Showing posts with label More Fun Comics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label More Fun Comics. Show all posts

Monday, July 23, 2012

July 1940: More Fun Comics #58

Cover by Bernard Baily

'The Spectre' (by Jerry Siegel and Bernard Baily): The Spectre goes up against a crooked businessman who is trying to kill a warehouse owner who knows about his shifty dealings. This is strictly small potatoes for the Spectre, and there's never any doubt of the outcome. The only spot of interest comes from a bit of falsely manufactured drama, as the Spectre is inexplicably drawn into the spirit world while trying to save the warehouse owner from a bomb. It's never explained, and is just a very weak piece of storytelling.

'Doctor Fate' (by Gardner Fox and Howard Sherman): This strip is a weird mix of the poetic and the prosaic. Fate must battle a wizard who has stolen a powerful book that contains "all secrets", and is capable of destroying the world. Epic enough, yes? Except that the wizard is using it to steal money. And Fate stops him with a punch to the jaw. But then there are really cool touches, such as Fate burning the book and scattering the ashes into the sea, only for thousands of fish to die because of its evil power. If Fox and Sherman would just go balls out epic this could be a great strip.

In other stories:

'Detective Sergeant Carey' (by Joe Donohoe) investigates the murder of a trapeze artist. 'Congo Bill' (by Whitney Ellsworth and George Papp) deals with a tribe of leopard men, and finally captures his archnemesis the Skull. 'Captain Desmo' (by Ed Winiarski) stumbles across an island where arms smugglers are stockpiling munitions, and blows it up. In 'Radio Squad' (by Jerry Siegel and Chad Grothkopf) Sandy and Larry track down some brutal robbers due to them having placed an unregistered measles sign on their house. 'Lieut. Bob Neal of Sub 662' (by Bob Hirsch and Russ Lehman) investigates some stolen bonds and a faked suicide. It's pretty obvious that the creators have no interest in the naval setting any more. 'Biff Bronson' (by Albert Sulman and Joseph Sulman) helps a man jailed for fur theft clear his name. And 'Sergeant O'Malley of the Red Coat Patrol' (by Jack Lehti) catches a gang that stole a lumberjack payroll.

Sunday, March 18, 2012

May 1940: More Fun Comics #57

Cover by Bernard Bailey

'The Spectre' (by Jerry Siegel and Bernard Baily): Zor is back! The Spectre's arch-nemesis escapes from his imprisonment, and it's not long before the two are engaged in psychic combat, hurling comets at each other. Zor wins, then sets about ruining the Spectre's life by framing his alter ego Jim Corrigan for murder, and recruiting a serial killer to menace Jim's ex-girlfriend. The Spectre is powerless, and as he always does in such a situation, he goes to God for advice. (It's happening a little too often for my liking.) God sends him off to find the mystic Ectobane tree, from which the Spectre fashions a casket to imprison Zor. He hurls the casket into space, rescues his girl, and everybody lives happily ever after. Except for the scientist at the beginning who Zor left trapped for eternity. And come to think of it, Jim never cleared his name of murder, either. But even with these nagging loose ends, this is cracking good fun. I'd be very surprised if this strip wasn't a major influence on Ditko's Doctor Strange work, and that's praise indeed.


'Detective Sergeant Carey and the Royal Lurma Diamond' (by Joe Donohoe): Carey is assigned to transfer a diamond from a ship to an armored car, but is tricked by disguised thieves. Most of this strip is the following car chase, which has some quite poor sequential storytelling. In the end it turns out that Carey's sidekick Sleepy didn't hand over the diamond after all, because: "I didn't trust that purser; he had a beard!" This from a guy with a comb-over and a Hitler moustache?

'Congo Bill' (by Whitney Ellsworth and George Papp): Bill and Professor Kent are heading for civilisation with the priceless relics they stole last issue, but they are ambushed and captured by the Skull. I rather liked the Skull last time, but his credibility goes down a notch here when he's beaten by a chimp. The chimp becomes Bill's new sidekick, christened O'Toole. This is alright. The action scenes are adequate, and there's some banter to liven things up. I've certainly read worse.

'Wild Stallion' (by Alec Mayne): A cowboy saves a wild horse from a precarious cliff, and the horse saves him in return. Then they become bestest buddies forever. Sickening.

'Captain Desmo' (by Ed Winiarski): Desmo decides that he's had a gut-full of the assassins, and goes after the Grand Assassin himself. He ends up captured, but escapes with an implausible bomb made out of playing cards, an iron pipe and some gunpowder. The assassins' castle is conveniently rigged with self-destruct mechanisms, so Desmo simply escapes and blows the whole place to smithereens, killing all of the assassins inside. The ending goes too far out of its way to make things easy for Desmo, and to wrap up the story quickly.

'Radio Squad' (by Jerry Siegel and Chad Grothkopf): Sandy and Larry are pissed off because they're stuck hunting for a stolen baby carriage when they'd rather be after a gang of bank robbers. So of course, it turns out that the bank robbers are the ones who stole the carriage. It's a mediocre story, but the annoyance of the main characters and a good car chase in the middle liven things up.

'Lieut. Bob Neal of Sub 662' (by B. Hirsch and R. Lehman): A soldier convicted of espionage in 1918 seeks revenge by murdering the pilots who testified against him. Part of his plan involves dressing up as an old lady, which again I question the necessity of. Bob stops him. Move along, nothing to see here.

'Biff Bronson' (by Albert Sulman and Joseph Sulman): Dan eats some chicken at 3 am, and has a nightmare about a guy who falls into a coma and is buried alive. Pointless and bizarre.

'Sergeant O'Malley of the Red Coat Patrol' (by Jack Lehti): A murderer escapes town with a captive child, and O'Malley must track him down. Against my natural instincts, this was actually a pretty solid adventure story.

'Doctor Fate' (by Gardner Fox and Howard Sherman): Doctor Fate battles a mystic named Mango, who is killing people with an orb of fire. Between the fiery deaths and some undead legions there's certainly enough going on, but Fate himself is almost too mysterious for his own good. He's very detached and otherworldly, and there really isn't a gateway character to draw me into the strip otherwise.  Even the Spectre has a human alter ego.

Sunday, February 26, 2012

May 1940: More Fun Comics #56

Cover by Howard Sherman

'The Spectre' (by Jerry Siegel and Bernard Baily): Jim Corrigan, aka the Spectre, must deal with an unscrupulous wholesaler that is threatening a department store, trying to force the store to buy more of its goods. There's never a question that the Spectre might fail, and not a hint of drama. Instead this story provides the catharsis of seeing crooks get what they deserve, usually in a gruesome or morbid fashion.  It's still a good read, though it is lacking in eeriness compared to previous installments.

'Biff Bronson' (by Albert Sulman and Joseph Sulman): Biff picks up the wrong short from the dry cleaners, one with a message written on it as a tip-off to a payroll robbery. He foils the robbery by posing as a Chinese laundryman, in a predictably horrendous fashion. As usual, I can accept it when the villains are racist, but Biff's disguise and fake accent are just terrible.

'Captain Desmo' (by Ed Winiarski): Gabby is captured by the society of Assassins, and Desmo rescues him. This almost certainly breaks the record for grenades thrown in a story up to this point. Even so, it manages to be a bit rubbish.

'Radio Squad' (by Jerry Siegel and Chad Grothkopf): Sandy tackles a married couple who are selling counterfeit fur coats on the street. The premise is a novel one, but it all falls flat in execution.

'Lieut. Bob Neal of Sub 662' (by Bob Hirsch and Russ Lehman): Bob and his sub must protect a huge American oil tanker from attacks by the "belligerent" nations. Another very dull story.

'Memory Test' (by George Shute): A kid helps a circus elephant that has a broken piece of chain sticking into its leg. Later, after an accident in the big top, the elephant saves the kid's mother. I don't know what it is tonight, but this is another terrible story. Perhaps I'm just in a shitty mood.

'Congo Bill' (by Whitney Ellsworth and George Papp): It's the first appearance of Congo Bill, who goes on (in a completely different form) to become one of DC's most long-lived characters.  In the Congo, Bill foils an attempt by the villainous Skull to steal treasures from some ancient ruins. Once again, I couldn't muster up any enthusiasm for this. I'm pretty sure now that this is all the fault of my sleep-deprived brain.

'Detective Sergeant Carey and the Jade Hatchet' (by Joe Donohoe): An old Chinese man is targeted by hatchet men for daring to oppose an opium smuggling operation. Carey protects the old man, and exposes the hatchet man as the mayor of Chinatown. Mayor dude, you need to learn how to delegate.



'Sergeant O'Malley of the Red Coat Patrol' (by Jack Lehti): Mounties and horse thieves. It's like my worst nightmares personified.

'Doctor Fate' (by Gardner Fox and Howard Sherman): After supposedly destroying his foe Wotan last issue, Fate goes to Hell to check if he is actually dead. It turns out that he's still alive, and has a plan to blow up the world. Naturally, Fate stops him. The first half of this story is great, full of references to Elder Gods and eldritch beings, all of which contribute to giving this strip an air of mythic wonder. The second half is more conventional super hero fare, and not nearly as good.

Wednesday, November 16, 2011

February 1940: More Fun Comics #54

Cover by Bernard Baily

That is a seriously great cover.  It's probably the first Golden Age cover that I really love.

'The Spectre' (by Jerry Siegel and Bernard Baily): The Spectre takes on a phony psychic, who has been fleecing the mother of the Spectre's former fiancee. This was all quite uninteresting, until the scene where the Spectre is summoned back to Heaven and offered a choice between eternal rest, or fighting evil on Earth as a ghost forever. With his fiancee's life in danger he chooses to remain Earth-bound. It's a great moment trapped in an otherwise mediocre story.

'Biff Bronson' (by Al Sulman and Joseph Sulman): Biff and Dan take on the Wizard and his robot army, which is nowhere near as exciting as it sounds. It mostly involves them running away while the robots' batteries run out.

'Captain Desmo' (by Ed Winiarski): Desmo and Gabby anger a group of assassins in India, and must beat them before they are killed. Which they do in a straightforward manner that elicits no excitement.

'Radio Squad' (by Jerry Siegel and Chad Grothkopf): Sandy and Larry must guard a wealthy man who is being targeted by "The Cloak", a mysterious killer who ends up being the wealthy man himself. The first part of the Cloak's plan makes perfect sense, but I can't see exactly what he was trying to achieve after that.

'Lieut. Bob Neal of Sub 662' (by B. Hirsch and Russ Lehman): A female spy after the US defense plans? Seen it. A spy ring with a ray that can stop a plane's engine? Seen it. Story with no original elements, told in a boring fashion? Definitely seen it.

'A Wet Wager' (by Paul Dean): A seaman makes a bet that he can stay underwater longer than his friend, but must be rescued when his oxygen line is cut. I'm almost certain that this is a reprint from an earlier comic.

'King Carter' (by Paul J. Lauretta): King and Red are stranded by pirates on a tropical island. Red befriends a tribe of apes that helps them defeat the pirates. There's a certain absurd charm of it all.

'Detective Sergeant Carey and the Policy Murders' (by Joe Donohoe): Carey and Sleepy track down the killers of a wealthy old recluse. It's all to do with an insurance scam, which is as worn out a motivation as there is.

'Sergeant O'Malley of the Red Coat Patrol' (by Jack Lehti): O'Malley takes on a gang of crooks that is trying to steal a mine from an old prospector. Predictably, dynamite is the answer to all of their problems.

'Bulldog Martin' (by Bart Tumey): Bulldog Martin uses an invisibility pill to wreak havoc on some crooks who are trying to make a transaction. In the course of setting the crooks against each other, he scatters eleven million dollars into the crowd below. Thus the day is saved, and the economy is ruined, by Bulldog Martin!

Sunday, November 6, 2011

February 1940: More Fun Comics #53, Detective Comics #37

Cover by Bernard Baily

I wasn't able to find a copy of this, aside from a reprint of the Spectre story, so that's all I can write about. 

'The Spectre' (by Jerry Siegel and Bernard Baily): Continuing from last issue, Jim Corrigan has returned from the dead to battle crime with his supernatural powers. In this story he must rescue his fiancee from the crooks who killed him. This is fantastically eerie stuff. Jim kills one of the crooks just by looking at him, and makes another's flesh fall away from his skeleton with a touch. And even though the crooks are dealt with easily, Jim is still little more than a ghost, and must leave his fiancee forever. This is very good stuff, spooky and tragic. The art lets it down here and there, but overall it's still effective.

Cover by Bob Kane

'Batman' (by Bill Finger and Bob Kane): Batman goes up against foreign agents in this story, which never quite feels right. From the opening where Batman has gotten lost while driving around, to the numerous instances if him being bashed on the head from behind, he doesn't feel like the same character. And I feel like the tone has shifted from what has come before, in a way that I can't quite pinpoint. It's not a terrible story by any means, but there's something off about it that I can't quite put my finger on.

'Spy' (by Jerry Siegel and Maurice Kashuba): Bart takes on Ligoni, leader of the "Ring of Death", who has just bombed some government officials. This is a solid story of Bart going undercover, even though it doesn't stray from the usual formula.  It's a solid rendition of a familiar routine.

'Cosmo, the Phantom of Disguise' (by Sven Elven): Cosmo must stop a plot to hijack a  ship en route to England and sell it to an enemy nation. Part of his plan involves faking an explosion so that the ship will be evacuated, but I'm still wondering how that was done without crippling the ship as well. The story itself certainly has no explanation for me.

'The Crimson Avenger' (possibly by Jim Chambers and Harry Lucey): The Crimson Avenger is back, after a lengthy absence.  He hasn't been seen since Detective Comics #29! Very little effort is made to reintroduce the character, but I don't think it would be too hard to pick things up. In this story he tackles some kidnappers, which is a fairly dull starting point. Their ringleader ends up being a guy named J.N. Worthy, which seems fair enough, except for the scene where he seems surprised to be getting a note from the kidnappers. There's no reason he'd do so while alone in his own office.  It's just a cheap ploy to obscure the identity of the villain.

'Murder at Sea' (by John Randall): In this prose story, a professor is murdered and his secret plans are stolen. A boy named Billy figures out that the steward did it; his alibi was that he was writing a note at the time of the murder, but the note is too neat to have been written on the ship. It's just clever enough to work, but it's in the much-loathed "kids stop crooks" category, which is something I really hate.

'Speed Saunders, Ace Investigator and the Crime Roundup' (by Gardner Fox and Fred Guardineer): Speed is framed by crooks as a drunk, doused with whiskey and thrown in an alley. He's quickly demoted, but sets about getting his job back by starting a one-man war on crime. Normally I'm a sucker for this kind of thing, one guy just going around town and busting up every crook he finds, from the lowest to the highest. But this one just wraps up too neatly. It's the sort of story that works really well when it's drawn out and the crooks get their chance to retaliate, but here they just get rounded up, put on trial and sent to jail.

'Steve Malone, District Attorney' (by Don Lynch): This is a stock standard story about a kidnapping plot, where Steve goes to the rescue and saves the day, ticking all the cliche boxes as he goes. But there's an actual rape attempt by one of the kidnappers on their victim, which is definitely something that hasn't been done in DC comics to this point. It's all pretty PG in the way it's presented, but the intent is obvious. There's something to be said for this as a nod to realism, but it's not something I want to see in every story from now on.

'Cliff Crosby' (by Chad Grothkopf): This is a new strip. Cliff Crosby is friends with a reporter, and to be honest I'm not sure what it is that Cliff does. In this story, he and his friend get a lead on a missing judge, and find that he is being sold by a slave ring in South America. Cliff gets captured himself, saves the judge when he is thrown to a giant octopus, then wears the octopus on his head to frighten the slavers. It's not good, and the art is some of the worst I've seen. There are good panels here and there, but in every fight scene the perspective and scale are completely off. And Crosby has the world's tiniest arms.



'Slam Bradley' (by Jerry Siegel and Mart Bailey): Slam and Shorty are left a horse named Dynamite in a wealthy man's will, and before too long they have it racing in the Kentucky Derby. The usual shenanigans ensue, with crooked gamblers taking an interest, and of course Shorty ends up having to ride the horse in the derby. The plot elements here are as hackneyed as any other horse racing story, but the difference is in the presentation. Slam Bradley's stories are always laced with a knowing humour that raises them above the pack.

Wednesday, October 12, 2011

January 1940: More Fun Comics #52

Cover by Bernard Baily

'The Spectre' (by Jerry Siegel and Bernard Baily): Jim Corrigan is a policeman, and also engaged to socialite Clarice Winston. After Jim single-handedly stops a gang of crooks from robbing a warehouse, gangster Gat Benson decides to bump him off. Which he successfully does, by putting him in a barrel, filling it with cement, and dropping into a river. Corrigan dies, but before he can enter Heaven a booming voice tells him that it is his mission to return to Earth and eradicate crime. Corrigan awakens at the bottom of the river, finding that he is a ghostly apparition with the ability to fly and turn invisible. The story ends with him about to take revenge on Gat and his thugs.

This is quality stuff.  Siegel is really on his game here, drawing out the origin story into a compelling read. If I have one disappointment it's that it ends before Corrigan can assume the look he has on the cover of the issue. It's a minor quibble. The characters are relatively well-defined, Baily's storytelling is strong, and I want to see where it's going.

'Wing Brady' (by Tom Hickey): Continuing from last issue, Wing Brady and his men are defending Fort Miranda from an Arab tribe known as the Touaregs. Wing uses some rudimentary tactics to defeat them, but the story is well told. If I have one complaint it's that the Touaregs are never developed as characters. Faceless hordes usually make for uninteresting villains.

'Biff Bronson' (by Albert Sulman and Joseph Sulman): A mad scientist known as the Wizard has built a robot army, and he uses it to steal all of the silver from West Point. It probably cost him more to build the robots, but never mind that. Biff Bronson disables a robot, figures out that he can use it as a disguise, and determines to infiltrate the Wizard's hideout. To be continued! This is fun stuff.

'Radio Squad' (by Jerry Siegel and Martin Wheeler): Sandy and Larry go up against a safe manufacturer who has rigged his safes with secret panels that conceal the treasure placed within. He then plans to buy back the seemingly looted safes and collect the treasure himself. This starts off as an intriguing mystery, but the payoff is not as interesting as the set-up.

'Bust-Up in Borneo' (by Jack Anthony): Two adventurers rescue a young boy from savages by using flares. It's not awful. It just kind of exists.

'Lieut. Bob Neal of Sub 662' (by B. Hirsch and Russ Lehman): Bob and Tubby go up against a disguised yacht that is laying mines in the Panama Canal. This is solid if unspectacular stuff. It's continued next month, even though the story seems to be over. Perhaps whatever foreign power is responsible for the plot will retaliate.

'King Carter' (by Paul J. Lauretta): King and Red are in the Arctic, searching for a lost research expedition. It turns out that the expedition was killed by a rival outfit, who wanted the reward money for scientific data about the Arctic for themselves. This story is okay, but marred by some terrible exposition near the beginning, as King and Red spend a page telling each other things they already know.

'Detective Sergeant Carey and the Studio Mystery' (by Joe Donohoe): Carey investigates a murder on a movie set, in which an actor was shot while filming a scene but nobody can find the gun. The culprit turns out to be a cameraman, who killed the actor with a gun inside the camera. This story doesn't do anything particularly wrong, but it's still not very good.

'Sergeant O'Malley of the Red Coat Patrol' (by Jack Lehti): O'Malley goes up against a gang of robbers who have their hideout in a secret room behind the local bank. I was convinced they were living behind a waterfall, and was all set to write about how stupid O'Malley was for not figuring it out on the first panel. That's some effective misdirection from Lehti, the best thing about an otherwise mediocre story.

'Bulldog Martin' (by Bart Tumey): Bulldog is left a bottle of invisibility pills by a deceased scientist, and uses it to break up a gang of union racketeers. There are some decent comedy bits in this story that give some life to the very well worn plot. And I'm glad that this strip now has a hook of some sort, even if it's not a particularly original one.

Sunday, October 2, 2011

December 1939: Pep Comics #2, Top-Notch Comics #2, Action Comics #20, More Fun Comics #51

Cover by Irv Novick

'The Shield, G-Man Extraordinary' (by Irv Novick): The Shield goes up against a fleet of "Nordic" ships that is raiding US oil rigs near Porto Rico. This is pretty bland stuff, except for one scene where the Shield beats some sharks to death with a chain. But he's still very boring, and completely immune to harm. Hell, even Superman can be hurt.  The Shield needs a weakness of some sort.

'The Comet' (by Jack Cole): In the city of Tampa, a giant devil face has been appearing in the sky, uttering threats to those who disobey it and drawing cars full of loot into the sky. The Comet investigates, and finds a gang of crooks who have set the whole thing up with blimps, magnets and projectors. The Comet uses his disintegrator eyes to destroy the blimps and end their plot. This one had an intriguing set-up and some good action, but it wasn't quite as much gonzo fun as the first chapter.

'The Press Guardian' (by Abner Sundell and Mort Meskin): The Daily Express newspaper is threatened by a Moronian bundist group, and the Press Guardian puts a stop to them. This is fairly average, but the strip has been improved greatly by switching its hero's identity from the Falcon to the Press Guardian. At the very least his costume (now a suit and mask) is much better than the weird rainbow bird outfit he had before.

'Fu Chang, International Detective' (by Joe Blair and Lin Streeter): Fu Chang is targeted by devil worshippers who are trying to take over Chinatown. They summon an actual demon, but Fu Chang's magical chessmen defeat it. I enjoyed this one, mostly because it's got a premise that is so far unique.

'Sergeant Boyle' (by Abner Sundell and Charles Biro): This is a fairly stock standard tale in which Boyle exposes a messenger who is actually a German spy. It's all fairly boring until the last page, which is an impressive double page spread of a sprawling battle scene. I think it might be the first double page spread that I've seen in this blog so far, and it certainly had the desired impact.

'When the Red Men Rode' (by Creators Unknown): This prose piece about the death of the Apache chief Geronimo is closer to non-fiction than anything else. I rather enjoyed it. Geronimo sounds like a pretty bloodthirsty character, and I'd like to read more about him. (Admittedly, this story does not have an unbiased portrayal.)

'The Midshipman' (possibly by Bob Wood): Midshipman Lee decides to put himself ahead of the Navy in an army vs. navy race. But he has to turn back to help an injured team-mate, and the race ends as a draw. Lee learns a valuable lesson about teamwork, and I learn a valuable lesson about the crapness of sport-based comics.

'The Rocket and the Queen of Diamonds' (by Abner Sundell and Lin Streeter): A villain named Retlek wants the Rocket out of  the way, so he injects him with dope and pushes him at the queen with a knife in his hand. The Rocket is thrown in the dungeon, but once the drug wears off he escapes and wrecks the bad guys. The Rocket has lost all of the humility he had last issue, and now he's just another typical Golden Age hero.

'Kayo Ward' (by Bob Wood): Kayo Ward quits boxing to please his girl, but goes back after everyone starts calling him a coward. There's a great dirty trick played by the opposing trainer, when he sends Kayo a telegram telling him that a guy he punched in the street is now dying. But apart from that little bit of subterfuge I didn't find much to enjoy here.

'Bentley of Scotland Yard' (by Sam Cooper): A man is killed by a vampire, and Bentley has three suspects - his uncle, his fiancee, and his cousin. The story stops and asks the reader to guess who is the culprit (it was the uncle, who loved the fiancee, and is also not really a vampire) but to solve it you'll need a knowledge of the properties of leech saliva. This was alright despite some slight cheating with the mystery.

Cover by Edd Ashe

'The Wizard' (by Will Harr and Ed Ashe): The army of Sybernia (a stand-in for Japan) is massing to attack Alaska, and the Wizard must hold them off single-handedly until the US fleet arrives. This involves page after page of the Wizard just tearing through troops, tanks and a battleship. I had thought he was just super-smart, but when he tore the ship's mast down I figured he's got a bit of super-strength to go with it. I was all set to give this story a pass mark based on its crazy action sequences, but it ends with the Wizard leaving a calling card that says, "Our country, right or wrong our country", which to me is just a reprehensible sentiment.  (Actually, it's not so bad now that I look at the origin and meaning of it in context.  Knee-jerk anti-patriotism retracted!)

'Scott Rand in the Worlds of Time' (by Jack Binder): Scott Rand, with his new allies Thor and Princess Elda, travel to the super-futuristic year of 2000 AD, where New York is besieged by a martian army. They help turn the tide, and I enjoyed this if only for the scene of Thor piloting a spaceship and blasting martians.

'Swift of the Secret Service' (by Creators Unknown): Swift tackles a gang of counterfeiters in a story that couldn't be more generic.

'Dick Storm in the Foreign Legion' (by Harry Shorten and Mort Meskin): Dick Storm is asked to join the Legion to ferret out some spies that are giving information to a local tribe of hostile Arabs. This is okay, but the action scenes are a bit stiff.

'Air Patrol: Sky Raiders of the Western Front' (by Joe Blair and Ed Smalle): Ben Johnson is still seeking revenge on German U-boat captain Von Schiller, and he gets his chance when the captain starts sinking Allied ships. There's a terrific full page aerial dogfight, and the conclusion is reasonably satisfying. It's hard to see where this strip can go now that Von Schiller is dead. (Although, there was no body...)

'Drum Language' (by Creators Unknown): A college graduate is sent to an island of hostile natives to replace the current person in charge of dealing with them. It's a classic "experience vs. education" set-up in which experience supposedly wins out. In truth, all it's saying is that being shockingly racist is the best way to deal with native tribesmen. Actual dialogue from our hero directed at the native chieftain: "Make one cry and ketcham bang-bang from gun! March, you imp of Satan!"

'The West Pointer' (by Ed Wexler): Keith Kornell is contacted by a spy trying to get a look at his new rifle, but foils the plan with the help of some friends. It might have worked if there was any chance at all that he would take their offer, but that sort of moral ambiguity is foreign to the Golden Age.

'Stacey Knight, M.D.' (by Lin Streeter): Stacey Knight is a doctor and a detective, which I'm sure keeps him busy. In this story, he infiltrates a gang that is smuggling dope into the USA. The story isn't particularly interesting, but it does have some decent action scenes.

'The Mystic' (by C.A. Winter): The Mystic exposes some fraudulent psychics, who send some thugs after him. I'm quite amused by the way he uses simple magicians' tricks to battle them, but the way he refers to them as "boys" in every single panel is beyond camp. Also, the Mystic has his phone set up to ring police headquarters regardless of the number that is dialled, which is absurdly impractical.

'Manhunters' (by Jack Cole): In this true story, the police track down a kidnapper and cop killer. The action scenes that bookend this are quite good, but the actual police work in the middle is beyond tedious. When even the narration is telling you it's boring, something is wrong.

Cover by Joe Shuster

'Superman' (by Siegel and Shuster): On holiday in Hollywood, Clark Kent saves starlet Dolores Winters from an assassin. He's invited to her house for an interview, but when he gets there she gives him the cold shoulder. Things get weirder when she announces her retirement, and during a yacht party kidnaps all of the stars and holds them to ransom. At this point in the story I was getting bored, but things perk up when Superman goes to the rescue and discovers that Dolores Winters is actually the Ultra-Humanite, revived from the dead and transferred into her body. One wonders what perversions drove the Ultra-Humanite to pick her body in particular. Anyway, he escapes, still in the body of Dolores Winters, so when the Ultra-Humanite inevitably returns I expect him to still be a hot girl.

'Pep Morgan' (by Gardner Fox and Fred Guardineer): Pep saves a pilot from a burning plane, and ends up becoming his co-pilot in an airshow race. A gambler spikes the pilot's drink, and Pep has to win the race and land the plane alone. Looks like Pep is back to being insufferably great at everything, except starring in good stories.

'Chuck Dawson' (by Homer Fleming): Chuck finds a dead body, and the real killers blame him. There's a shootout, but Chuck escapes and vows to deal with them later. I seriously doubt he will, given how self-contained Fleming's work has been of late.

'Clip Carson, Soldier of Fortune' (by Bill Finger and Bob Kane): Clip is still hauling a load of ivory through the jungle. Last issue he befriended some cannibals by giving them harmonicas. In this issue, after being captured by the evil Wolf Lupo, Clip asks to play his harmonica as a last request, and the cannibals come to his rescue in a fairly brutal battle. One can only assume that Wolf Lupo and his cronies are eaten by the cannibals afterwards.

'Tex Thomson and the Zombies' (by Bernard Baily): Tex and his buddies are still captives of an African tribe that tries to turn them into zombies. It turns out that salt is a cure for the zombie formula (which ties well into some zombie mythology), so Tex revives the zombie army and they all escape. It's not bad, but doesn't do a lot with the premise.

'Five Star Trap' (by Frank Thomas): A kid newspaper salesman who witnesses a murder is used to flush out the killer. It's very dull.

'Three Aces' (by Bert Christman): Gunner, Whistler and Fog come across a distress signal written in the snow. Gunner bails out and finds an old man and a girl who were shot by fur trappers. Because no planes can land in a blizzard, Gunner and the girl are forced to survive for a week in the snow, fighting off wolves with bullets and gun butts. Eventually they're rescued, and just when I was setting myself for a good survival horror story.

'Zatara the Master Magician and the Moon Men' (by Gardner Fox and Fred Guardineer): When a mysterious mist arises on coasts all over the world, killing anyone who inhales it, Zatara is led to the culprits by a winged girl named Nala. Alien Moon Men are to blame, and Zatara kills them with their own gas before unleashing deadly winged snakes on the survivors. He is very ruthless for a man in a top hat. This is tons of fun, as usual, and next issue's story promises to see him on the moon with his new winged girl ally.

Cover by Sheldon Moldoff

'Wing Brady in Paris' (by Tom Hickey): Wing and Frenchy get something of a peaceful interlude, as their section of the French Foreign Legion is in Paris to take part in the Bastille Day celebrations. As the two of them lounge around in a bar they get into a brawl with a purse snatcher, talk to a pretty American girl, then foil an ambush from the same purse snatcher. It doesn't hold together as a story at all, and it doesn't seem to be leading into anything. But despite that, I enjoyed this as a change of pace. This strip is almost always some sort of life-and-death struggle, and it's nice to see the characters get to relax once in a while.

Also, I have learned that an Apache is what they call ruffians or gangsters in Paris, and not just a Native American tribe. It would have saved me a lot of confusion if I had known that before reading this story.

'Biff Bronson' (by Al Sulman and Joseph Sulman): Biff and Dan investigate the hatchet killings of seven Chinese men, and manage through dumb luck to find the culprit: the mayor of Chinatown. The protagonists display a very unpleasant racist streak throughout this story, culminating in Dan's mocking line of dialogue: "And that goes double, my fliend!"

'King Carter' (by Paul J. Lauretta): King and Red go to a South Seas tropical island to take pictures of the volcano-worshipping natives. As is the way of things in the Golden Age, said natives are vicious savages who try to kill the interlopers, and then out of nowhere the volcano comes to life and the whole island sinks. King and Red exchange quips with the ship captain while presumably hundreds of people drown to death no more than a few hundred metres away. Luckily for this story King fights a shark with a knife, and I'm always a sucker for a good bit of shark-fightin'.

'The Buccaneer' (by Bernard Baily): This strip spends a lot of time setting up a storyline about a man found cast adrift, and his treasure map, but then it veers into an unrelated plot in which Dennis Stone must rescue his love Regina's father from the pirate Jorgens. After the rescue, Regina's father says that he will pardon Dennis and allow him to marry Regina if he gives up his life on the seas. He happily does so. This would have been a fitting end to this series if not for the superfluous treasure map stuff at the start.

The final panel of the story is a promo for the Spectre. "Who is he?? What is he??" I'm happy to see that More Fun Comics, the last DC hold-out, is finally getting its own super-hero.

'"Kit" Strong' (by Maurice Kashuba): Kit Strong is a private investigator, supposedly the "greatest manhunter of all times". In his debut story he is called in to investigate the kidnapping and ransom of a wealthy man's daughter. Having been billed as a great detective, Kit starts his clue-gathering impressively, but in the end he triumphs mainly through dumb luck and punching. Kashuba's art is cursory, and only comes alive when he's drawing women, particularly women being manhandled or tortured. I don't hold high hopes for this as a series, and luckily for me this is its only appearance.

'Gambler's Luck' (by Jack Anthony): In this prose story, Truck Farel goes after a gambler called Ace Tripone to get him to stop dating his sister. During their scuffle Ace is accidentally shot and killed. I'm really not sure what the author was going for here. Ace is presented as the bad guy, but all we ever see him do is defend himself, and on his deathbed he doesn't tell the police that Truck shot him. I've yet to see anything particularly nuanced from Jack Anthony, so I'm going to assume the straightforward approach: that Ace was a bad dude who got what was coming to him. If that's the intended story, then it's an utter failure.

'Lieutenant Bob Neal of Sub 662' (by B. Hirsch and Russ Lehman): Bob and the crew of Sub 662 find gold at the bottom of the ocean, and must mine it while avoiding foreign spies. It's fairly dull as a spy story, and the main antagonist never really gets an ending to her story.

'The Flying Fox' (by Terry Gilkison): Rex Darrell investigates the disappearance of a wealthy aviator, and finds a plot involving a gang of crooks, an island, and some buried treasure. The villain, Bayou Borg, escapes with the treasure at the end, with the dreaded To Be Continued. This would have been adequate, but the deluge of exposition at the beginning sucked all of the life out of it.  And despite the cliffhanger, this is the last we see of Rex Darrell, who I'm going to assume is killed in his attempts to capture Bayou Borg.  Given the villain's name, I expect that Darrell's corpse will be dumped in a swamp somewhere, missed by no one.

'Detective Sergeant Carey and the Wheels of Death' (by Joe Donohoe): Carey and Sleepy are called in to investigate death threats against a champion race car driver. If only they had seen that one of his rival drivers was a baron they could have solved the mystery before he got murdered.

'Sergeant O'Malley of the Red Coat Patrol' (by Jack Lehti): O'Malley goes up against a gang of gold thieves in a lacklustre story. Lehti pretty strongly establishes a realistic setting, then expects us to believe that a man thrown off a cliff can be lassoed to safety by an Indian.

'Bulldog Martin' (by Bart Tumey): Bulldog investigates a haunted house, and discovers that it's really the work of someone trying to scare off potential buyers while he looks for the treasure inside. This one pulls out all the cliches, but it does have an amusing conclusion when Bulldog tries to knock a secret door down with a sledgehammer and clobbers the crook standing behind it.

Monday, April 11, 2011

December 1938: More Fun Comics #39

Cover by Creig Flessel

'The Masked Ranger' (by Jim Chambers): The Masked Ranger rescues a man who has been falsely accused of murder from a lynch mob, and then gets involved with the machinations of a renowned gambler. No doubt the two plots are connected somehow. There's an adequate mystery being set up here, but it's not particularly interesting me.  The novelty of the cowboy wearing a mask is fading.

'Johnnie Law' (by Will Ely): Johnnie Law stumbles across a diamond smuggling racket, and defeats the smugglers with the time-honoured tactic of calling the police.  At least this time he did it with a phone he had installed himself in the smugglers' cave.

'Radio Squad' (by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster): Sandy and Larry investigate a "monster" that has been killing people. Two great danes are the real culprits, as well as the master who trained them. This was not bad, and at the very least it had me wanting to see the mystery's solution. I figured it would be an animal of some sort, but I was convinced that it would be the usual ape.  Great danes are a great untapped resource as far as fictional animal maulings go.

'Fun on Wheels' (by Gardner Fox): This is a prose story continued from last issue (which I was unable to read due to a bad scan).  It's about a bicycle salesman who is trying to prop up his business, marry a girl, and stop the crooked politicians in his town. I'm certain that this is reprinted from an earlier issue. I remember enjoying it then, but without having read the set-up from last issue it's not quite as much fun this time.

'Detective Sergeant Carey' (by Joe Donohoe): Carey investigates a psychic who is hypnotising butlers, maids and chauffeurs so that they can help him rob their wealthy employers. In what may be a bit of parody, there's a situation where Carey is getting beaten up, and he wishes he'd called the police earlier. Then a policeman arrives to help anyway, because he was looking for Carey to give him a parking ticket. I can't work out if this is a piss-take or a lazy cop-out.

'Red Logan' (by Ed Winiarski): Red was last seen being lined up by a firing squad in the country of Boronia. He manages to escape and prove that he's not a spy, but makes an enemy of a munitions salesman in the bargain. As troops from a neighbouring country invade, Red is blown up with a big grenade by his new found nemesis. This one is pretty unremarkable in its execution, but at least the scope is fairly epic.

'Red Coat Patrol' (by Creig Flessel): This is a new strip about Constable O'Malley, a mountie.  This is the second ever DC strip about mounties, and I remember that the first was deadly dull; as a general rule, mounties are good only for comedy sketches, and not for genuine drama. Anyway, O'Malley deals with a fur thief pretty handily. The only remarkable thing about the story is a torture sequence, where the thief talks about O'Malley's beautiful body, and wants to "have the pleasure of making him squeal like a pig!"

'The Magic Crystal of History' (by Homer Fleming): The crystal shows Bobby and Binks the events of the Spanish Armada, and its defeat by a smaller English fleet. And then at the end, after Binks says a few things to put these events into historical perspective, Bobby just randomly mentions that Shakespeare was around doing stuff at the time as well. Come on kid, stay focused!

'Gary Hawkes' (by Bob Jenney): Gary deals with a movie director who is arranging for the deaths of his stunt pilots as a way to bring his studio into disrepute, over revenge for something or other.  Again this story is very dull, which seems to be par for the course for this issue of More Fun Comics.

'Lieut. Bob Neal of Sub 662' (by R. Lehmann and Russ Hersch): Bob and his crew are tasked with defending a shipment of silver on its way to China. The scan of this story was very blurry, and besides that it was getting late and I was utterly knackered.  I see that Bob had to wrestle a giant octopus, so I'm really disappointed that I couldn't read this one.

'Wing Brady' (by Tom Hickey): Wing manipulates one of the men who framed him into shooting another, and is about to have a confrontation with the third.  I thought that the third guy was disposed of already, so it's disappointing to see him back in the story already.

'Buccaneer' (by Bernard Bailey): Dennis Stone is wounded in a duel with Captain Klaugh, and his crew work to get him off the ship while the battle still rages.  Now I love a good sword-fight, and will watch any terrible movie with a bit of swash and buckle in it, but this can't even hold my interest.

COUNTDOWN TO BATMAN: 15 days!

Tuesday, April 5, 2011

November 1938: More Fun Comics #38

Cover by Creig Flessel

'The Masked Ranger' (by Jim Chambers): This wraps up the Night Raiders plot. It was building quite nicely, I thought, with the various characters gradually heading towards a final conflict, but then it all finishes in the space of two pages, with barely a shot fired.  It's a disappointing conclusion.

'Gary Hawkes' (by Bob Jenney): Gary Hawkes also wraps up his first storyline, in which he's been hired by the nation of San Columbo to fight would-be dictator Colonel Rodista.  Rodista is a cold bastard, ordering the bombing of every surrounding village just because he's in a bad mood. Gary goes undercover and becomes his confidante, then kidnaps him at gunpoint and takes him to the authorities.  Everyone is happy, but I can't help but wonder about Rodista's army, which is still out there and intact. Surely one of his lieutenants would take over?

'Radio Squad' (by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster): Sandy and Larry are fired up for adventure by a cop movie, and then disappointed to be assigned by their chief to help set up his wife's party. But as is the way with such things, the swami who is providing the entertainment is a jewel thief, and the boys get their excitement after all. This is fairly average by this strip's standards, but it was enjoyable seeing Sandy and Larry on their time off.

'Fun on Wheels' (by Gardner Fox): This is a prose story, but I gave up on it due to the blurry scan I have. I don't need my eyeballs exploding over this nonsense. It's to be continued next month, so maybe I'll be able to catch up with it then.

'Johnnie Law' (by Will Ely): Johnnie Law tackles a group of bank robbers who killed some cops. The entire strip is Johnnie and his partner Helen just laying into these guys, pummeling and shooting them into submission. That sort of thing can work if the situation is set-up well enough, but there's no background here.  We just know the bad guys are bad because we're told they're bad, and that makes it much less satisfying when they get wrecked.

'Rex Darrell' (by Terry Gilkison): This is another story I had to give up on. These blurry scans are murder.

'Mob Fury' (by Creators Unknown): This is a one-off story about a deputy who has to get a wanted man away from an angry mob who wants to hang him. It's alright.  I wouldn't mind more of these stand-alone stories.

'The Magic Crystal of History' (by Homer Fleming): This depicts the life of Mary, Queen of Scots. It would be nice if this strip could get away from English history for a while.

'Detective Sergeant Carey' (by Joe Donohoe): Carey investigates a string of disappearances at a museum, only to find the curator is collecting test subjects for his immortality experiments. This story barrels along from one crazy moment to the next, and it works on that basic level. It's not really good, but it is eventful.

'Lieut. Bob Neal of Sub 662' (by R. Lehmann and Russ Hersch): Bob Neal deals with some ammunition smugglers in Central America. The story is pretty average, and it has some pretty outrageous South American stereotypes, and the obligatory femme fatale who falls for the hero and then gets killed.  It's not over-the-top enough to get away with the cliches.

'Wing Brady' (by Tom Hickey): Wing finally makes some progress with his revenge. He's been needling Von Blarcom for months, and now the guy finally snaps and beats Wing, who just takes it. Of course there's another officer present, and Von Blarcom is arrested and sent to jail. With one down, Wing and Frenchy move on the next victim. This one's still holding my attention.

'Buccaneer' (by Bernard Baily): Captain Stone leads a raiding party on Captain Klaugh's ship to rescue some slaves.  The battle is still going when the strip finishes, so I suppose we'll see how it ends next issue. Again, there's nothing remarkable here.

Tuesday, March 29, 2011

October 1938: Detective Comics #21; More Fun Comics #37

Cover by Leo O'Mealia

'Speed Saunders' (by Gardner Fox and Fred Guardineer): Speed tackles a mobster who has murdered an author whose research led her to his hideout.  The little details in this strip are more interesting than the main plot. There's a panel of Speed reading an issue of Detective Comics, which raises all sorts of questions. And then there's the murder victim's secretary, who is seen during the climactic fight wresting a tommy gun from a gangster and socking him in the jaw. She's officially the most impressive female in DC comics yet.

'Larry Steele' (by Will Ely): Larry deals with a shonky doctor and lawyer who have hired an acrobat to fake being hit by a car, and thereby blackmail the driver into giving them lots of money. It's as averagely done as you'd expect.

'Buck Marshall' (by Homer Fleming): Buck goes up against a crooked deputy who is intimidating people into committing crimes for him, then shooting them and collecting the reward money. Buck actually gets shot and spends three weeks recovering, which makes this one a little more dramatic than the usual Buck Marshall story.

'Spy' (by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster): Bart and Sally are assigned to show Baron von Huldorf (a known spy) around, and tip him off to some unimportant confidential information while keeping the good stuff secret. They end up humiliating him and driving him from the country, but this is just a prologue of sorts, as their actions become the final straw in getting international spy Lorenzo Rica to decide to kill them once and for all. Again it's a pretty good story, as Siegel and Shuster have a knock for taking pedestrian material to a higher level than their contemporaries.

'Fu Manchu' (by Sax Rohmer and Leo O'Mealia): A detective on Fu Manchu's trail turns up dead, and Petrie and Nayland Smith have to go to his house to get his case book. Will they make it before Fu Manchu? This is transitional stuff until the next set piece starts, but it still succeeds in deepening the mystery. And with such a slow build, I'm just dying for Fu Manchu to appear in person.

'The Crime in Stone' (by Gardner Fox): This is a short prose story about a detective investigating the murder of a notorious racketeer. It's one of those where the detective immediately solves the mystery and gets the culprit to confess without even trying, so there's no drama at all.

'Bruce Nelson and the Song of Death' (by Tom Hickey): The story continues, with Bruce still investigating the murders of two showgirls. In this installment someone tries to drop a sandbag on Bruce's head, and he spends the rest of the story solving that mystery; it was Mrs. Warren, the wardrobe mistress. But whether that gets him any closer to solving the real mystery is not yet revealed, as the story's still to be continued.  It's a perfectly decent middle chapter that lets the mystery develop at a natural pace.

'The Crimson Avenger' (by Jim Chambers): This has a very simple story this month, as the Crimson Avenger busts up a gang that is digging up graves looking for $50,000 that was buried with a bank robber.  If this didn't feature a guy in a costume, I'd be panning it.

'Steve Malone, District Attorney' (by Gardner Fox and Artist Unknown): This gets my attention instantly when Steve is told that his Russian friend Big Jim has been shot. I remember him from a few chapters ago, and I rather liked him, so I had an instant investment here. The shooting was in revenge for when Jim and Steve caught the Fellini gang together, and when Steve investigates he finds the culprits are also smuggling dope via pigeons. So the actual plot isn't that interesting, but the use of Big Jim got me caught up in it. It's too bad the writer had to go and ruin things by using the term "chink" in the narrative captions.  I can almost forgive it when it's in dialogue, because that could just be specific to that character, but if it's in the captions there's no one to blame but the writer.

'Slam Bradley' (by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster): Slam and Shorty head to Egypt looking for money, and fall afoul of Seth, one of Slam's old enemies and a slave trafficker.  Slam takes him down in a decent action-adventure story, but along the way he has some dodgy interactions with one of Seth's slave girls. She is sent to kidnap Slam and hold him at gunpoint, but seems unable to resist when he takes her veil off and starts kissing her. Then later in the story she comes to his aid and sacrifices her life to save him.  That Slam Bradley must be one hell of a kisser.

Cover by Creig Flessel

'The Masked Ranger' (by Jim Chambers): The Masked Ranger is still after the Night Raiders, but he doesn't get far, because most of the story focuses on the two girls he rescued last issue, and their dodgy uncle.  It's not bad, especially for a Golden Age western, but the title character should be in it more.

'Gary Hawkes' (by Bob Jenney): Gary has become famous after the kidnapping he foiled last issue, and a South American country has hired him to stop a mad colonel bent on dictatorship.  I wouldn't be too worried about this colonel, because even in private where he'd undoubtedly be speaking his native tongue he can barely form a coherent sentence. This one continues next issue.

'Wing Brady' (by Tom Hickey): Wing spends yet another strip needling Von BlarcomBlarcom has finally snapped, and I'm looking forward to seeing how it pans out next issue.

'Touchdown' (by Richard Martin): This is a football prose story in which a player who can't run is called in to replace an absolute champion. For starters, I know nothing about American football, so a lot of the terminology flew over my head. And the conclusion (in which the coach puts a firecracker in the player's pants to make him run faster) is telegraphed from very early on, but treated like a grand revelation after it happens.

'Johnnie Law' (by Will Ely): Johnny Law is still in pursuit of the ammunition smugglers, who are escaping in their ship.  At first I thought that there was a big hole in this story's plot, but then I realised that my scan is missing a page, so I can't really review it. I don't feel like I'm missing anything.

'The Magic Crystal of History' (by Homer Fleming): This shows the events surrounding King Philip II of Spain's persecution of the Netherlands, and William of Orange fighting back.

'Red Logan' (by Ed Winiarski): Red is in Boronia, where the leader of the nearby country of Blurbia has been assassinated. With the two countries on the brink of war, Red tries to get into the palace, but is captured and put before a firing squad. The stakes may be high, but the storytelling is dull. The only interesting thing is a passing mention of Slam Bradley.

'Ginger Snap' (by Bob Kane): Ginger is fishing in a lake and catching lots of gumboots and such. Then she's using her rod to dunk kids in the water as a way of providing swimming lessons.  How one relates to the other is beyond me.

'Detective Sergeant Carey' (by Joe Donohoe): Carey is staying in a cabin that is said to be haunted. I enjoyed this one, because it's a total Scooby Doo plot (albeit 30 years early).  And Carey's sidekick talks about ectoplasm, which I always thought was a Ghostbusters thing, but I now know is more of an early 20th century paranormal charlatan thing.

'Rex Darrell' (by Terry Gilkison): This is a new strip about an aviator and investigator, known by crooks as "The Flying Fox".  In this story a pirate gang has kidnapped an inventor, as they plan to take over an aircraft carrier that he designed.  The coup goes off well, but Rex beats them by heroically calling the authorities in.  Seriously, there are far too many Golden Age stories that are resolved when the hero calls the police.  It's not a good way to end a story.

'Lieut. Bob Neal of Sub 662' (by B. Hirsch and R. Lehman): Bob Neal and his crew take on some pirates (they seem to be a big part of the zeitgeist at this point). There's not much to recommend this one, although there is a startling scene in which a captured Bob has lit matches jammed under his fingernails.  The problem with the scene is that he continues along afterwards as though it never happened.

'Radio Squad' (by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster): This begins with a pretty cool riot in the streets, then the plot swerves into being about a jewel thief called "The Mastermind".  I enjoyed the novelty and carnage of the first half, but the second was the usual bland material.

'Buccaneer' (by Bernard Baily): Dennis Stone captures Capt. Klaugh, then goes after the real leader of the slave traders. A combination of sleepiness and a bad scan mean that I didn't follow this one very well.

Thursday, March 24, 2011

September 1938: More Fun Comics #36

Cover by Creig Flessel

'The Masked Ranger' (by Jim Chambers):  This new strip features the eponymous hero, a masked cowboy who fights crime with the help of his horse Star and his Mexican sidekick Pedro. In this story he goes up against the Night Raiders, a gang who are trying to get both halves of a treasure map. It's really not that much better than the other cowboy serials, but the addition of various pulp hero trappings livens things up a bit. The story continues next issue.

'Three Musketeers' (by Sven Elven): This continues with D'artagnan and Athos still making their mad ride to London. It remains quite exciting.

'Wing Brady' (by Tom Hickey): Wing continues stalking his enemy Von Blarcom, and telling him about the horrors of El Brunda prison. He also finds time to survive an assassination attempt.  This is still really well done, and I actually want to find out how it ends, which is more than can be said for a lot of the other serials in this issue.

'Last of the Killers' (by Tex Horton): This is a prose story about a US State Marshall tracking down a murderer in Tombstone.  It manages to evoke the atmosphere of the old west quite effectively, and this authentic sense of place makes it better than most of the other DC prose stories.

'Johnnie Law' (by Will Ely): Johnny Law was last seen chasing arms smugglers into a thick sea fog. There's a bit of a battle on the ocean, and some of the smugglers are arrested, but the bulk of them are getting away in their ship as the strip ends.  To be continued!  This is fairly sedate for a story with a boat chase and tommy guns.

'The Magic Crystal of History' (by Homer Fleming): Bobby and Binks witness the rise of Queen Isabella of France, and the story of Christopher Columbus. It's hard to evaluate this series, because it's more of a history lesson than a story. But I'm usually interested to read them, so it must be doing something right.

'Red Logan' (by Ed Winiarski): Red was being attacked by a shark last issue.  He deals with it, while his friend and Russian stereotype Ivan captures the foreign agents who put him in the water in the first place.  The rest of the strip has them arriving in Boronia and looking around, with the cliffhanger being that the local dictator has been killed.  I honestly never thought a strip with a man knifing a shark could be boring, but I was wrong.

'Gary Hawkes' (by Bob Jenney): This is a new strip about a pilot who has been giving flying lessons to a millionaire's daughter. When she is kidnapped he flies to her rescue, and the usual bland shenanigans take place. This story has nothing new to offer, and I doubt that it's going to do anything interesting in the future.

'Detective Sergeant Carey of the Chinatown Squad' (by Joe Donohoe): Carey is on vacation, but while riding a train he stumbles across a man who has been murdered by a doctor who is really a terrorist leader. It's really not good, and the art features quite possibly the ugliest woman in the history of DC comics to this point.

'Buccaneer' (by Bernard Baily): The story continues, with Captain Dennis being captured by Klaugh, who is still angry that Dennis refused to carry slaves for him. It's not that exciting, but it does end with the promise of a final confrontation between Dennis and Klaugh. I don't expect much, but that might be the best way to approach it.

'Radio Squad' (by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster): Sandy and Larry deal with a pyromaniac fireman, with the aid of a dog that Sandy rescues from a burning house. I'll say one thing for Siegel and Shuster, they're probably better than anyone else at this time at getting drama from a situation. Any story that ends with the hero wrestling a pyromaniac in a burning building is okay in my book.

'Lieut. Bob Neal of Sub 662' (by R. Hirsch and Russ Lehmann):  New strip! Bob Neal stops foreign agents from destroying Sub 662, and so becomes its second-in-command.  The only remarkable thing about the story is that it features the first use of punctuation symbols to replace a swear word (in a DC comic, anyway).

Sunday, March 20, 2011

August 1938: Detective Comics #19; More Fun Comics #35

Cover by Creig Flessel

'Speed Saunders' (by Gardner Fox and Fred Guardineer): This is a fairly average story about counterfeiters, but in its defense I didn't pick who the ringleader was.  Looking back there was only one suspect, but it still surprised me when he was revealed.

'Inspector Kent of Scotland Yard' (by George Newman): This is a new strip.  Kent goes up against the super-criminal known as The Raven, who steals a top-secret invisibility formula.  This is pretty decent, but I suspect that my opinion is coloured by a weakness for the trappings of super-hero fiction.  Throw in a colourfully named villain and an invisibility formula and I'm bound to mark a story up.

'Larry Steele' (by Will Ely): This has an unusual opening for the era.  This is the first time I've seen a strip open with an extensive back story.  It explains how a group of convicts came to be marooned on a desert island some twenty years earlier. A plane crashed on the island some years later, and the convicts killed all of the crew except for 14-year-old Dolores, who the convict leader planned to marry when she became old enough.  The story hits the present when Larry Steele lands there, but there's really not much to it from there.  The convicts convince him to fly them back to the USA, he starts to bond with Dolores, and then it's "to be continued".

'Spy' (by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster): This strip has its best installment yet.  Since the last story Bart and Sally have quit the spy game and are getting married.  But as is the way of things, they're summoned urgently half-way through their ceremony to deal with female saboteur Rosa Rinaldo.  This gives the story a bit of an edge in the dialogue, with Sally constantly making snide remarks about the interrupted marriage.  The majority of the story as they chase Rosa Rinaldo isn't out of the ordinary, but the finale really is something else.  Rosa has a mirror that can fire destructive rays, and, well... I'll let the picture speak for itself.


That there is my favourite panel yet.

'Fu Manchu' (by Sax Rohmer and Leo O'Mealia): Nayland Smith explains the ways in which Fu Manchu kills his victims as he and Petrie make their way home under the constant threat of death.  The suspense is really building effectively here, and Fu Manchu manages to be a compelling figure without yet having made an appearance.

'A Dead Case' (by Gardner Fox): This prose story is about a detective investigating the theft of corpses from the morgue. The culprit is a scientist who is trying to bring them back to life.  The subject matter is more in my wheelhouse than most of these prose stories, but this is still not very good.

'Bruce Nelson and the Coolie Smugglers' (by Tom Hickey): This installment is quite basic, being mostly made up of an aerial dogfight followed by Bruce exposing the leader of the smuggling ring. Usually this is one of my favourite strips in the issue, but this one didn't excite me.

'Cosmo' (by Sven Elven): Cosmo saves a gold shipment from some bandits. The only notable thing about this story is that there's a character who specifically hasn't met Cosmo before. Trust me, for this strip it's unusual.

'Steve Malone, District Attorney' (by Gardner Fox and Artist Unknown): Steve deals with a gang of bank robbers, with the help of his Russian friend Big Jim.  Big Jim turns out to be a fun character, and the action scenes are better than average. This isn't too bad.

'Slam Bradley' (by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster): Slam and Shorty head to a city of ape-men in Africa to rescue a museum curator.  This is fun stuff, and just reinforces that Slam Bradley is probably still the most consistently good strip I'm reading now.  And to top it off, Shorty finally gets the girl at the end.  Hooray!

Cover by Creig Flessel

'Radio Squad' (by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster): This story gives us a healthy dose of cross-dressing humour as Sandy and Larry go undercover to catch the robber of Lover's Lane.  Siegel and Shuster have proved that they can do very good comedy before, and they've produced another amusing story here.  (Also, the chief gives a big speech about how obedient Sandy and Larry are, forgetting how last issue they stole another cop's squad car.)

'Bloodhound Brown' (by Russell Cole): This is another of Cole's tiresome chase sequence strips. It's just panel after panel of dudes following each other.

'Buccaneer' (by Bernard Baily): This continues its story, in which Captain Dennis Stone just informed his crew that he doesn't want to trade in slaves any more.  His crew backs him up, but he has made an enemy of the villainous Captain Klaugh. It's a reasonably effective piece of set-up for future stories.

'High Stakes' (by Richard Martin): This is the second part of a prose story in which two foreign correspondents are trying to get important documents over the border in some sort of German-like country. With a bit of extra space to develop, it turns out much better than the usual fare for these stories.

'Johnnie Law' (by Will Ely): Johnnie Law is trying to capture some ammunition smugglers, but they get in their boat and sail away as a fog rolls in.  To be continued!  It's all set-up, and dull set-up at that.

'Magic Crystal of History' (by Homer Fleming): This is a strip in which two kids look into a crystal that shows them historical events. This time it details the reign of Henry VII, and the two guys who pretend to be the Earl of Warwick to drum up support and overthrow him. It's more interesting for the events it depicts, rather than the actual execution as a story.

'Red Logan' (by Ed Winiarski): Red is sent overseas as a foreign correspondent, but runs into trouble on the ship with some agents who are trying to kill a foreign secretary and take his top secret documents.  It's average stuff, but the cliffhanger has Red being menaced by a shark, and sharks make everything better.

'Detective Sergeant Carey of the Chinatown Squad' (by Joe Donohoe): Carey deals with a crazy murderer on a plane, which is at least a relief from his usual racist antics in Chinatown.  This strip has shifted over from New Adventure Comics.

The Fun Stamp Club: There is an article in here about stamps.  WHAT THE HELL, DC.  I thought we were past this nonsense.

'The Three Musketeers' (by Sven Elven): D'Artagnan and his companions are tasked to deliver a secret letter from the Queen to the Duke of Buckingham in London. The evil Cardinal's forces dog them at every turn, and it's a relatively tense read as the musketeers fall one by one.  Elven's work is much better when he's adapting other people's stories.

'Jack Woods' (by Jim Chambers): Jack is on the trail of cattle rustlers, and after a confrontation with them he's badly wounded. To be continued!  Honestly, it's like these cowboy strip have exactly one plot.  And to top it off, the strip doesn't appear again until Adventure Comics #39.  I'll have forgotten everything that's happened by then.

'Marg'ry Daw' (by Stan Aschmeier): This wraps up its kidnapping plot in a pretty poor fashion. Ace reporter Jack Kane is introduced and does all the work of exposing the kidnappers, leaving Marg'ry to make a one-panel cameo at the end.  It's bad form when the main character has absolutely nothing to do with resolving her own story.

'Wing Brady' (by Tom Hickey): Wing and his buddy Frenchy are still trying to get revenge on the men who sent them to prison for three years. Wing pretends that he has gone crazy so that he'll be allowed some leeway, and proceeds to stalk one of his enemies.  This is pretty good stuff, with some tense build-up.

'Sandra of the Secret Service' (by Will Ely): Sandra is trailing some thugs who have kidnapped an ex-crook to force him to give them his money. But the ex-crook tricks them and makes his escape. Sandra, being a girl, does nothing but summon the police.  And apparently this is the end of the series, and I'll never find out if Sandra catches that dude.  I'm going to assume that he's caught by a man, because even in their own strips the female characters are pretty ineffectual.

Tuesday, March 15, 2011

July 1938: More Fun Comics #34

Cover by Vin Sullivan

There's very little of note going on in this issue.  But a look at http://www.comics.org/ tells me that Stan Aschmeier, not Bob Kane as credited, is the penciller of 'Marg'ry Daw'.  I find it pretty amazing that even this early in his career Bob Kane is using ghosts and taking the credit.  I figured he wouldn't start that nonsense until Batman had blown up, but I guess not.

'Cap'n Jerry' makes its last appearance, and I honestly can't remember a thing that happened in it.  The aforementioned http://www.comics.org/ can't even tell me who created the thing, which shows you how significant it was.

'Wing Brady' (by Tom Hickey) starts a new story.  Wing and Frenchy have just spent three years in the French Foreign Legion's toughest prison between strips.  After one of their friends was murdered by other members of the Legion, they got in a fight and ended up being locked away.  And now, they're back for revenge!  It's a strong set-up.  And Frenchy continues with his new defining character trait of being a hot-headed drunk.  The only problem with this strip is that it ends on a cliffhanger threatening Wing's life: in a flashback!  Gee whiz, I wonder if he'll get out of this one!

It seems to me that the number of strips in More Fun Comics and New Adventure Comics is getting down to a tolerable level, so I'm going to start covering them in a more comprehensive fashion.  Because, you know, I don't have enough on my plate as it is.

Wednesday, March 9, 2011

June 1938: Detective Comics #17, More Fun Comics #33

Cover by Creig Flessel
 
'Speed Saunders' (by Gardner Fox and Fred Guardineer): This strip has a new artist in Fred Guardineer.  It doesn't make a lot of difference; the up-side of so many Golden Age heroes having bland personalities and appearance is that there's no huge shift when strips change creators.  In this story, goons kidnap the daughter of an inventor and hold her to ransom for his plans.  Speed rescues her in a fairly rudimentary fashion, and a big deal is made of his knowledge that snakes won't cross a rope made of hair.  It sounds so dubious that it just has to be true.

'Oscar the Gumshoe' (by Bob Kane): This is a one-page filler strip, in which Oscar is tricked into calling out a police squad by a gang of kids.

'Larry Steele' (by Will Ely): Larry is asked by a Hollywood buddy of his to go with him to look at an abandoned castle.  They stumble across some thugs holding a girl for ransom, get captured, escape, and by the end of the strip they have fallen into a trap door.  Again, this is very standard material, with little to liven it up beyond the setting.

'Cosmo' (by Sven Elven): Cosmo is caught up in the world of international intrigue.  An old friend of his (naturally) has invented a Very Big Cannon, only for the plans to be stolen by foreign agents.  Cosmo does his thing at a Russian ball, chatting up the duchess who also happens to be the one with the plans.  It's about as good as Cosmo ever is, but at least by dabbling in the spy genre it generates some interest.

'Fu Manchu' (by Sax Rohmer and Leo O'Mealia): An adaptation of the 'Fu Manchu' stories by Sax Rohmer begins in this issue (I believe that this is an adaptation of The Insidious Dr. Fu Manchu).  It's weird for me seeing Fu Manchu in a DC comic, as I usually associate him with Marvel's Master of Kung Fu.  Even so, this is actually quite absorbing, as detectives Petrie and Nayland Smith investigate a murder connected to the evil Fu Manchu, "the Yellow Peril incarnate in one man!"

'Spy' (by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster): Bart and Sally infiltrate the Hooded Horde, an organisation bent on taking over the USA.  With some colourful villains and some decent dialogue between Sally and Bart it's quite entertaining. This is definitely a strip on the upswing.

'Disaster on the Diamond' (by Gardner Fox): This prose story is about a betting syndicate that assassinates a baseball player to protect its winnings.  There's really very little that can be done with these two-pagers.

'Bruce Nelson and the Coolie Smugglers' (by Tom Hickey): On holiday after the Omar Diamond affair, Bruce finds himself in South Africa being asked to track down some smugglers.  At first he refuses, but pretty soon he's been implicated in the whole thing, and is on the run.  Most of the strip involves a desperate plan to get gas for his plane, which a is a surprising diversion from the main thrust of finding the real smugglers.  This story plays against expectations quite well throughout.

'Buck Marshall' (by Homer Fleming): Cattle rustlers.  Nothing to see here.

'Slam Bradley' (by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster): Slam is investigating the murders of radio singers, who are being killed with exploding microphones.  The culprit for this one is bleeding obvious.  There's a little bit of comedy when Shorty becomes a radio singer.  There's also the introduction of his twin brother Sporty, but that quickly goes nowhere.  A fairly average installment.

Cover by Vin Sullivan
 
'Buccaneer' (by Bernard Baily) is a new strip about pirates (one of the big genres of the day, it seems).  It involves a guy who kills his captain for harassing a woman, and then takes over the captain's position.  It's hard to muster up any enthusiasm for this one.

'Cap'n Jerry' (by R.A. Burley) is yet another pirate strip.  In this one, Jerry meets another captain who is mistreating some natives.  This one at least has a suitably reprehensible villain, but it's still quite average.

There's one more new strip called 'Marg'ry Daw' (by Stan Aschmeier), which is about a little girl who gets involved in the plots of some crooks led by her professor uncle.  Little girl adventure strips are also fairly common at this time, probably spurred on by the popularity of Shirley Temple.  But once again, this is uninteresting.

The real star of this issue is the latest installment of 'Wing Brady' (by Tom Hickey).  Wing's sidekick Frenchy has "like all Latins" a weakness for drink and girls.  So of course, Frenchy gets drunk, sexually harasses Wing's girlfriend, and gets in a big punch-up with Our Hero.  It's completely irrelevant to anything, but entertaining nonetheless to watch Frenchy go off the rails.

Sunday, March 6, 2011

May 1938: Detective Comics #16, More Fun Comics #32, New Adventure Comics #27

Cover by Creig Flessel

'Speed Saunders' (by Gardner Fox and Creig Flessel): Speed investigates a gang of opium dealers who have 1) killed an FBI agent; 2) hidden his corpse in the grave of Joseph Bannon, then 3) hidden Bannon in the sewers to be found by a telephone services company.  You know what, I can't make heads or tails of that plan either.


'Larry Steele' (by Will Ely): Larry was nearly burned alive by gangsters last month, and in this continuation he has to go back to the warehouse where he left their leader tied up to find out the location of a stash of valuable Persian rugs.  Of course the bad guy escapes, and most of the strip involves him and Larry fighting in a burning warehouse.  The problem I have with the whole thing (and with basically all of the Golden Age adventure strips) is that the good guy always seems to have the upper hand.  The creators never even try to pretend that he's in jeopardy.  It goes against every instinct I have about how a story should work.

'Cosmo' (by Sven Elven): Cosmo is called into a museum to investigate the theft of some Indian jewels. At first it seems like a glowing mummy is haunting the museum, but it turns out to be a jewel thief in disguise, Scooby-Doo-style.  (The museum curator mentioned finding the jewels on an expedition to India with Cosmo, and I vaguely remember a story that could fit the description. Perhaps this is a sequel?)

'Bruce Nelson in Too Many Crooks' (by Tom Hickey): This is the concluding chapter of the latest Bruce Nelson story. It wraps up the whole affair with the Omar Diamond pretty neatly; Bruce captures the smugglers and gets the girl, naturally.  It's probably the least interesting chapter in this serial for some time, and it's not helped by the many pages of exposition at the beginning.

'The Tattoo Trap' (by Gardner Fox): This is a very rudimentary prose story about a detective who goes undercover to catch a group of counterfeiters.

'Spy' (by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster): Bart and Sally investigate a man who is selling secret FBI documents to the ambassador of Baralvia.  There's a bit more intrigue than is usual in this strip, a couple of decent twists, and some decent banter between Bart and Sally.  I wouldn't mind if it was this good all the time.  (I just noticed this, but every one of these stories ends with Bart and Sally making out while their boss watches from behind his desk with a grin on his face.  It's a bit weird.)

'Finger-Print Farson' (by Russell Cole): This is a little more than a chase sequence, with Farson after a criminal.  It's not quite as pointless as his strip from Action Comics #1, but it's close.

'Buck Marshall' (by Homer Fleming): Buck tackles some pretty clever bank robbers. One of them was a ranch owner who hid his horse and declared it stolen, used that horse in the bank robbery, then traded it to a stranger so that he'd get the blame for the robbery.  It's about the smartest plan I've seen in this series.  Still, it seems like you can't turn around in Sage City without someone being murdered, robbed or rustled.

'Slam Bradley' (by Siegel and Shuster): 'Slam Bradley' is back to something resembling its best.  Slam and Shorty go undercover (complete with tap-dancing lessons) in a Broadway show to find out who has been robbing the theaters.  Events are complicated by the presence of Joan Carter, an investigator who specialises in tailing Slam and swooping in at the last minute to solve his case and claim the reward money. It's very funny stuff, and I'm really happy to see my favourite series regain some of its mojo.

Cover by Vin Sullivan
I don't have a scan of More Fun Comics #32, so I can't write about it.  But what's this I see over at http://www.comics.org/?  Doctor Occult's next appearance is in All Star Squadron #49?  Egad, that isn't until the 1980s.  It seems as though I've read my last Doctor Occult story for some time, which is a shame.  It was one of the more consistent and enjoyable strips around.

Cover by Creig Flessel
Oh my god, is it really the last appearance of 'Captain Jim of the Texas Rangers' (by Homer Fleming)?  Seriously, it's about time, because that strip had descended into farce a long time ago.  Captain Jim has been chasing the same gang of cattle rustlers since issue #1, making exactly no progress at all.  All that ever happened in it was an endless series of escapes and captures.  Needless to say, Captain Jim still hasn't caught the rustlers when it ends.

On a similar note, we see the end of 'Sandor' (also by Homer Fleming).  Sandor was raised in the jungles of India by wolves, and he spent all his time fighting against the evil Rajah Maharajah.  This strip had the same problem as 'Captain Jim' above, in that it never went anywhere.  It's just been months and months of Sandor running around in the tunnels under the Rajah's palace and killing his guards. Still, it did have Sandor wrestle a panther one time, so it had a leg-up on the cowboys.  When we leave Sandor, he is still trapped in those tunnels, and I like to think he stayed there for years and years, becoming some sort of legend to the Rajah's guards, who refuse to go down there for fear of meeting him.