Monday, January 31, 2011

September 1937: Detective Comics #8

Cover by Creig Flessel
 
'Speed Saunders' (by Gardner Fox and Creig Flessel): In this installment, Speed has an interesting moral dilemma.  After he chases down a criminal and is forced to spend time with him in a ship's crew, he finds that the guy is really not so bad, and is making a better life for himself as a seaman.  But it's his duty to arrest the dude, even though he doesn't want to.  However, as is the way with Golden Age stories, any internal conflict is done away with when it's discovered that the criminal is really innocent.  Moral dilemma averted!

'Larry Steele' (by Will Ely): Holy crap!  I don't know what happened, but this formerly mediocre strip just got good.  There's a very creepy story here about a mad scientist kidnapping celebrities to dissect them and create the perfect man.  Yes, it's a Frankenstein riff, but what's the entire comic book industry but riffing on other people's ideas?  It has one of the most effective splash pages I've seen in this era yet, and a decent cliffhanger.  Larry, you've got my attention.

'Cosmo' (by Sven Elven): Even this strip gets quite macabre this month, as Cosmo investigates the theft of corpses from a local morgue.  It turns out that the mortician is trying to bring them all back to life, and the whole thing is attributed to the catch-all motivation of insanity.  There's really no point to it, but I've gotten used to that with Cosmo.  Oh, and for a guy with Master of Disguise as his major gimmick, he uses no disguises in this story.

'Claws of the Red Dragon' (by Malcolm Wheeler-Nicholson and Tom Hickey): Argh! The kidnapping story ends in this issue.  The final installment begins well enough, with the threat of Sigrid's dismemberment followed by an all-out brawl between some Chinese Tongs and Lu Gong's criminal band.  Then, after the fight is done and all of the main bad guys have escaped, it slips into a shit-ton of exposition about the Jade Dragon that Lu Gong was hunting for, and the treasure it provides directions to.  About this point I started to get a sinking feeling, then lo and behold, there's a trailer for the 'New Adventures of Bruce Nelson'.  So much for a satisfying conclusion!  I was looking forward to the end of this and the prospect of something more interesting coming along.

'The Laughing Mummy' (y Gardner Fox): This is a prose story about a detective investigating strange murders in a museum that are connected to the mummy of an Egyptian princess.  Of course the museum curator is responsible, because he's the only other character in this story, and his motivation makes no sense at all.  Like the 'Cosmo' story above, we can blame it all on insanity.

'Bloodhound Brown' (by Russell Cole): This story features a guy who masquerades as a detective and goes around telling fanciful stories.  It's mildly diverting in the way that all of Cole's strips are.  At least they always look good.

'Spy' (by Siegel and Shuster): Bart and Sally protect a French envoy, only to find out that his would-be killer is impersonating him.  Which is all well and good, but it's hard to invest in these things without some background.  We never find out why anyone would want this French envoy dead, or even who the killer was.  I realise that the creators only had a few pages to work with here, but I feel like these are major story elements to be left out.

'Buck Marshall' (by Homer Fleming): Buck solves a murder case involving a boundary dispute between ranch owners.  Ho hum.

'Slam Bradley' (by Siegel and Shuster): This story opens with Slam stopping a bank robbery in a single panel.   The man responsible soon escapes, and Slam and Shorty have to chase him to the mountains of Kentucky.  Enter the hillbillies!  There are the usual hi-jinks with feuding families, and I was starting to feel like this would be an average installment.  But when Shorty finds himself held at gunpoint by a teenage hillbilly girl, then proceeds to seduce her, things really picked up.  Siegel and Shuster never get credit for this, but they are great at comedy.  The next strip promises Shorty's villainous rival, and that will definitely be a hoot.

It should also be pointed out that Slam Bradley and Shorty sleep in the same bed, in matching pyjamas.

Sunday, January 30, 2011

August 1937: More Fun Comics #24, New Adventure Comics #19

Cover by Vin Sullivan
 
The absurdity levels skyrocket in 'Marty McCann' (by Ed Cronin).  In the last issue he beat the number one contender for the world heavyweight title.  In this issue, through yet another series of ridiculous events, he beats up the actual champion.  There's something quite charming in the brazen stupidity of it all.

'Radio Squad' (by Siegel and Shuster) features a strange story about a guy named Harry Owens, who wanted to be a radio announcer but has ended up as a policeman.  He practises his announcing skills over the police radios, and gets simultaneously fired by the police and hired by a radio station.  It's an adequate story so far as these things go, but it's almost presented like Harry Owens is a real person.  He could be this guy, but there's no mention of a radio career on that page.  The time-frame matches up, at least.

'Doctor Occult' this month is another pretty good one from Siegel and Shuster.  A bunch of guys have been turning up dead in mysterious circumstances, with the letters H.D. on their forehead.  The culprit is a painter, who is killing them by painting them into lethal situations.  It's a well-used story element, but I just love the touch that he is signing all of his victims.

Speaking of which, the H.D. in question is Henri Duval, who the more attentive among you may remember as the star of one of Siegel and Shuster's earliest strips.  That version of Henri Duval was a swashbuckling musketeer-type character, and has no overt connection to this painting murderer, but it's still odd that they would recycle the name.

Cover by Creig Flessel
 
I'm struggling to find something to say about this comic, to be honest.  There are no new strips, no strips ending, and nothing really noteworthy going on.  Everything is just chugging along as before.  Normally I'd chime to say what's going on in 'Federal Men', but I'm tired of writing about how that strip has become a pale shadow of its former glory.  The only other thing going on is that 'Don Coyote' and 'Cal 'n' Alec' are back after a bit of a hiatus, and they're now being done by a guy named Ray Burley, who is not the originator of either strip.  Both were originated by Robert Leffingwell and continued by Bill Patrick, and among the better humour strips, but now they've lost a lot of their distinctiveness and flavour.  I'd probably be happier if they had just disappeared for good.

Wednesday, January 26, 2011

July-August 1937: More Fun Comics #23, New Adventure Comics #18, Detective Comics #7

Cover by Vin Sullivan
 
There's a new strip this issue: 'Marty McCann, Champion of the Navy', by Ed Cronin.  It's about a member of the US Navy who gets into an argument with the number one contender for the boxing world heavyweight title, and ends up beating him in a match.  It's mostly page upon page of two guys beating the hell out of each other, but not bad for all that.  At the very least it's a break from cowboys and detectives and such.

In other news, it turns out that in 'Doctor Occult' (by Siegel and Shuster) the title character was not dead, just drugged.  So his claim as the first ever resurrected comics character has been retracted.  He beats the Lord of Life this issue, and it must be said that Siegel and Shuster aren't the sort of creators who drag out their stories too much.

Cover by Creig Flessel
 
There's more from the Junior Federal Men Club this month.  In a remarkable display of gender equality, apparently girls can join as "auxiliary members".  But what do I know, maybe this really was progressive for the 1930s.

'Federal Men' (by Siegel and Shuster) is once again quite sedate, although there was a glimmer of interest when a man was strapped to a torpedo and fired from a moving train.  But where are the giant robots and atomic tanks and burning skyscrapers I once loved so much?

'Steve Conrad' (by Creig Flessel) continues to surprise me, having moved from being one of the most forgettable strips to one of the most memorable.  Steve has a fistfight with the Devachan this month, and the large, impactful panels seem like they've been influenced by Siegel and Shuster's work on 'Slam Bradley'.  I hope there are other creators taking notice as well.

Cover by Creig Flessel
 
'Slam Bradley' (by Siegel and Shuster): Speaking of which, this month Slam Bradley and Shorty go undercover as life guards to investigate the disappearances of people swimming in the ocean.  The actual plot is kind of a dud, because it's a whodunnit where the culprit doesn't even appear until he's exposed.  It makes up for it by being super-funny and entertaining.  It even opens with Slam having the time of his life, stopping a man from drowning by punching him in the jaw.  And next issue: hillbillies!  It's going to be awesome.

'Cosmo' (by Sven Elven): Once again, I'm amused that everyone on the planet is a close personal friend of Cosmo.  This time he investigates the murder of a pianist, and like the 'Slam Bradley' strip above the mystery is a total cheat.  Unlike Slam Bradley, there's nothing else of merit here.

'Claws of the Red Dragon' (by Malcolm Wheeler-Nicholson): Bruce Nelson finally meets the mastermind of the kidnapping scheme, Lu Gong, who has got to be the chattiest bitch in villain history.  I swear there's a panel where his word balloon takes up a quarter of the page.  Next month is the conclusion to the strip, and I have to give Malcolm Wheeler-Nicholson some props, because all of his strips have ended in a relatively satisfying manner so far.  Many others just keep chugging along with no end in sight, but he finishes his stories when their natural time is up.

'Rifles on the River' (by Guy Monroe): This is a prose story about some soldiers fighting bandits who steal an armoured train.

'Gumshoe Gus' (by Bill Patrick): I don't know what has happened to Bill Patrick. I used to really like his strip 'Don Coyote', which really was one of the better humour strips in these comics at the time, but 'Gumshoe Gus' isn't all that funny.  Perhaps it's the focus on a single character, as a lot of what made 'Don Coyote' work was the interplay between the three main cast members.

'Spy' (by Siegel and Shuster): Bart and Sally capture a plane manufacturer who shot down a zeppelin to stop it from hurting his business.  There's a little more tension to their relationship this month, but it's far from the focus I hoped it would be.  Also, this was almost certainly inspired by the Hindenburg disaster, as that had happened just a few months before this issue went on sale.

'Buck Marshall' (by Homer Fleming): Buck arrests a guy who killed the local ranger for not letting his cattle graze more.  Or something.  I confess to being very uninterested in cattle ranch politics.

'Larry Steele' (by Will Ely): Larry keeps driving back to New York, only for his pursuers to push a car down a hill on top of him.  He tracks them down with the help of the FBI, and I quite literally fight to stay awake.

'Speed Saunders' (by Gardner Fox and Creig Flessel): Speed Saunders tracks down a cowboy who got kicked out of the rodeo, and was shooting the performers for revenge.  It's a long way from the waterfront for Speed, which could be a boon, except that it makes him just like every other generic detective out there.  I think he should stick with his gimmick for the most part.

Saturday, January 22, 2011

Schedule: July-December 1937

It looks like more of the same here, with DC's core three books chugging along.  I can't wait for some variety in 1938.


July 1937
DC:
            Detective Comics #6
            More Fun Comics #23
            New Adventure Comics #18

August 1937
DC:
            Detective Comics #7
            More Fun Comics #24
            New Adventure Comics #19

September 1937
DC:
            Detective Comics #8
            More Fun Comics #25
            New Adventure Comics #20

October 1937
DC:
            Detective Comics #9
            More Fun Comics #26

November 1937
DC:
            Detective Comics #10
            More Fun Comics #27
            New Adventure Comics #21

December 1937
DC:
            Detective Comics #11
            More Fun Comics #28
            New Adventure Comics #22

June-July 1937: New Adventure Comics #17, Detective Comics #6

Cover by Creig Flessel
 
As I was reading the latest installment of 'Captain Bill of the Texas Rangers' (by Homer Fleming), it occurred to me that he has been trying to arrest the same damn gang of rustlers since the beginning of time.  The guy needs to hire Buck Marshall over from Detective Comics, because that guy goes through a different rustling outfit every four pages.

'Nadir, Master of Magic' (by Bill Ely) is a new strip about a magician detective.  His origin mentions the tragic death of his parents which inspired him to fight crime, so I guess he's a sort of Indian Wizard Batman.  His first adventure sees him trying to solve a pearl theft, and surviving a murder attempt on his own person.  Despite the premise, Nadir doesn't use any magic so far, and the whole thing ends in fairly limp fashion, to be continued next issue.  Still, I love Nadir's business suit and turban outfit.

Ever since the strip a few months ago where the Devachan went murderously nuts, 'Steve Conrad' (by Creig Flessel) has been a lot more interesting.  This month Steve breaks a giant vulture's neck with his bare hands, and he's taking over from Steve Carson of 'Federal Men' as the raddest action hero of New Adventure Comics.

Speaking of 'Federal Man', the Junior Federal Men Club is now in full swing, with instructions being issued to its members.  I didn't think this was so bad last time, but now it comes across as a little creepy, like someone trying to construct their own personal child militia.  But then I've never been sold on patriotism or any of that sort of thing.  The good intentions of the 1930s can look a little odd when viewed from a modern perspective.

The actual 'Federal Men' strip (by Siegel and Shuster) is a fairly bog standard story about a jewel thief.  It feels like a really long time since this strip was the best thing around.

Checking in quickly with the resident novel adaptations, I'm getting quite absorbed by H. Rider Haggard's 'She' (adapted by Sven Elven).  On the other hand, I honestly can't keep track of 'A Tale of Two Cities' by Charles Dickens (by Merna Gamble).  It bores me to tears, and seems to gain nothing from being adapted into a visual medium.

Cover by Creig Flessel
 
'Speed Saunders' (by Gardner Fox and Creig Flessel): This strip has gone crazy this month, with what might be the very first intelligent ape story in DC history.  Anything with apes and mad scientists usually piques my interest, and this one had the right sort of manic energy to pull it off.  One thing to note, though, is that Speed is now seemingly back with the Harbour Patrol; I suppose he was rehired rather quickly after getting fired a couple of months ago.

'Larry Steele' (by Will Ely): This strip sees Larry's plane being shot down while he's on his way to Hollywood to investigate the celebrity disappearances.  Unremarkable stuff.

'Cosmo, Phantom of Disguise' (by Sven Elven): Cosmo foils some diamond smugglers.  Man, there are jewel thieves all over comics in the 1930s.

'The Claws of the Red Dragon' (by Malcolm Wheeler-Nicholson and Tom Hickey): In this extra-long installment, Bruce Nelson is recaptured and about to meet the guy in charge of all the Chinese villains in this strip.  I fully expect some outrageous stereotyping next month.

'Tropical Trouble' (by Gardner Fox): This is a prose story about a secret agent sent to rescue another agent in Honduras.  It sets up a mystery about why the hero, a desk clerk, is even sent on the mission, then doesn't bother to answer it.

'Gumshoe Gus' (by Bill Patrick): Gus goes undercover as a crazy hobo to find a criminal hiding in the nut-house, and by the end of the strip he's in his own padded cell.  I'm not sure if this is a punchline or the set-up for a continuing story.

'Spy' (by Siegel and Shuster): The new status quo begins, with Bart Regan and his fiancee Sally both working as spies.  And magically all of the romantic tension from the previous strips has gone, and they're working together in perfect harmony.  It's a waste of a promising set-up.

'Mr. Chang' (by Ed Winiarski): Our resident Chinese sleuth deals with a mad scientist who is creating giant slaves by injecting people with chemicals.  It seems to me like the mad scientists in these strips are all starting to get a little crazier, and I heartily approve.  This is the final appearance of Mr. Chang, and he goes out as the least racist portrayal of a Chinese character in these comics so far.

'Slam Bradley' (by Siegel and Shuster): 'Slam Bradley' is once again very good, as Slam and Shorty go to Mexico to stop a bandit gang.  There is a definite formula to these strips, and it's followed every month.  Shorty always goes undercover, Slam always wins by punching a guy super-hard, and there's always a gag at the end with Slam getting the girl and Shorty missing out.  I also love the standard opening page, usually a full page shot of Slam Bradley just brutally wrecking some random villains.  So far the formula is working, and I anticipate this strip more than any others.

Tuesday, January 18, 2011

June 1937: More Fun Comics #22

Cover by Vin Sullivan
 
I'm usually quick to praise the work of Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster, but not everything they do is great.  Case in point: the latest installment of 'Radio Squad'.  The long-running storyline here has involved policeman Sandy Keane just flat out arresting all of the organised crime bosses in town and hauling them off to court.  We've had months of court room drama, where it's become obvious that the court itself is so corrupt that Keane is never going to win.  And then it just ends when, without any previous set-up, the local governor just walks into the court, declares everybody corrupt, then tells them they're all going to jail.  With no evidence and no real trial.  It's a particularly egregious example of how abruptly and nonsensically some of these stories end.

'Doctor Occult' on the other hand is a lot more interesting.  He was killed in the last story, and this one opens with his funeral.  And yes, he is actually for real dead.  Then of course the villainous Lord of Life brings him back with a ray gun, with the threat that he'll die again without regular monthly zaps.  Which makes Doctor Occult the first ever DC character (and possibly the first ever comics character) to die and then return to life.

'Jungle Fever' by Ed Winiarski has made the jump over from New Adventure Comics, but it needn't have bothered, because this is the last installment.  The main characters were still wandering around the island and getting shot at by the locals, and as usual I like to think that they were brutally murdered and never heard from again.

Monday, January 17, 2011

June 1937: Detective Comics #5

Cover by Creig Flessel
 
'Slam Bradley' (by Siegel and Shuster): This issue gets off to a cracking start, with the best 'Slam Bradley' strip yet.  It opens with him just cold punching his former schoolyard bully, and from there he has to go undercover as a school teacher.  Among other amusing tidbits, we learn that he was actually called Slam Bradley in the 6th grade, so that could very well be his real name.  He's probably the worst schoolteacher ever, as the only solution he has to any problem is to punch it or yell at it.  But this is really fun stuff,  and I'm enjoying the running gag where Slam gets the girl at the end of the strip, while his sidekick Shorty is rather less well rewarded.  Next month we are told that Bradley is facing off against Mexican bandits, which promises to be great.

'Buck Marshall' (by Homer Fleming): Buck foils a robbery this month, which is at least a break from the incessant string of cattle rustlers.  But the mystery is kind of ruined as soon as a guy named Kane shows up.  His name is Kane, of course he's the culprit!

'Claws of the Red Dragon' (by Malcolm Wheeler-Nicholson and Tom Hickey): Bruce Nelson has finally found the kidnapped girl Sigrid, so at least there's some plot progression.  But it's still very generic compared to how it began.

'Winged Death' (by Fredric Wells): This is a text story about a detective investigating airplane sabotage.  I swear it took me longer to read this thing than the rest of the issue combined.

I haven't mentioned these before, but Russell Cole (aka Alger) has a short and supposedly humorous detective strip in each issue.  I honestly can't figure out the point of this one at all, or even how the mystery is solved.  I feel that way about a lot of Alger's work, where I either don't get the joke or don't understand the ending.  Is it a lack of context due to the many decades since this was published, or a deficiency on the part of the creator (or possibly myself)?  Who knows.

'Spy' (by Siegel and Shuster): 'Spy' takes an interesting turn this month.  Bart Regan's fiancee Sally is still stalking him on his missions, trying to get him to confess that he still loves her.  At this point I want to advise Bart to get the hell out of there, because that is one seriously fixated woman.  By the end she's become a spy herself, so we're getting a format change, with two leads who are romantically involved in a sort of antagonistic fashion.  It could be good.

'Cosmo' (by Sven Elven): Cosmo disguises himself as a Portuguese sailor to foil dope smugglers as boringly as possible.

'Larry Steele' (by Will Ely): This is a new strip about a detective who is investigating missing celebrities.  It just sort of ends mid-stream with no real conclusion or cliffhanger, so I guess it continues next month.  But it's not as though the creator has provided me with a compelling urge to read it.

'Speed Saunders' (by Creig Flessel): After getting fired last issue, Speed Saunders now seems to be working as a private detective (although he still specialises in water-based crimes, just like Night-Boat).  This month he foils gold robbers who are hiding the gold inside dead fish.