed seeing Bart dodging lightning bolts wherever he went. I was also surprised at the end that the US Defense Department takes control of the machine. It will never be referred to again, but usually these types of machines get destroyed before anyone can get their hands on them.

'Red Logan' (by Ken Ernst): Red investigates a murder that appears to have been the work of a vampire. It's actually just a mad scientist who is trying to use the blood of the living to resurrect the dead. The premise is a good one, but it never follows through on the creepiness.

'The Crimson Avenger' (by Jack Lehti): The Crimson Avenger deals with some jewel thieves, and discovers that their victims have paid them off to steal the jewels so that they can collect the insurance money. It's a very tired plot, and telegraphed the instant that the insurance was mentioned.

'Speed Saunders Ace Investigator and the Kidnapped Singer' (by Gardner Fox and Fred Guardineer): Speed investigates the kidnapping and ransom of a singer, and discovers that the culprit is a man pretending to be her fiance. It's solid enough, and rather than Speed Saunders being the hero, that honour goes to the pilot who was flying the kidnapper's plane.

'Steve Malone, District Attorney' (by Don Lynch): Steve tackles gambling racketeers and the crooked politician who is protecting them. It's decent enough.

'Cliff Crosby' (by Chad Grothkopf): Cliff and his friend Dr. Broussard are explorers. They inexplicably find a tribe of African natives in the Arctic, who are surviving due to a serum that protects them from the cold. Cliff helps the rightful king regain control of the tribe, and along the way he fights a polar bear (breaking its jaw with his hands) and a cobra (covered in the serum as well, I guess). This is pretty crude stuff, but fun all the same.  It never does explain how those tribesmen got to the Arctic, though.

'The Case of the Vanishing Train' (by Richard Martin): A train robbery is foiled by an FBI agent. Dull.

'Slam Bradley' (by Jerry Siegel and Dennis Neville): Slam and Shorty rescue a whole bunch of people from a fire, and capture the janitor who set it deliberately. New artist Dennis Neville can't quite draw Shorty correctly, which is an essential part of the comedy for this strip. The story itself is pretty humourless, and lays the Slam Bradley hero worship on very thick. It's one of the weakest installments of this series.

Sunday, November 6, 2011

February 1940: More Fun Comics #53, Detective Comics #37

Cover by Bernard Baily

I wasn't able to find a copy of this, aside from a reprint of the Spectre story, so that's all I can write about. 

'The Spectre' (by Jerry Siegel and Bernard Baily): Continuing from last issue, Jim Corrigan has returned from the dead to battle crime with his supernatural powers. In this story he must rescue his fiancee from the crooks who killed him. This is fantastically eerie stuff. Jim kills one of the crooks just by looking at him, and makes another's flesh fall away from his skeleton with a touch. And even though the crooks are dealt with easily, Jim is still little more than a ghost, and must leave his fiancee forever. This is very good stuff, spooky and tragic. The art lets it down here and there, but overall it's still effective.

Cover by Bob Kane

'Batman' (by Bill Finger and Bob Kane): Batman goes up against foreign agents in this story, which never quite feels right. From the opening where Batman has gotten lost while driving around, to the numerous instances if him being bashed on the head from behind, he doesn't feel like the same character. And I feel like the tone has shifted from what has come before, in a way that I can't quite pinpoint. It's not a terrible story by any means, but there's something off about it that I can't quite put my finger on.

'Spy' (by Jerry Siegel and Maurice Kashuba): Bart takes on Ligoni, leader of the "Ring of Death", who has just bombed some government officials. This is a solid story of Bart going undercover, even though it doesn't stray from the usual formula.  It's a solid rendition of a familiar routine.

'Cosmo, the Phantom of Disguise' (by Sven Elven): Cosmo must stop a plot to hijack a  ship en route to England and sell it to an enemy nation. Part of his plan involves faking an explosion so that the ship will be evacuated, but I'm still wondering how that was done without crippling the ship as well. The story itself certainly has no explanation for me.

'The Crimson Avenger' (possibly by Jim Chambers and Harry Lucey): The Crimson Avenger is back, after a lengthy absence.  He hasn't been seen since Detective Comics #29! Very little effort is made to reintroduce the character, but I don't think it would be too hard to pick things up. In this story he tackles some kidnappers, which is a fairly dull starting point. Their ringleader ends up being a guy named J.N. Worthy, which seems fair enough, except for the scene where he seems surprised to be getting a note from the kidnappers. There's no reason he'd do so while alone in his own office.  It's just a cheap ploy to obscure the identity of the villain.

'Murder at Sea' (by John Randall): In this prose story, a professor is murdered and his secret plans are stolen. A boy named Billy figures out that the steward did it; his alibi was that he was writing a note at the time of the murder, but the note is too neat to have been written on the ship. It's just clever enough to work, but it's in the much-loathed "kids stop crooks" category, which is something I really hate.

'Speed Saunders, Ace Investigator and the Crime Roundup' (by Gardner Fox and Fred Guardineer): Speed is framed by crooks as a drunk, doused with whiskey and thrown in an alley. He's quickly demoted, but sets about getting his job back by starting a one-man war on crime. Normally I'm a sucker for this kind of thing, one guy just going around town and busting up every crook he finds, from the lowest to the highest. But this one just wraps up too neatly. It's the sort of story that works really well when it's drawn out and the crooks get their chance to retaliate, but here they just get rounded up, put on trial and sent to jail.

'Steve Malone, District Attorney' (by Don Lynch): This is a stock standard story about a kidnapping plot, where Steve goes to the rescue and saves the day, ticking all the cliche boxes as he goes. But there's an actual rape attempt by one of the kidnappers on their victim, which is definitely something that hasn't been done in DC comics to this point. It's all pretty PG in the way it's presented, but the intent is obvious. There's something to be said for this as a nod to realism, but it's not something I want to see in every story from now on.

'Cliff Crosby' (by Chad Grothkopf): This is a new strip. Cliff Crosby is friends with a reporter, and to be honest I'm not sure what it is that Cliff does. In this story, he and his friend get a lead on a missing judge, and find that he is being sold by a slave ring in South America. Cliff gets captured himself, saves the judge when he is thrown to a giant octopus, then wears the octopus on his head to frighten the slavers. It's not good, and the art is some of the worst I've seen. There are good panels here and there, but in every fight scene the perspective and scale are completely off. And Crosby has the world's tiniest arms.



'Slam Bradley' (by Jerry Siegel and Mart Bailey): Slam and Shorty are left a horse named Dynamite in a wealthy man's will, and before too long they have it racing in the Kentucky Derby. The usual shenanigans ensue, with crooked gamblers taking an interest, and of course Shorty ends up having to ride the horse in the derby. The plot elements here are as hackneyed as any other horse racing story, but the difference is in the presentation. Slam Bradley's stories are always laced with a knowing humour that raises them above the pack.

Thursday, October 13, 2011

January 1940: Detective Comics #36

Cover by Bob Kane

'Batman' (by Bill Finger and Bob Kane): Batman goes up against Hugo Strange, a "scientist, philosopher and criminal genius".  Strange has built a machine with which he can blanket the city in fog, and under the cover of that fog his army of crooks loot everything in sight. Batman tracks them down, and beats the lot of them in a pretty well done multi-page fight scene. Kane is still the only guy doing fight scenes like this, and here it works to good effect. There's a particularly impressive panel of Batman bowling over some crooks, that shows a level of dynamism not often seen in this era.

I liked this one.  It had an interesting villain, great atmosphere with the fog-drenched city-scapes, and a really good fight scene.

'Spy' (by Jerry Siegel and Maurice Kashuba): I don't have the first page of this story, but from what I gather Bart must protect a US freighter from foreign spies. It does have a scene where he fights a spy who has dynamite strapped to his back, but otherwise this is an average story.

'Buck Marshall, Range Detective' (by Homer Fleming): Buck Marshall must clear the name of a man who has been framed for murder, and is scheduled to be hanged. This is actually a pretty solid story, even though it ends on an anticlimax when the final confrontation with the real culprits lasts for a single panel.

'Steve Malone, District Attorney' (by Don Lynch): Steve is on the trail of Rocky Roman, a wanted murderer. He tracks him down, and the story climaxes with a rooftop shootout and fist-fight. This isn't the most interesting story, but at least it makes an effort to liven up the action sequences.

'Speed Saunders Ace Investigator and the Spider' (by Gardner Fox and Fred Guardineer): Speed is on the trail of the Spider, a renowned jewel thief. It turns out that the Spider is actually a woman masquerading as a man, in a fairly implausible plot twist.

'Cosmo, the Phantom of Disguise' (by Sven Elven): How do you make Cosmo even more boring than usual? Send him out west to tackle a gang of cattle rustlers! It was a neat touch when Cosmo admitted he would make a crappy cowboy, because Golden Age heroes are usually super-competent at everything, but other than that this was a snoozer.

'A Climax in Opera' (by Richard Martin): An jewel thief steals a whole bunch of gems, and a detective tracks him down in the theatre because he knows that he is obsessed with the opera. I was all set to dismiss this one, until the final line, where the jewel thief's only regret is that the detective didn't allow him to see the third act of "Carmen". Class.

'Bruce Nelson' (by Tom Hickey): Bruce Nelson investigates a murder at a wealthy socialite's ski party. This was shaping up well, with a few legitimate suspects, until the end when Bruce just bluffed his way into finding the culprit then dumped a whole load of exposition explaining what happened. I think this would have worked better as a two-parter.

'Slam Bradley' (by Jerry Siegel and Mart Bailey): Slam and Shorty go to China, where they are hired by the Lan Chee Tong to retrieve a sacred idol. This one is uncharacteristically humourless, but it's still not bad as a straight action story.

Monday, October 3, 2011

December 1939: Detective Comics #35

Cover by Bob Kane

'The Batman' (by Bill Finger and Bob Kane): Batman gets caught up in machinations involving a sacred ruby idol of the Hindu god "Kila" (I assume this is supposed to be Kali). The idol is seemingly wanted by Hindu priests, crooked gangsters, and a Chinese crime lord named Sin Fang. Batman's raid on Sin Fang's hideout is quite amusing, as they very politely play cat and mouse games with each other, Sin Fang pretending that every deathtrap is an accident, and Batman going along with each ruse. As usual there are some unpleasant undertones when non-Caucasian villains are used, but this was quite fast-paced and enjoyable.



Gun Watch: Batman is holding a smoking gun on the title page, but never uses one during the story.

'Spy' (by Jerry Siegel and Maurice Kashuba): Bart infiltrates a submarine from the fake country of Luxor, which is blowing up cruise ships from the equally fake Boralia. The story ends in unsatisfying fashion when Bart is saved by a Boralian spy who comes into the story with no prior warning. The most notable thing here is that the strip has a new artist, Maurice Kashuba. His work has a similar tone to that of the previous artist, Mart Bailey, but his use of shadows gives it a more foreboding atmosphere.

'Buck Marshall, Range Detective' (by Homer Fleming): Buck stages a fake robbery on a stage coach before the "hooded gang" can get there, then spends the rest of the strip exposing their identities as respectable men of the community. This is quite good for a Golden Age western.

'Steve Malone, District Attorney in The Kidnapping Racket' (by Gardner Fox and Don Lynch): Steve investigates a gang that is involved in kidnapping, as well as a retailing protection racket. He hires private detectives to start up their own racket and infiltrate the crooks, and his plan goes off without a hitch. It's a solid "I love it when a plan comes together" type story, so long as you can stomach the good guys winning with no trouble at all.

'Mystery With Music' (by Richard Lawlor): In this prose story, a thief turns out the lights in a cabaret nightclub, steals a necklace, and tries to hide it in a musician's trombone case. It's pretty lifeless.

'Speed Saunders Ace Investigator and the Voodoo Vengeance' (by Fred Guardineer): Speed Saunders goes after the Snake Master, chief of a Cuban voodoo tribe, and killer of the dancer Rhumba Rita. There's not much of interest in this story, besides a hilarious panel of Speed Saunders shooting a snake's head off.

'Cosmo, the Phantom of Disguise' (by Sven Elven): Cosmo's old enemy Gaston Dupre fakes his death to escape from prison and Cosmo tracks him down. I quite liked this one, it had a nice sense of tension during the series of deathtraps that Cosmo must navigate.

'Bruce Nelson' (by Tom Hickey): Continuing from last issue, Bruce has escaped with the White Goddess, and her native captors are in hot pursuit. Most of the strip is a chase through the jungle, followed by a dose of exposition as the White Goddess explains her story. It's livened up by some very good art, and a couple of large action shots that are quite impressive.

'Slam Bradley' (by Jerry Siegel and Mart Bailey): Slam and Shorty enlist in the French Foreign Legion to track down two murderers. This is another in a long line of cracking, humorous adventure stories. It's almost brought low at the end, when Slam is saved by a commander who just happens to be his biggest fan. But it works because it's played for laughs, and the rest of the strip is enough fun that it doesn't matter.

Sunday, September 11, 2011

November 1939: More Fun Comics #50, Detective Comics #34, Adventure Comics #45

Cover by Fred Guardineer


Hey look, a milestone! I'd love to be able to say that I have read the first fifty issues of More Fun Comics, but in terms of availability this is the hardest of the DC Golden Age titles to get a hold of.  Even so, I'd say I'm ahead of 99.9999999% of the world's population in terms of issues of More Fun Comics read (or is that endured?).  It's something to be proud of.

'Wing Brady' (by Tom Hickey): Wing's unit is posted in the most inhospitable fort of the Foreign Legion. When Arabs cut off their relief force in an effort to starve the legion out, he must gather his men and ride to the rescue. Good old Wing Brady, you can always really on him for a solid start to this comic.

'Biff Bronson' (by Al Sulman and Joseph Sulman): Biff and Dan go up against a crazy wax museum owner known as the Mastermind, who is using actual corpses as his wax statues. This is good for a Bronson story, though I'm not particularly optimistic about the hinted return of the Mastermind.

'King Carter' (by Paul J. Lauretta): When Carter's friend Red is run over by a local tyrant prince, Carter seeks revenge. It turns out that the prince is planning to overthrow British rule, and in the course of fighting him Carter is sealed behind a brick wall, chased by a tiger, and menaced by cobras. The non-stop action is fun, but it's hard to overlook the bit where Carter refers to the prince's henchmen as monkeys.

'The Buccaneer' (by Bernard Baily): Dennis Stone is still helping the prince of Natria prepare to oust his usurper. This is mostly set-up, but it's effectively done.

'Radio Squad' (by Jerry Siegel and Mart Bailey): Sandy and Larry tackle a gang of car thieves. It's a decent story, and I liked the scenes of the two mocking their chief and his absurdly high requirements.

'Anything for a Story' (by Terry Keane): In this prose piece a reporter in desperate need of a story tracks down an escaped convict who is hiding out in the country. It's okay, and the end is quite satisfying.

'Lieut. Bob Neal in Peril' (by Bob Hirsch and Russ Lehman): Bob and his crew test out an underwater drill and a device that can turn water into oxygen. There are lots of complications, but it's hard to get excited over some testing.

'The Magic Crystal of History' (by Homer Fleming): This installment tells the story of Peter the Great, one of Russia's earliest rulers. It's starting to degenerate again into a flood of names and genealogies, but Peter's willingness to work as a peasant at the end is a humanising touch. This strip would benefit greatly if Fleming treated the people in it as characters.  But it's too late for that, because this is the last installment.  This strip has been running since issue #1, the very first comic DC ever published.  But I have no special attachment to it, so allow me to heartily declare: "Good riddance, Magic Crystal of History!"

'The Flying Fox' (by Terry Gilkison): The Flying Fox seems to have finally captured the leader of the air pirates this issue, but I thought the same thing last time. It's hard to keep this stuff straight when the strip is so uninteresting.

'Detective Sergeant Carey and the Avenging Ghost' (by Joe Donohoe): Carey investigates the murders of some jurymen, who are being killed by the father of a man they sent to the chair. It has a solid plot, and is therefore streaks ahead of Carey's usual output.

'Sergeant O'Malley of the Red Coat Patrol' (by Jack Lehti): O'Malley deals with a guy who is setting fire to his own land to collect the insurance.  It has too many mounties.

'Bulldog Martin' (by Bart Tumey): Bulldog and his black sidekick Jonah take on a gang trying to raid Switzerland's gold reserves. The only thing of note in this story is Jonah's outrageous speech patterns, and they're nothing to be proud of.

Cover by Creig Flessel

'Batman' (by Gardner Fox, Bob Kane and Sheldon Moldoff): Still in Europe following his adventure with the Monk, Batman goes up against the Duc D'orterre, a mad French scientist who has used a ray to burn the face off of the brother of a woman (named Karel) who scorned him. This is a solid story, spiced up with some unexplained weirdness. I don't know why the Duc has a garden full of flowers that have faces, and the story isn't helping me either. But it's a memorable scene.

The only thing I didn't like is some nonsense with Batman's secret identity. He meets the girl Karel as Bruce Wayne, and after hearing her story he leaves the room and returns five seconds later as Batman. That Karel and her brother don't know his identity instantly is stretching the bounds of credibility a little too far.

Speaking of Karel's brother (who had his face burned off with a ray gun), he looks exactly like the Question.



'Spy' (by Jerry Siegel and Mart Bailey): Bart impersonates an ambassador from the fake country of Bolaria, and is captured by enemy agents from Luxor. It's decent enough.

'Buck Marshall, Range Detective' (by Homer Fleming): Buck helps a man who is framed for murder track down the two real culprits. This story was quite effective in obscuring who the real murderer was, which puts it a long way ahead of Homer Fleming's usual level of quality.

'Steve Malone, District Attorney' (by Gardner Fox and Don Lynch): Steve goes up against a gang of laundry racketeers in a fairly routine story.

'Swift Justice' (by Gardner Fox): In this prose story, a wealthy man is murdered, and the butler did it. Kudos to Gardner Fox for his originality!

'Speed Saunders, Ace Investigator and the Spy Mystery' (by Fred Guardineer): Speed is called in to investigate a spy ring that is stealing plans and smuggling them in a plane to Mexico. It's not bad.

'Cosmo, the Phantom of Disguise' (by Sven Elven): Cosmo must deliver a treaty to a foreign nation while avoiding enemy spies. I couldn't really bring myself to care, but it is one of those rare stories where Cosmo does actually use a disguise.

'Bruce Nelson' (by Tom Hickey): Nelson and his guide Mambu were captured by tribesmen last issue, and now Nelson meets their "White Goddess", an American woman who has been heavily drugged. Nelson tries to rescue her and escape in a solid story that concludes next month.

'Slam Bradley' (by Jerry Siegel and Mart Bailey): After turning in a criminal for a $5000 reward, Slam and Shorty take a trip around the world. It all goes horribly wrong when they get caught up in a war between Luthor and, uh, Twerpany. What follows is an amusing series of events where they go from one exploding vehicle to another, get captured by both sides, and just generally have the worst day possible. It's a lot of fun. And while Mart Bailey is no Joe Shuster, he's really finding a groove on this strip.  He draws Shorty well, and that's really the number one requirement.

Cover by Fred Guardineer

'The Sandman' (by Gardner Fox and Creig Flessel): Sandman tackles a lounge singer who has faked her own kidnapping to claim the insurance money. This one gets pretty convoluted at times, and it's never enjoyable enough to reward the effort of following it.

'Barry O'Neill' (by Ed Winiarski): Last issue the strip's arch-villain Fang Gow died, and just to emphasise the point we get his funeral here. But it's obvious by the way the creators are trying to sell his death that he is actually alive, and sure enough he rises from suspended animation a few days later and gets back to his favourite past-time, kidnapping Jean LeGrand. Barry goes to her rescue, and is menaced by lions in the cliffhanger. This one is full of cliches, but it does them pretty well.

'Federal Men' (by Jerry Siegel and Mart Bailey): When a racketeer named Rutska accidentally kills an innocent man, Steve Carson must hunt him down. This one was pretty boring until the end, when Rutska tries to swing away from the police on a power line and is electrocuted. Meanwhile, Steve is lying unconscious after a blow to the head, which is a huge fall from grace for the guy who used to kill every crook in sight.

'Socko Strong' (by Joseph Sulman): When Socko is hit by a car and loses his memory, a crooked gambler convinces him to throw his next boxing match. Socko's pal Jerry goes for help, and what we get is a genuine crossover between Socko Strong and Biff Bronson from More Fun Comics. Socko and Biff spar with each other, and Biff returns Socko's memory by punching him really hard. This would have been pretty dull, but I'm a sucker for a crossover.

'Trial by Water' (by Frank Thomas): A sailor's ship sinks in a storm, and he has to save his dog and swim to shore. Decent enough for what it is.

'Captain Desmo' (by Ed Winiarski): A British mining camp in India is beset by cutthroats, and has also fallen victim to cholera. It's an interesting twist on a familiar plot. The execution isn't that great, but at least the idea was a good one.

'Skip Schuyler' (by Tom Hickey): Continuing from last issue, Skip rescues the pilot he was looking for from a drink-crazed Eskimo. The Eskimo is much more disappointing than he sounds, but the story is okay.

'Rusty and His Pals' (by Bob Kane): Rusty and Steve lead a police raid against Chen Fu, who is killed in the attack. Steve decides to marry his girlfriend, and invites Rusty and his pals to live with them, but they leave for new adventures instead. This story tries to claim that Rusty, Tubby and Specs are all orphans, but that rang false for me. Checking back in the first installment, when the three of them sneak away from home to sail away on a raft, Rusty says "I only hope that Pop doesn't catch me!" Bob Kane, you have failed at continuity.

'Anchors Aweigh' (by Bart Tumey): Don and Red take on 'Satan's Sister', a female ship captain who is smuggling arms to those who are attacking China from the north. With an unusual villain and a surprisingly good ending, this is one of the better strips in the issue.

'Cotton Carver' (by Gardner Fox and Ogden Whitney): Last issue the pirate queen Deela swore allegiance to her enemy King Marl. Her pirate lieutenants are none to pleased, and Cotton must help her destroy their rebellion, which he does by using battle tactics he learned on Earth. This would be much more enjoyable without the smug 'Earth tactics are best!' attitude that it develops.

Thursday, August 25, 2011

October 1939: Detective Comics #33

Cover by Bob Kane
 
'Batman Wars Against the Dirigible of Doom' (by Bill Finger, Gardner Fox and Bob Kane): Scientist (and Napoleon admirer) Carl Kruger tries to take over the world with his death ray and huge dirigible. Batman puts a stop to him using just about every trick in his arsenal. This story, even more so than the previous vampire two-parter, is the one where all the pieces come together.

It kicks off with Batman's origin story: coming home from a movie, Bruce Wayne's parents are killed by a mugger. He vows to rid the world of crime, trains himself physically and mentally, and is inspired by a bat flying through his window. All the major points are covered, although there are a lot of details left to fill in. We don't learn who the mugger is, for example, or what movie the Waynes had just seen.  A lot of the iconography, such as Martha's pearls, isn't present.  But it's a well executed origin as written by Bill Finger, and gives Batman something besides an awesome costume.

Batman also really comes into his own as a scientist here. We see him mixing chemicals and using all sorts of gadgets, from the batarang to the batplane to a variety of gas pellets. This Batman is very recognisable in comparison to the modern version.

The story ends with an image of Batman posing with a gun, and I've often heard it said that Batman used a gun in his early stories. So far that's only been true once, and then it was to shoot vampires with silver bullets. I'll be keeping an eye on Batman's gun use to see if it's actually a sort of comic book urban myth.

'Spy' (by Jerry Siegel and Mart Bailey): When the fake European nation of Luxen is annexed by the equally fake Thoria, its president escapes to America. Bart must protect him from assassination, and when he returns to Luxen he also helps him incite the citizens to resist their oppressors. The conclusion is fairly unconvincing: the Thorians are holding an election for Luxen people to vote on whether they want to be annexed, and apparently just by voting against this the nation is freed. That's really not how these sorts of things work.

'Buck Marshall, Range Detective' (by Homer Fleming): The Acme Mining Syndicate wants to buy a mine that has suddenly struck it rich, but Buck and the sheriff are suspicious. It turns out that the mine owner is using a syringe to inject the ore samples with gold particles so that he can sell his worthless mine for big bucks. This one has a novel premise, and isn't too bad at all.

'Larry Steele, Private Detective' (by Ken Ernst): Larry investigates a series of jade thefts from a department store. It turns out that one of the managers is the culprit, in a story where the information needed to solve the mystery is only revealed at the end (something I hate in mystery stories). It's not all bad though. Larry's hard-as-nails secretary Brenda is introduced, and she adds a much-needed second dimension to his personality.  I think she can accurately be described as a "sassy dame".

'Coffee-Colored Diamonds' (by Frank Thomas): An FBI agent goes to Brazil to expose a diamond smuggler who is hiding the gems inside coffee beans. It gets the job done.

'Speed Saunders Ace Investigator and the Northwoods Mystery' (by Fred Guardineer): Speed goes hunting in Canada, and ends up fighting against a crazy guy who is killing and stealing fur from other hunters. This was okay despite the very high Mountie presence.

'Cosmo, the Phantom of Disguise' (by Sven Elven): Cosmo captures a gang of bank robbers who have tunneled through the sewers to commit their crimes. It's an average story brought even lower by some cliched criminal stupidity.

'Bruce Nelson' (by Tom Hickey): While hunting big game in the Congo, Bruce Nelson is captured by tribesmen and told that he'll be sacrificed to their "White Goddess". It ends with one of those cliffhangers where the protagonist stares in amazement at something we can't see, which is always terrible. But the rest of the set-up is done pretty well.

'Slam Bradley' (by Jerry Siegel and Mart Bailey): Slam and Shorty rescue an heiress and her guardian Farnsby from gangsters who want to steal her $500,000 diamond. Hijinks ensue when Shorty eats the diamond by mistake, and all sorts of crazy characters come by to try and get it out of him. As it turns out, Farnsby is behind the whole thing, and he pocketed the diamond himself and lied about Shorty swallowing it. In terms of the writing it's just as entertaining as ever, but with Mart Bailey on pencils instead of Joe Shuster there's an inevitable drop in quality.  If this is the end of the Siegel/Shuster collaboration on this strip I'll be very disappointed. It's been the best run I've read on a Golden Age strip so far.

Sunday, August 14, 2011

September 1939: All-American Comics #8; Detective Comics #32

Cover by Jon Blummer

'Gary Concord, The Ultra-Man' (by Jon Blummer): Awesome, it's a new superhero! In the year 2239, Gary Concord Jr. takes the position of High Moderator of the USA, which I think makes him like a cross between the President and Superman. The position was created by his father, who we are told brought about world peace, and after Junior accepts he gets to read about his dad's true history.

Gary Concord Sr. was born during World War I, a war in which both of his parents were killed. After vowing as a child to wipe out war, he spends all of his time becoming the best damn war-monger there ever was, seeking to learn the ways of his enemy before taking it down. In 1950, another World War breaks out while Gary is in his bunker devising a chemical so deadly that it will force everyone to make peace. His bunker is bombed, the deadly chemicals mix, and as they flow towards him he writes the 'Formula for Peace'. It turns out the chemicals don't kill him, only put him to sleep for a very long time, and grant him super-strength. The story ends as Gary starts to explore the USA of the future.

This was a hell of a lot of fun. It's hard to believe that this is by the same guy as 'Hop Harrigan'.  I'm looking forward to the goofy president/super-hero angle to come in future stories, and Gary Sr.'s origin is pure pulp sci-fi. His methods seem idiotic to me, but I wonder if they were indicative of theories at the time. Certainly his creation of a deadly super-chemical to force peace on everyone is absurd, yet not so different to how the fear of nuclear armageddon affected the Cold War.

'Red, White and Blue' (by William Smith): In this story Red and Blooey (minus Whitey, who doesn't appear at all) help Doris West investigate a plot by the Black Cross to sabotage a new submarine. The Black Cross are thinly veiled analogues to US Nazi sympathizers, and they're a bad bunch. After they capture Doris they spend most of the story burning her toes with matches.  It isn't shown at all, but the implication of it is enough to make them amongst the worst villains seen yet. Red does most of the action here, saving the submarine, chasing down the Black Cross ringleaders, rescuing Doris and even making heart-eyes at her. This is a very solid and entertaining adventure story.

'Hop Harrigan' (by Jon Blummer): While Wash and Ikky fly a cargo of nitro-glycerin, Hop and Gerry get into a dog-fight with smugglers who are trying to shoot them down. You know you've got a good issue of All-American Comics when even Hop Harrigan is decent.

'Wiley of West Point' (by Lieut. Richard Rick): Remember the suspense last issue, when Wiley had a loose button on his coat, just as the Lubanian General Pomposo was about to visit? In this chapter he's sent to his room, teased mercilessly by his peers, and then throws a bucket of water on Pomposo thinking that it's his fellow soldiers. Against my better judgement I even liked this one. Either All-American Comics is now great, or I'm just in an insanely good mood.  (Also, Pomposo is a really cool name.)

'Adventures in the Unknown' (by Carl H.Claudy and Stan Aschmeier): Professor Lazar shows Ted and Alan his time machine (or as he calls it a "Tempomobile"), but gets so excited that he has a stroke and dies. His Chinese manservant insists that Ted and Alan continue Lazar's quest to travel through time, which they do. This is a transitional chapter, something I generally don't get excited by, and the depiction of the Chinese manservant isn't helping matters. But I'm still looking forward to what's to come.

'Popsicle Pete' (by Sheldon Mayer): Pete and his friends decide to start a radio station, but learn they need $100 for a license. Ho hum.  It's pretty obvious to me that Sheldon Mayer is putting his effort into 'Scribbly'.

'Scribbly' (by Sheldon Mayer): Scribbly has a new teacher, and gets in trouble when he draws an unflattering cartoon of her in the newspaper. This was fairly cliched until the principal got involved and had some good lines.  I've discovered that 'Scribbly' has been reprinted a lot more than it's contemporary humour strips (at least the ones in the comic books), and it's easy to see why.  A lot of its jokes still hold up.

'Ben Webster' (by Edwin Alger): Ben's scientist friend Pat Ented opens a school in which he hopes to take six delinquent kids and turn them good through kindness. Shenanigans ensue.  It's pretty easy to see where this is going, but it's not terrible so far.

'Syndicate of Schemes' (by George Shute): In this prose story, Jimmy and Phil find a dead body.  There's a bit more stuff going on, but that's what it amounts to. It's continued next month, but so far it hasn't engaged me at all. The most notable thing is a plug for Movie Comics, which is already cancelled.  The axe must have fell on that series very unexpectedly.

'The American Way' (by John B. Wentworth and Walter Galli): Last month Karl's son was deciding whether to enlist to fight in World War I. This chapter is all about that debate, with his mother saying he shouldn't be going to fight their own German people. In the end he decides he must, because the family is American now. I can't say I'm happy to see any pro-war patriotic sentiments in a story, especially when that story is also urging people to cast off their heritage.  It's not badly told, but any story of this kind has an uphill battle in getting me to like it.


Cover by Fred Guardineer

'Batman' (by Gardner Fox and Bob Kane): We left Batman last issue on the trail of the Monk, who had kidnapped Batman's fiancee and taken her to Hungary. Batman defeats the Monk in this story, and it turns out that he is a vampire. Or a werewolf, the story claims both things at various times. This one isn't quite so gripping as the last chapter, but the Monk is still a good villain. He'd be great if he could figure out what monster he's supposed to be.  This is the first time we see Batman use a gun, as he kills the sleeping vampires with silver bullets.

'Spy' (by Jerry Siegel and Mart Bailey): Bart takes on a group of spies who are sabotaging the US navy in a fairly dull adventure. I've talked before about how I miss Bart's fiancee Sally in  this strip. In this one he rubs it in by talking about taking "his girl" to see a movie. Either he's moved on with another woman, or he's still with Sally and she's not allowed to be a spy any more. I can't say I'm happy with either prospect.

'Buck Marshall, Range Detective' (by Homer Fleming): Buck Marshall investigates a group of cattle smugglers who are paying for cattle with counterfeit bills. Weak and predictable as usual.

'Larry Steele, Private Detective' (by Ken Ernst): Larry deals with a fortune hunter who tries to kill a wealthy heiress who spurned his proposal. The culprit is obviously guilty from his first appearance, and his stupidity in revealing his guilt has to be seen to be believed.

'Vanishing Gems' (by Gardner Fox): A detective discovers that a man is stealing jewels from a jewelry factory by firing them out of the window with a slingshot. It's actually kind of an ingenious plan.

'Speed Saunders, Ace Investigator and the Skull-Face Cult' (by Fred Guardineer): Speed goes up against Skull-Face, a weird cult leader who is selling lethal beauty products to wealthy heiresses after taking their money. He's kind of rad with his skull mask and inexplicable giant ape servant. Fred Guardineer can come up with some intriguing stories and situations, but his dialogue is terrible.

'Cosmo, The Phantom of Disguise' (by Sven Elven): Cosmo tackles a group of criminals who are killing public figures with ice bullets, which melt after entering the body. Sorry Cosmo, not even your absurd ice bullets can make you interesting enough to care about.

'Bruce Nelson' (by Tom Hickey): Bruce Nelson investigates the murder of a notorious playboy, who it turns out had a lot of gambling debts. This is about the only strip in here where some real detective work gets done, as opposed to the half-arsed "jump to conclusions" and "follow hunches" methods that the other detectives use. It makes a big difference, but the story is let down by the villain's weak capitulation at the end.

'Slam Bradley' (by Siegel and Shuster): Slam is hired by a hotel manager to rid his hotel of ghosts, but it turns out that the whole thing was a practical joke being played on Slam. The story was entertaining enough, but it was an incredibly weak ending.  I can't believe Slam didn't punch the hell out of that hotel owner at the end.

Sunday, July 24, 2011

August 1939: Adventure Comics #42; All-American Comics #7; Detective Comics #31; More Fun Comics #47

Cover possibly by Creig Flessel or Chad Grothkopf

'The Sandman' (by Bert Christman): Wesley Dodd gathers three of his old navy buddies together to stop the murder of another friend of theirs. With the addition of some friends and a past, Dodd suddenly feels like a real character. The aerial dogfight that climaxes the story is decent as well. I was also surprised that Dodd's friends are well aware that he is the Sandman, and that he allows them both to take on the Sandman identity for this adventure. This strip will improve greatly if it keeps on this direction. 

'Barry O'Neill' (by Ed Winiarski): Barry rescues Inspector LeGrand, then stop's Krull and his gang from blowing up the French fleet with mines. It's an adequate wrap-up to this story-line, with a good variety of action scenes.

'Federal Men' (by Jerry Siegel and Wayne Boring): Steve Carson single-handedly arrests a gang of bank robbers, which isn't really interesting at all. This is the first credit for Wayne Boring, who is a major name in early DC history. At this point I can see that his story-telling is really solid, but his art lacks the character and energy of Joe Shuster.

'Jack Woods' (by Jim Chambers): Jack Woods guns down the bank robbing gang from last issue, and rescues the boy they had captive. The story ends when a mysterious stranger shows up to arrest Jack for murder. I love how Jack's friend leaps to his defense: "He just shot up one o' the worst mobs around here. He ain't no murderer!" Yep, the fact that he just killed a bunch of dudes is great evidence in his favour.

This appears to be the last we see of Jack Woods.  I can only assume that he is arrested for murder and hanged, which is an ignominious end for the character who starred on the cover of the first DC comic ever.

'Socko Strong' (by Joseph Sulman): When last we left Socko and Jerry, they were aboard the legendary ghost ship, the Flying Dutchman. In this issue it turns out not to be a ghost ship, but the ship of Charles Starwin, on his way to return a prehistoric man to his island home. Once they reach the island they are menaced by dinosaurs, and it's rather quaint the way the dinosaurs are depicted. I'm especially fond of the stegosaur with the poisonous bite. This strip never makes any sense, but it's always enjoyable.

'Captain Desmo' (by Ed Winiarski): Gabby is captured by the Thuggees from last issue, and Desmo goes to his rescue. I appreciate the use of the Thuggees as villains, but otherwise this is a fairly standard adventure. And will we never learn why Desmo wears that damn helmet?

'Quest in India' (by Terry Keane): Continuing from last issue, a group of explorers find the hidden temple of the Lasbas in the Hindu Kush, only for a crazed priest to blow it up with dynamite so that they can't desecrate it. This turned out better than I was expecting.

'Anchors Aweigh!' (by Bart Tumey): Red and Don are still trying to find the culprit behind a submarine base that threatened the security of the Panama Canal. When they're captured they are taken to meet Cato, an Asian man who dresses like Napoleon, and is also the head of the Mayenese army. There's a little bit of humour with Cato, but it's still a below-average story.

'Skip Schuyler' (by Tom Hickey): Skip is in "The Orient", and rescues a young boy during a bombing raid. The boy leads him to a laundry, where a beautiful foreign correspondent is being held for ransom. This is okay, and I enjoyed Skip's relationship to the kid. I just feel like there's more story to tell here, even though it's obviously over.

'Rusty and His Pals' (by Bob Kane): Rusty and Steve are captured by Chen Fu, who wants revenge on them for killing his most trusted lieutenant. Chen Fu goes for the classics, putting Steve in a deathtrap with a spiked floor and a giant scything blade. This is just silly enough to be enjoyable.

'Cotton Carver in the Pit of Dagan' (by Gardner Fox and Ogden Whitney): Cotton is still trying to find his way to the surface. He rescues his friends from cultists, gets chased by dinosaurs, and finally finds refuge in the city of Marla. Fun stuff, especially when Cotton sets fire to a carnivorous brontosaurus.


Cover by Stan Aschmeier

'Red, White and Blue' (by William Smith): Red, Whitey and Blooey go up against a munitions manufacturer who is hiring people to cause trouble at the World's Fair, trying to make the countries involved go to war with each other. This is fun as usual, but the bad guy's plan does involve trying to get France and England to go to war over a stink bomb and a knocked over statue. He's not exactly the sharpest villain I've ever seen.

'Ben Webster' (by Edwin Alger): Last issue Ben's thought projector was stolen, and this issue he discovers the culprit - the maid did it! This storyline has taken a definite swerve into cliched territory.

'Bobby Thatcher' (by George Storm): After their boat was smashed in last issue's storm, Bobby and Elmer swim to shore, but they can't find Tubby. He is eventually found after a long search, and the whole town celebrates. It's a bit flimsy for a whole chapter of an adventure strip.

'Adventures in the Unknown: A Thousand Years a Minute' (by Carl H. Claudy and Stan Aschmeier): Ted and Alan arrive back on Earth, but when their mechanical man Elmer is rusted by salt water they are unable to prove that they went to Mars, and everyone thinks they're crazy. Except for Dr. Lazar, who's obviously a bit mental himself.  It's decent enough, but it certainly didn't live up to the awesome title (or the cover).

'The American Way' (by John Wentworth and Walter Galli): This chapter starts out light-heartedly, with Martin Gunther's daughter Lisa about to be married, but it takes a grim turn when World War I begins, and his son Karl must decide whether or not to go to war. With the over-patriotic nonsense out of the way, this is becoming a decent family drama.

'Hop Harrigan' (by Jon Elby): Hop is giving Geraldine flying lessons. The first goes badly when she brings her dogs along, and Hop has to knock her out with a fire extinguisher. But she learns her lesson, and later rescues Hop and her father from a flood. This is sort of charming, and the courtship of Hop and Gerry is a strange one. "Oh mother, Hop's adorable! He hit me with the fire extinguisher today!"

'Wiley of West Point' (by Lieut. Richard Rick): Oh no! There's an inspection from the Lubanian Embassy, and WILEY HAS A LOOSE BUTTON ON HIS DRESS COAT!!!!!

'Criminal's End' (by George Shute): Jimmy stops some foreign agents from sabotaging a US ship. This was adequate until the nauseating exchange at the end of the story. Phil: "You can't win when right is not on your side, Jimmy. Always remember that." Jimmy: "I won't forget, Phil. An American just can't forget that!" I realise that I am reading All-American Comics, so I should expect this stuff. Doesn't mean I have to like it.

'Scribbly' (by Sheldon Mayer): Scribbly does his best to get a picture of an elusive writer who has never been photographed or sketched. Amusing as always.

'Popsicle Pete' (possibly by Sheldon Mayer): Pete is interviewed, and after saying in the interview that he thinks girls are silly he is inundated with hate mail. Average.

Cover by Bob Kane
'The Batman' (by Bob Kane): Batman's fiancee Julie is hypnotised and abducted by a mysterious hooded monk, and he must pursue them to the monk's castle in Hungary. This is the first great Batman story. Not only does it really hammer home that weird creature of the night vibe, but it has his first really good adversary in the Monk, who looks cool and has every trick in the super-villain book. The batarang makes its first appearance here, as does the bat-plane (which is more of a helicopter, but never mind). The introduction of Julie Madison as Bruce Wayne's fiancee humanises him a little, though I do wonder whether he plans to tell her about Batman even after they're married. My only misgiving about this story is that Batman runs away from a giant ape instead of fighting it, but there's always next issue, because this is to be continued.

'Buck Marshall, Range Detective' (by Homer Fleming): Buck goes up against a gang of bank robbers, and gets a confession out of them by going undercover. This is a solid story by Buck Marshall standards.

'Spy' (by Jerry Siegel and Mart Bailey): Bart investigates the theft of America's new "mystery plane", and it turns out the man assigned to guard it is the leader of the thieves. This was decent enough until Bart just pulls a machine gun out of nowhere to capture the crooks. As he says to his boss, "we're pretty busy protecting our country from its enemies who bore from within!" Make sure to get the comics that bore from within as well, Bart.

'Larry Steele, Private Detective' (by Ken Ernst): This one gets off to a good start, with businessman Amos Velvet telling Larry about the death threats his wife has been receiving, just before getting a phone call telling them that she has committed suicide. It turns out that Amos himself was the murderer, as he'd been forcing his wife to funnel money from her charity work into his business. Larry, you should have slapped the cuffs on this guy the second you saw his little Hitler moustache. This is a pretty good mystery story, with solid motivations and a couple of neat misdirections.

'Newspaper Nightmare' (by Gardner Fox): In this prose story two newspapermen are murdered by their publisher, who placed a poisoned needle in their typewriters. This is a murder mystery in which there is exactly one suspect, and all of the relevant information that could help the reader solve the crime is withheld until the end. I've always believed that a mystery story should be solvable by the reader, so this one gets a fail.

'Speed Saunders, Ace Investigator and the Mammoth Mystery' (by Fred Guardineer): This one has a cracking start, as Speed investigates the murder of an explorer who was killed with a gigantic elephant tusk. The investigation leads to a circus and a jealous animal trainer. The clues are all there, but the murderer's motivation is virtually non-existent.

'Bruce Nelson' (by Tom Hickey): Bruce is lured out to a party at an old friend's house, while the man who set that up raids Bruce's safe for evidence that would convict him of murder. Bruce gets wise and stops him. It's an adequate story, but a long way down from the height of this strip.

'Cosmo, the Phantom of Disguise' (by Sven Elven): This is pretty good for a Cosmo story, as he investigates a doctor who is stealing the brainpower of other brilliant men, adding it to his own and leaving them as vegetables. It does, however, feature the most amazing panel of exposition I have ever seen in my life.

Sven Elven: paid by the word

'Slam Bradley' (by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster): Slam and Shorty go up against a zoo keeper who is murdering the people who torment his animals. It's a lacklustre installment for the usually great Slam Bradley.


Cover by Fred Guardineer

I don't have a copy of this issue.  The only thing that I seem to be missing is the final installment of Cal 'n' Alec.  To be honest, that strip has been on life support for ages, so I won't be sad to see it go.

Monday, July 11, 2011

July 1939: Detective Comics #30

Cover by Fred Guardineer

'The Batman' (by Bob Kane): After Batman witnessed his death in a fire last issue, Doctor Death returns with a scheme to steal some diamonds. It's kind of a low rent plan for a master criminal, but nevertheless I found myself enjoying Batman's investigation. Bob Kane has really figured out how to depict the character at this point, and the story is littered with iconic images. It's too bad that the story falls down a little bit at the end, with some out-of-left-field nonsense about Doctor Death being disguised as a jewellery fence. Still, not even that weak ending can ruin a story where Batman kicks a dude so hard his neck breaks.

'Buck Marshall, Range Detective' (by Homer Fleming); This month Buck investigates two ranch owners, Morgan and Vail, who are feuding because Vail is stealing Morgan's cattle. It turns out that neither is to blame, and that the local gambling den owner is setting it up so that he can kill Vail and take his ranch. This is standard Buck Marshall material, but what makes it extra shitty is that the whole thing hinges on Slade trying to frame Morgan for shooting Vail.  Slade forgets that Morgan has no trigger finger on his right hand, EXCEPT THAT MORGAN IS POINTING AT VAIL WITH THAT FINGER IN THE VERY FIRST PANEL HE APPEARS IN. That is some amateur-hour bullshit right there.

'Spy' (by Jerry Siegel and Mart Bailey): Bart takes on a mad scientist who is using a mind control machine to manipulate politicians so that he can become the despotic ruler of the USA. This is a fairly dull story with none of the charm that this strip used to have. I don't care about the mad scientist's plot, I just want to know where Sally has gone. You know, Bart's fiancee, who he made out with on the last panel of every story? She's gone, completely, and it's lame that they did it with no explanation at all.

'Larry Steele, Private Detective' (by Will Ely): Larry gets shot by a pair of bank robbers, who go on to commit a bunch more robberies until Larry finally catches them. It's as boring as it sounds.

'Shadowed' (by Frank Thomas): This prose story is about a detective who is investigating a gang of counterfeiters. He is captured, but manages to escape and arrest them. The villains in this story have got to be the most stupidly over-confident dummies that I've read in this blog so far. I understand that it's the whole point of the story, but there's only so far you can go before it becomes irritating.

'Speed Saunders, Ace Investigator and the Crossbow Mystery' (by Fred Guardineer): Speed investigates the murder of a writer. This guy was also a collector of old weapons, and was killed by a crossbow. It turns out the maid did it, as she'd just been named in the will, and thought that the weapons would be worth thousands of dollars. Speed arrests her and claims that she killed for nothing, because the whole collection was worthless. Sure thing Speed, a 13th century crossbow and an ancient Aztec sacrificial dagger is of no monetary value whatsoever.

'Bruce Nelson and the Racketeers' (by Tom Hickey): Bruce takes on a gang of Chinese tea racketeers, and leads their rivals as they hijack the latest shipment and throw it in the ocean in a reenactment of the Boston Tea Party. This is alright, but let down at the end when it completely glosses over the climactic action scenes in a single caption.

'Cosmo, the Phantom of Disguise' (by Sven Elven): Cosmo gets involved with a guy who is being sent threatening notes if he doesn't send his blackmailers $200,000. It turns out that the guy is faking the notes and trying to escape with his insurance money. It's a bit more cleverly told than the average Cosmo story.

'Slam Bradley' (by Siegel and Shuster): After the classic Slam Bradley opening of him punching some random crooks, Slam and Shorty see a woman being dragged off to an insane asylum. Slam decides to investigate, and he goes back to another old standby when he decides that Shorty will have to act crazy until he gets thrown into the looney bin. It's very funny stuff, even if it does slip into cliche when we learn that the owner of the asylum wants the girl to die so that he can inherit her fortune. There's even a little bit of Siegel and Shuster's patented social crusading, when we're shown the way the patients are mistreated. It's played for laughs, but there's no doubting what the creators feel about the situation.

Wednesday, June 15, 2011

June 1939: Detective Comics #39

Cover by Bob Kane

'The Bat-Man meets Doctor Death' (by Bob Kane): Now this is a bit more like it. In this story, as you may have guessed from the title, the Bat-Man goes up against Doctor Death. Doctor Death has a plan to poison any millionaire who doesn't pay him lots of money, but he needs to get rid of the Bat-Man first. A series of traps and attempts to kill the Bat-Man ensue, until the Bat-Man tracks down his opponent.  Doctor Death is killed in a fire, and the Bat-Man utters the immortal line: "Death... To Doctor Death!" This is the first Bat-Man story that really effectively captures his mystery and eeriness, and also his hard-as-nails attitude.
We also see the first real use of Bat-Man's utility belt: he stores some smoke bombs in it.

Mind you, he's not too protective of his secret identity.  When Doctor Death puts an ad in the paper addressed to Bat-Man telling him to pick up a parcel from the post office, Bat-Man goes there as Bruce Wayne to collect it.  I expect that other people, possibly the police, would have noticed that ad as well.  And it's not like Bruce Wayne, millionaire playboy, wouldn't be recognised.

'Larry Steele, Private Detective' (by Will Ely): While Larry is looking out of his apartment window he sees a man in the building across the street being murdered for not paying a debt. Larry decides that the best way to get across there is to climb on the girders of a half-finished building, and the crooks also decide that that is the best way to escape. What follows is a shoot-out high above ground level. The novel setting made this one more interesting than its banal plot would suggest.

'Spy' (by Jerry Siegel and Mart Bailey): What? No Shuster? I suppose he's got too much Superman to worry about his other strips right now. In this story Bart Regan and a guy named Jack Steele go up against a foreign spy who plans to kill a bunch of military officers with bombs during an aerial demonstration. It lacks a lot of the charm that it had during Shuster's run, most notably because Bart's fiancee Sally has been replaced by some random new guy. The heart of this strip was not the intrigue or the plotting, but the interplay between Bart and Sally. Without that, and without Shuster, you have just another generic comic about spies.

'The Crimson Avenger' (by Jim Chambers): The Crimson Avenger tackles some kidnappers in what is about the most generic story ever devised by man.

'A Game for Two' (by Paul Dean): In this prose story a man named Baxter buys some priceless pearls, only for a master thief to send him a letter explaining that he is going to steal them. Baxter notifies the police, who then proceed to disguise themselves and capture the thief as he's stealing the pearls. I enjoyed the cocky attitude of the thief early on, but after that things go far too smoothly for the police to entertain me.

'Speed Saunders, Ace Investigator and the Perfect Crime' (by Fred Guardineer): Scientist Doctor Oldbourne kills his partner by blowing tobacco in his face, then substituting the chemicals he was working on with explosives. It's supposedly the perfect crime, but Speed Saunders keeps on keeping on until Doctor Oldbourne is under arrest. This isn't a great story, but I love the way it plays up Speed using a dictaphone to record Oldbourne's confession; it's made out to be the most ingenious idea ever, when really it should be tactic #1 for every detective.

'Bruce Nelson' (by Tom Hickey): Bruce is still investigating the murder of Lily Gravet, and to be honest I remember nothing of what went before. It turns out that The Butler Did It, which is about par for the course. It's too bad, because this was once a great strip, but now it seems a bit lacking.

'Cosmo, The Phantom of Disguise' (by Sven Elven): This one certainly got my attention, as a mystery man destroys a church and kills thousands of people. He later does the same thing with a battleship and a dam. Eventually Cosmo tracks him down, and discovers a mad scientist with a disintegrator ray. A freak accident causes the ray to destroy itself, and the madman dies in the ensuing explosion. This was relatively epic, and is easily one of the best Cosmo stories to date.

'Slam Bradley' (by Siegel and Shuster): This is another one with an intriguing start, as Slam receives a mysterious letter telling him to stay out of Hawaii. Of course this just fuels his desire to go. The pay-off to this is much less interesting than the set-up, as it turns out that the letter was sent by a woman whose father has been kidnapped, and she decided to use reverse psychology to get Slam to come to Hawaii and help her. After that it's a fairly straightforward action/adventure rescue mission. The only bit of originality comes when Slam is menaced by a leper. But despite the opening, this is one of the weaker Slam Bradley stories.

Thursday, June 2, 2011

May 1939: Detective Comics #29

Cover by Fred Guardineer

'The Bat-Man' (by Bill Finger and Bob Kane): This month the Bat-Man (I'm going to call him that so long as the actual comic does) goes up against some jewel thieves, and there's not much more to be said about that. The plot is of very little interest, so it's the little details I have to focus on. The first is in the introduction, which says that the Bat-Man is "Bruce Wayne, bored young socialite". The Bat-Man hasn't had an origin story at this point, and from that description you'd get the idea that he's a rich kid playing super-hero to keep himself entertained.

The Bat-Man doesn't have any gadgets at this point, but he does use a silk rope an awful lot in this story to swing from buildings. He even has to twirl it around his head like a lasso before he throws it. We also see the first "batmobile", although it isn't named as such. It's just a simple red car of the 1930s, with nothing to distinguish it from any other random dude's vehicle.

If it wasn't for the gift of hindsight, I wouldn't be getting into this strip at all. About the only thing it has going for it is that the Bat-Man looks cool.

'Speed Saunders Ace Investigator and The Dope Ring' (by Fred Guardineer): Speed is hired by a newspaper owner to investigate a dope ring, and it turns out (surprise!) that the newspaper guy is the head of that very ring. There are shootings galore and a treacherous femme fatale, both of which help to push this just slightly above mediocrity.

'Buck Marshall, Range Detective' (by Homer Fleming): Buck Marshall goes up against yet another guy trying to kill a ranch owner to get his land, but this story has a decent hook at the beginning, as Buck is seemingly mistaken for a criminal and thrown in jail. It turns out to be a plot by the sheriff to get Buck undercover, and it puts this on a level much higher than the usual Homer Fleming story.  Which is to say, the prospect of reading it didn't have me ready to break out the razors.

'Spy' (by Siegel and Shuster): When a ship from Baralia is blown up in a US harbour the two countries threaten war. Bart is assigned to stop this, which he does by tracking down the real culprit, the ship's captain. Sally is not in this story at all, and as a result it lacks a lot of its usual charm.

'The Crimson Avenger' (by Jim Chambers): This month the Crimson Avenger tackles a gang of knife-wielding Arab jewel thieves. This story is seriously disjointed. At one point the Crimson Avenger is hit by a car and put in hospital, but in the very next panel he's up and about and ready to fight some crime. The conclusion is similarly weak, as the Crimson Avenger leaves just as the police are arriving to arrest everyone.  Say what you want about Superman, but that dude sticks around to clean up his own messes.

'Human Cargo' (by Jack Anthony): This is another reprint of an earlier prose story, the one where the discovery of a human leg in the bay leads to the a gang smuggling Chinese people into America. Obviously DC don't want to pay anyone for these anymore, and I don't blame them.

'Bruce Nelson' (by Tom Hickey): Bruce and his partner Lane are investigating the murder of Lili Gravet, a woman with a fascination for black magic. There's a certain creepy atmosphere to this strip, but far too much of it consists of Nelson and Lane talking to each other about the various suspects. They've made absolutely zero progress by the time the strip finishes. It will continue next month, but I guarantee I'll have forgotten what they talked about by the time I get to it.

'Doctor Fu Manchu' (by Sax Rohmer and Leo O'Mealia): Petrie and Nayland Smith are still protecting the old missionary Eltham from Fu Manchu. One of Fu Manchu's goons is stalking the grounds, and even beats up a mastiff, but I don't feel like this story is going anywhere.

'Cosmo, The Phantom of Disguise' (by Sven Elven): Cosmo goes fox hunting with yet another of his endless list of lifelong friends, only to find out that this friend is deep in debt to a man who wants his house and his daughter.  The bad guy pulls out every cliche trick in the book, even haunting the house like a Scooby-Doo villain. Despite all of these hackneyed shenanigans, this story somehow manages to be better than most Cosmo stories. It was probably the fight Cosmo has with a suit of armour. Or maybe the scene where he shoots a glow-in-the-dark cat.

'Slam Bradley' (by Siegel and Shuster): This month, Slam is bequeathed a million dollars in the will of a man he once saved. But there's a stipulation: he has to spend the night in a house full of all the family members whose inheritance he has taken without being murdered. A decent mystery follows when the murders begin, though it's a little light on humour, and it turns out the killer is Ronald, the obligatory drunken son. As usual, Slam is the best thing in Detective Comics.