Showing posts with label Feature Comics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Feature Comics. Show all posts

Monday, August 27, 2012

July 1940: Feature Comics #36

 
Cover possibly by Gill Fox

'The Doll Man' (by Will Eisner and Lou Fine): A mad scientist who is collecting brains decides that he needs the Doll Man's, and he sends one of his lobotomised slaves to capture him. What follows is a creepy tale, with art from Eisner and Fine providing just enough grotesque detail.

'Samar' (possibly by Chuck Mazoujian): This story is something else. Samar finds himself captured by a society of Amazons, where the women rule and the men are slaves. By the time Samar is through with the place, the men are back on top. Not only that, he promises to return to see the former queen "when she has learned her lesson". There's even a shot of one of the women lying protrate with the crotch torn out of her dress. This is pretty bad no matter what era it was made in.


In other stories:

'Rance Keane' (by William A. Smith) deals with a doctor who has given his anti-cancer serum to a crime syndicate. 'Reynolds of the Mounted' (by Art Pinajian) captures the head of a narcotics ring. 'Spin Shaw of the Naval Air Corps' (by Bob Powell) defends the air mail service in South America from saboteurs, one of whom is named "Greg Rucker". 'Rusty Ryan of Boyville' (by Paul Gustavson) rescues a wealthy young boy from kidnappers. 'Dusty Dane' (by Vernon Henkel) is captured by a German-looking guy and forced to join the crew of his ship. 'The Voice' (by Stan Aschmeier) investigates the murders of radio personalities, all of whom were killed by their boss for insurance money. 'Captain Bruce Blackburn, Counterspy' (by Harry Francis Campbell) stops some spies from stealing an experimental motor. And 'Zero, Ghost Detective' (by Dan Zolnerowich) helps a girl whose grandfather's ghost is trying to take her to the afterlife with him.

Thursday, July 12, 2012

June 1940: Feature Comics #34

Cover by John Devlin

'Doll Man' (by Lou Fine): The Doll Man's buddy Wampum, now an Injun oil magnate, is kidnapped by pirates.  This was all pretty tiresome, until Doll Man came to the rescue riding a penguin.  Also, Lou Fine is brilliant, easily one of the best artists of the Golden Age.

In other stories: In 'Rance Keane' (by William A. Smith), Rance's buddy Pee Wee dreams about fighting Chinese crooks.  'Zero, Ghost Detective' (by Dan Zolnerowich) protects a girl from violin-playing skeletons.  'Reynolds of the Mounted' (by Art Pinajian) tackles some kidnappers who are after maps of the coast.  'Spin Shaw' (by Bob Powell) rescues an explorer from Amazonian tribesmen. 'Captain Fortune' (by Vernon Henkel) is pursued by a ghost ship.  'The Voice' (by Stan Aschmeier) investigates a murder in which the gun was hidden in a record player and triggered by playing some music. 'Rusty Ryan of Boyville' (by Paul Gustavson) deals with some crooks who set fire to Boyville so that they can buy the property on the cheap. 'Bruce Blackburn, Counterspy' (by Harry Francis Campbell) must stop some spies who are trying to get America involved in a war with Solvonia.  And 'Samar' (by Robert Hayward Web) fights cavemen and a flesh-eating brontosaurus.

Wednesday, February 22, 2012

April 1940: Feature Comics #33

Cover by Joe Devlin

'Dollman' (by Will Eisner and Lou Fine): A racketeer named Gat Granet frames another man named Tim Shean for murder. The Dollman stops the man from being executed and drags Granet to a mock trial, where he is driven mad by a jury of hobos and the sight of a still-living Shean. This is classic Eisner (actually, it's Lou Fine, who's just as good). The scene leading to Shean's hanging is great, with the spectre of the grim reaper hovering over the page, and the mock trial is very tense as well.

'Rance Keane' (by William A. Smith): Rance and Pee Wee have travelled to New York, where they decide to buy some new clothes so that they won't look out of place. In the store they foil the plot of a cross-dressing thief, and are both awarded with shiny new outfits. (Seriously, they look like they're glowing.) There's an interminable few pages here of people arguing about the purchase of a fur coat, but it is an intriguing change of pace in a "what the hell are they doing" kind of way.

'Captain Bruce Blackburn, Counterspy' (by Harry Francis Campbell): Bruce goes up against female spy Tanya Slavska, who is trying to steal some secret papers. The usual business, with nothing original to speak of.

'Samar' (by John Charles): Samar is a shameless Tarzan knock-off. In this story he tackles a woman named Mona, who has a hypnotised army of apes that she's using to steal gold from an archaeological dig. It's a whole level of craziness above what Tarzan usually deals with, which is the sort of ripping-off that I approve of.

'Spin Shaw of the Naval Air Corps' (by Bob Powell): In the Philippines, Spin stops the attempt of a princess and her tribe to murder every white person on the island. It's a potentially exciting set-up that doesn't go anywhere.

'Captain Fortune' (by Vernon Henkel): After being shipwrecked in a storm, Fortune and his crew are captured by a lady pirate, and eventually must team up with her against the Spanish. The action is quite well done, but it all wraps up a bit too neatly at the end, with the lady pirate dead and Fortune with his crew back again. He has, however, picked up the habit of talking in the third person.

'The Voice' (by Stan Aschmeier): The Voice takes on a gang of counterfeiters who have murdered a bank president. I don't think that I followed this very well, but I didn't notice anything worth writing about, and that's never a good sign.

'Zero, Ghost Detective' (by Dan Zolnerowich): Zero must protect a man and his niece, who are threatened by the ghosts of negro slaves that were mistreated by the man's great-grandfather. It's a great set-up, but as is the case with so many Golden Age stories, it's not developed at all. Zero burns the haunted mansion down and that's that.

'The Dead Return' (by Robert M. Hyatt): Captain Mulravey murders a crew member over a treasure map. Later, when he has found the treasure, the crewman returns from the dead to kill Mulravey. Or perhaps his dead body floats into his oxygen tube and cuts off his air, it's a little ambiguous. But still quite well done.

'Rusty Ryan of Boyville' (by Paul Gustavson): A crazy old man shoots at some rock-climbing kids, and leaves one of them dangling halfway down a cliff. Rusty comes to the rescue, and the old man repents his ways. Heartwarmin', ain't it? I think I liked the old guy better when he was shooting kids with rock salt.

'Reynolds of the Mounted' (by Art Pinajian): A mine foreman murders one of his workers and tries to pin it on another, but a snooping kid helps Reynolds solve the case with his photography. There's nothing particularly wrong with the story. Except that it has a Mountie in it.

Thursday, January 12, 2012

March 1940: Feature Comics #32

Cover by Lou Fine

'The Dollman' (by Will Eisner and Lou Fine): Some spies kidnap a scientist who has invented a deadly gas, and the Dollman must go to the rescue. The whole plot of this story hinges on this gas being deadlier than any other yet created, but when a vial of it is smashed it doesn't kill anybody. Dollman survives it, the spies survive it, even the old scientist survives it. The story was fairly entertaining otherwise, but that's a pretty big logic flaw.

'Captain Fortune' (by Vernon Henkel): Captain Fortune leads an assault on Castle Balomar, to help Lord Essex regain his lands from the villainous Duke Edward. This is quite a good bit of fun. It's full of cliches, but it revels in them. Clashing armies, a kidnapped princess, and a one-on-one duel between hero and villain, this has them all, and uses them well.

'Zero, Ghost Detective' (by Don Zolnerowich): Zero, as it says on the tin, is a paranormal investigator. In this story, a man has returned from the dead as a three-fingered ogre to kill his brothers, due to a pledge they made as children. It has a suitable level of creepiness, and I did enjoy it despite Zero's complete lack of personality.

'Reynolds of the Mounted' (by Art Pinajian): Reynolds gets caught up in the machinations of two unscrupulous fur traders and an Injun medicine man who wants to become chief of his tribe. Wonder of wonders, but I actually liked this. It plays the various factions off each other nicely.

'Spin Shaw of the Naval Air Corps' (by Bob Powell): Spin goes up against saboteurs that are trying to destroy an experimental plane. The plot is cliched, but it has several rather good action set pieces.

'Rance Keane' (by William A. Smith): Rance and Pee Wee must retrieve the stolen money of Rance's murdered friend, which they do with a plan that involves them pretending to be drunk. It's not nearly as entertaining as it sounds.

'Captain Bruce Blackburn, Counterspy' (by Harry Francis Campbell): This new strip has a cracking opening, as Bruce must fake his own death due to his identity having been leaked. After a spot of plastic surgery he resumes his spy-hunting career, and sets about figuring out who is the spy in their organisation. Alas, it gets a little too dry and procedural after the great opening.

'Rusty Ryan of Boyville' (by Paul Gustavson): Rusty Ryan is an orphan with a knack for solving crimes. In this story some crooks organise to become the beneficiaries of a child's insurance policy before causing him to fall from a bridge. Rusty finds them out in a story that is decent enough. I do like the way that Rusty can just get whatever he wants from the local newspaper; he's so trusted that the editor stops the presses on his word, and sets some column inches aside because he knows there will be a story if Rusty's involved.

'Gold of Atlantis' (by Robert M. Hyatt): An adventurer named Perry Scott goes hunting gold in an ancient Atlantean city, and instead finds a golden serpent. It sounds like the basis for a great pulp yarn, but in practice it's mostly the characters sitting around talking, and the snake presents no menace at all.

'The Voice' (by Stan Aschmeier): The Voice is Mr. Elixir, who was stranded on an island in 1790 and has lived for 150 years due to special herbs that also give him super-strength. After returning to New York he takes up crime fighting, using the powers of hypnotism and ventriloquism to take on a daring hold-up gang. It's a decent enough set-up, but the story is mediocre.

'Samar' (possibly by Ted Cain and Nick Cardy): Samar is a generic jungle hero who saves a village from stampeding elephants. The stampede was caused by an evil trader who is after the blood ruby owned by the village chief. The art for this strip is very good, reminiscent of things like the Tarzan newspaper strips.

Sunday, November 27, 2011

February 1940: Whiz Comics #2, Smash Comics #9, Feature Comics #31

Cover by C.C. Beck

Officially this is issue number two of Whiz Comics, but in actuality it is the first proper comic in the series. The first issue was a promo comic with no real content to speak of.

'Capt. Marvel' (by Bill Parker and C.C. Beck): This is the first appearance of Captain Marvel, a very significant piece of comics history. It gets off to a cracking start, as orphan Billy Batson is whisked away by a mysterious man in a subway train to visit the wizard Shazam, who gifts him with awesome power. When Billy says the magic word SHAZAM he becomes Captain Marvel, with the following abilities: the wisdom of Solomon, the strength of Hercules, the stamina of Atlas, the power of Zeus, the courage of Achilles and the speed of Mercury. The origin is really powerful, and rich with mythological symbolism. It really does feel momentous, and the sense of deep history is hinted at very effectively.



The main plot is a little weaker, as criminal mastermind Sivana invents a ray that will disable all radio broadcasts, and uses it to hold the world to ransom. Captain Marvel's ingenious solution is to wreck the machine, but I guess it gets the job done. It also serves as a way to get Billy Batson a job as a radio announcer, something that I'm sure will be a vital part of this strip's storytelling engine.

Despite the weaker second half, this is still a strong first outing.

'Ibis the Invincible' (by Bill Parker and C.C. Beck): Ibis is an Egyptian pharaoh who wakes up in the year 1940. Why he wakes up is never explained, but it's not super important. He owns a powerful wand called the Ibistick, which can pretty much do anything, including clothe him in the standard Golden Age magician's attire of suit and turban. Ibis's first instinct is to resurrect his lost love Taia, but before he can find her he spends a lot of time wandering the world righting wrongs, including an extended stay in Europe where he helps out during the war. By the end of the story he has brought Taia back to life, but his Ibistick has been stolen by a common crook. In many ways this is a variation on the 'Zatara' formula, although Ibis's magic tricks are not very imaginative. He also displays very little personality, and is very conversant with the modern world for an ancient Egyptian. It gets by on pace alone, with Ibis finding a new wrong to right every few panels. For all of its flaws, it's quite enjoyable.

'Golden Arrow' (by Bill Parker and Greg Duncan): Roger Parsons is the son of a millionaire, but his parents are murdered while flying a balloon across the country, and Roger is raised in the wild by an old prospector. He grows up and becomes skilled with the bow, earning the name Golden Arrow, and avenges the murder of his parents. It's a weird mash-up of the cowboy genre with a bit of the jungle hero archetype thrown in. But other than that it's rather bland.

'Spy Smasher' (by Bill Parker and C.C. Beck): Secret plans are stolen from a US admiral by the villainous Mask. The mysterious Spy Smasher gets them back. Great pains are taken to obscure Spy Smasher's identity, and the same goes for the Mask. There are two real suspects: Filipino houseboy Zambo, and wealthy young sportsman Alan Armstrong. No answer is given in this chapter, but surely Armstrong is the hero and Zambo the villain. I'll be delighted if I'm wrong.

'Scoop Smith' (by Bill Parker and Greg Duncan): As you may have guessed, Scoop Smith is a reporter. In this story he investigates Doctor Death (aka James Kirk!), who has invented a ray that can bring back the dead. Of course, he must murder someone before he can test it. Scoop gets the doctor arrested, and everything wraps up very neatly, except that there is now a ray that can bring back the dead in the hands of the US government.  It's the sort of thing that demands a follow-up, but I'm certain it will never be mentioned again.

'Lance O'Casey' (by Bill Parker and Bob Kingett): Lance O'Casey is a very Irish sailor, who must rescue a scientist and his daughter from island natives, and the white man in charge of them. The story's not very good, but the sheer Irishness of O'Casey is somewhat endearing. And he does fire his monkey sidekick from a tree like a catapult.

'Dan Dare in Seals of Doom' (by Bill Parker and Greg Duncan): No, not that Dan Dare. This one is a private detective, travelling with his girlfriend Carol. A millionaire hires them to try and pin a murder on someone, which is all tied into a dope smuggling operation. It's relatively complex, and done better than most stories of this type.

Cover by Gill Fox

'Espionage starring Black X' (by Will Eisner): Eisner's European war montage openings get more and more ludicrous. This time, in addition to the usual war imagery, we're treated to Jesus on the cross, a skeleton forging weapons at an anvil, and the Four Horsemen of Death.

But that has nothing to do with the main story, which sees the Black X taking on Proxoff, a warlord who has built his own private army with which he plans to take over the world in the aftermath of the war. His soldiers don't fear death, and when caught they ingest a drug that turns them into skeletons. This is another solid outing.  Not only does it work as a great action adventure story, but it displays an understanding of the horror and senselessness of war that many other similar strips lack.

'Abdul the Arab' (by Vernon Henkel): Abdul is tasked with capturing the bandit Khabib, but as usual Abdul gets captured and his sidekick Hassan comes to his rescue. He even survives getting shot before punching Khabib right in the mouth. Seriously, why does Abdul get all the credit? The guy does nothing!

'Flash Fulton, Newsreel Ace' (by Paul Gustavson): Flash, working in the European war zone, smuggles the information in some vital papers across the border by making a newsreel of them. There's very little here of note, except for a joke in the last panel that falls completely flat.

'Clip Chance at Cliffside' (by George Brenner): With his coach's job on the line, Clip wins every event in the decathlon and beats up some crooks who try to steal the gate receipts. He's just so wonderful!

'Wings Wendall of the Military Intelligence' (by Vernon Henkel): Wings stops a group of spies that is taking photographs of Hawaii's military defenses. This story has nothing of interest.

Captain Cook of Scotland Yard: The Case of the Roving Taxicab' (by Stan Aschmeier): A man is murdered in a taxicab, and Captain Cook proves that the culprit was the cab driver. No shit Sherlock, he was the only other guy in there!

'John Law, Scientective' (by Harry Francis Campbell): Last issue John Law figured out the identity of the Avenger, but was not able to capture him. This time the Avenger is menacing the owner of a bus company, making his buses disappear in a strange fog. Law tracks him down to an unfinished subway tunnel, gets captured, and McGuyvers his way out by making home-made thermite. Yes kids, with some aluminum filings, rust and camera flash powder, you too can make a substance that burns at 5000 degrees! This is pretty average, but I really did enjoy that potentially dangerous little home chemistry lesson.

'Chic Carter, Ace Reporter' (by Vernon Henkel): Chic Carter smashes a marijuana ring in a very pedestrian story.

'The Cat Men' (by Robert M. Hyatt): A bunch of trains race to the Norton Mine, with the winner to gain the lucrative freight contract on offer. One of the train drivers cheats mercilessly and gets his comeuppance in a relatively satisfying fashion. It's alright so far as these prose stories go.

'Invisible Justice' (by Art Pinajian): The Invisible Hood takes on a small band of pirates.As often happens, sleepiness set in around the time I was reading this story, and it wasn't exciting or interesting enough to keep me awake.

'Hugh Hazzard and his Iron Man' (by Wayne Reid): Hugh and Bozo take on a dictator named Motler, who is totally original and nothing like Adolf Hitler at all. I've only just realised it, but now that Hugh can climb inside the robot, he is very much in the same vein as Iron Man (the Marvel character).

Cover possibly by Ed Cronin

'The Dollman' (by Will Eisner and Lou Fine): The Dollman tackles a weird hunchback who is murdering diamond salesmen and stealing their wares. It's a very basic story, and I still feel like this strip isn't making the most out of its premise.

'Jane Arden' (by Monte Barrett and Russell E. Ross): Jane is still getting entangled in soap opera romance and the like, but as the strip is ending it looks as though one of the men she's been dating is a crook. Pretty much everyone here is acting like a jerk this month.  I'll never get to find out what that maybe-crook's deal is, because this is Jane Arden's final appearance here.  It was never interesting enough to be missed.

'Captain Fortune' (by Vernon Henkel): Captain Fortune rescues his friend the Earl of Essex from a rival duke. The duke vows revenge as a set-up for next month's story. In theory this all sounds quite exciting, but on the page it's quite staid and flat.

'Rance Keane, the Knight of the West' (by William A. Smith): Rance Keane helps a supposed FBI agent against a gang of cattle rustlers, only to discover that this agent is actually their leader.  I could write about whether this was good or not, but instead I'd like to share my opinion of cattle rustler stories in general: they suck and I hate them.

'The Clock Strikes' (by George Brenner): The Clock takes on a spy who has stolen the formula for a new type of poison gas. He survives an attack with the gas because his mask got wet, which is pretty weak.  This appears to be the last we will see of the Clock for many decades. It's a fairly ignominious finale for the first costumed hero in comics.

'Spin Shaw of the Naval Air Corps' (by Bob Powell): Spin goes undercover in a gang of arms smugglers. It's another incredibly generic and boring story.

'Slim and Tubby' (by John J. Welch): Benton tries to get another boxing match, but because he's a hero nobody wants to fight him. I liked that one twist in the ongoing storyline, but otherwise this is pretty dull.  This is the last appearance of this strip, and Slim and Tubby have yet to come up with the money to save their ranch.  I can only assume that it goes out of business and they die penniless on the streets.

'Ned Brant' (by Bob Zuppke and R.W. Depew): Ned loses a relay race, then comes back and wins the race that decides the whole athletics meet. Because he's awesome.  This is the last appearance of Ned Brant, to which I say good riddance.  The sooner these sport-themed strips die out the better.

'Charlie Chan' (by Alfred Andriola): Charlie investigates a kidnapping and the attempted theft of some rubies. The story ends with him accusing a man who is still vehemently claiming his innocence, and his evidence is pretty tenuous.  This is the last we see of Charlie in Feature Comics.  I won't miss him.

'Magic on the Rink' (by Robert E. Jones): A crook tries to fix an ice hockey match by putting heating units into one team's skates, but he screws up and puts them in the skates of his own team. I'm not sure what this story is trying to say, except for "criminals are dumb".

'Reynolds of the Mounted' (by Art Pinajian): Two escaped crooks hole up in a cabin, but the boy who lives there notifies the Mounties by arranging the washing in Morse code.  It's terrible, and has Mounties in it.

As you may have guessed, Feature Comics is in for a big overhaul in the next issue.  I'm looking forward to it, because this is one of my least favourite comics to read for this blog.  Any change will probably be an improvement.

Monday, October 31, 2011

January 1940: Feature Comics #30

Cover by Lou Fine

'The Clock Strikes' (by George Brenner): Some foreign spies engineer a car crash so that they can steal the US industrial mobilisation plans, and the Clock tracks them down and gets them back. I'm getting tired of these stories that are straightforward to the point of tedium. There are so many that play the same story beats over and over again with nothing new to add.

'Jane Arden' (by Monte Barrett and Russell E. Ross): Jane and her friend Sue are on holiday. Sue hooks up with a handsome dude, while Jane talks to a fat guy, and there is jealousy all round. Jane recognises the handsome dude, so I'm sure he'll turn out to be a crook at some point, but at the moment we're in romantic comedy territory. It's not particularly well done, but it's also an area that comics haven't touched on much to this point.

'Reynolds of the Mounted' (by Art Pinajian): Reynolds must take a shipment of gold to Nugget City by canoe, while a fake shipment goes by steamer to throw off potential thieves. Along the way he's attacked by Dixon, a foreman who had suggested the plan in the first place. With Dixon's arrest the story would normally end, but it turns out that the mining manager Lane is trying to steal the gold as well. It certainly took me unawares.  Too bad this has mounties in it.

'Spin Shaw of the Naval Air Corps' (by Bob Powell): Spin is a Naval Air Force pilot. In this story he aids in the rescue of a sinking yacht by using his plane's propellers to blow away a cloud of smoke. No effort is made to make the reader care about any potential deaths, and Spin displays no personality to speak of.

'Captain Fortune in the Days of the Spanish Main' (by Vernon Henkel): Fortune is sent to find a missing ship, and ends up rescuing the crew from a native tribe by blowing them away with his ship's cannons. Way to triumph against the odds, guy!

'The Dollman' (by Will Eisner): Dollman takes on a submarine full of foreign agents who have been stealing shipments of American motors. The action scenes are dynamic, but other than that this story has little to offer. It's hard to believe that this is the same Eisner who is doing such great work on 'Espionage' in Smash Comics.

'Rance Keane, the Knight of the West' (by William A. Smith): Rance Keane stops a guy from blowing up a bridge so that he can claim his victim's will. It's another very hackneyed story.

'Smoke Screen' (by A.L. Allen): An orange farmer must deal with a gang of Mexican gun smugglers in this prose story. Which he does by calling the sheriff. It makes sense, but it doesn't make a good story.

'Charlie Chan' (by Alfred Andriola): Charlie is on a cruise ship that is attacked by pirates who are after some rubies owned by a doctor. The lettering on this thing is miniscule, and it was a real chore to read. I think I only deciphered about half of the dialogue, so I definitely missed some of the finer points.

Sunday, October 9, 2011

December 1939: Smash Comics #7, Feature Comics #29

Cover possibly by Gill Fox

'Espionage starring the Black X; (by Will Eisner): Eisner opens with a war montage yet again, and this time he has added skeletons in military uniforms. Everything is improved with skeletons. In the actual story, foreign spies try to sabotage a US blockade that is stopping their country from gaining access to the Pacific Ocean. The Black X is sent to stop them, and the story proceeds along the usual captures and escapes line. But it takes a surprisingly emotional turn when Black X falls for the female leader of the spies, and tries to save her from certain death as she pilots a kamikaze torpedo at a US naval base. He fails, and is so gutted that he quits the spy game. It rings a little false when he instantly jumps back into action a panel later, but the rest of the story is told very well indeed.

'Abdul the Arab' (by Vernon Henkel): Abdul and Hassan go up against the "Masked One", the hooded leader of an arms smuggling operation. Abdul gets captured and Hassan does all the work, which seems to be a trend in this series. It's not particularly interesting.

'Captain Cook of Scotland Yard' (by Stan Aschmeier): Lola Barnes, daughter of Sir Sidney, is kidnapped, and a mysterious voice with no discernible source demands the Red Star Diamond as ransom. Captain Cook figures out that the voice is transmitted through wires, and that Lola is being held in her own house by Sidney's Hindu servant. Cook's hunch about Lola's location is never explained, and the Hindu servant is never mentioned before he is caught, so this definitely fails as a mystery story.

'Clip Chance at Cliffside' (by George Brenner): Clip receives a note from gamblers, telling him that if he plays in tomorrow's basketball game they will kill his mother. True to form, Clip wants to play regardless of the danger (he did the same thing when his girlfriend was threatened) but his coach won't let him. He tracks down the crooks, gets captured, escapes and goes on to win the game. But the crooks are still at large, and free to kill Clip's dear old mum at any time. Man, Clip Chance is the biggest jerk ever.

'Wings Wendall of the Military Intelligence' (by Vernon Henkel): A female spy is sent to seduce an army officer to get the New York Defense Plans. Wings stops the spy ring in a pretty solid story.  There are also scenes of German-born Americans holding rallies to declare their allegiance to the Fatherland, which must have been topical at the time, and they serve to ground the action and up the stakes.

'Invisible Justice' (by Art Pinajian): Invisible Justice takes on a gang of crooks who set fire to businesses before robbing them in asbestos suits. There's nothing of interest here.

'Flash Fulton' (by Paul Gustavson): Flash foils some kidnappers, and films their confession without them realising it. Dull.

'Chic Carter, Ace Reporter' (by Vernon Henkel): Chic is shot down behind enemy lines, and his captors force him to send the articles they want him to write. Chic escapes, foils an assassination attempt on the royal family of Moravia, then plants a kiss on the princess. It's a terribly boring story, but Chic Carter is easily the most bad-ass non-superhero reporter around.

'The Master of Mu' (by Robert M. Hyatt): After a promising opening, in which our hero Jon was kidnapped and sent to the moon by the villainous Milo, we find out that he's not actually on the moon, and that Milo is stealing planes by purely mechanical means. With all of the fantastical elements stripped out, this conclusion falls very flat.

'John Law, Scientective' (by Harry Francis Campbell): The Avenger's next target is Albert Lewis. Law goes to help him, only to find that the Avenger has turned Lewis's house into a deathtrap. Of course Law escapes, but the deathtraps are actually pretty creative in places. The Avenger, however, comes across as a pretty weak villain; there's a hilarious scene where he fails to capture Law's girlfriend, and watches forlornly as she drives away. Apparently Law is going to unmask the Avenger in the next issue, and any idiot can see that it's Albert Lewis.  Unless I'm being misdirected with very obvious clues, but I don't think so.

'Hugh Hazzard and his Iron Man' (by George Brenner): "Jarmanian" spies kidnap a general's son and try to blackmail him for the gold at Fort Kentucky. Hugh and Bozo stop them, with the help of a notorious crook who refuses to betray his country. The inclusion of the crook and his redemption raises this above the usual fare.

Cover by Ed Cronin

'The Doll Man' (by Will Eisner): Darrel Dane is framed by an art thief, but as the Doll Man he is able to escape and beat up the thief and his gang. This is as rudimentary as this type of story gets. The art is quite good, with some very solid storytelling, but there's no sense of scale. The Doll Man is tiny, but it's not conveyed all that effectively.

'Ned Brant' (by Bob Zuppke and R.W. Depew): Ned Brant and his friend Bud Shekels are jerks to each other over a girl. I suppose I should be happy that they aren't playing any sort of sport, but this is still not very good.

'Charlie Chan' (by Alfred Andriola): In the last issue, Charlie and Detective Kirk went undercover in a gang of kidnappers. In this chapter they are exposed, but manage to beat them all in a fist fight. The story here is average, but there are number of scenes told effectively without dialogue or narration, which is pretty sophisticated for the time.

Ed Wheelan has moved on from this strip, and it's now being done by Joe Devlin.  It has switched from a continuing story to one page gag strips, and I approve. The latter format wasn't doing it any favours.  And at the very least, I won't have to write about it any more.

'The Clock Strikes' (by George E. Brenner): A friend of the Clock's is killed by blackmailers lead by a crook named the Reaper. The Clock captures them and places them under arrest. There are no real flaws to this story, but it's still frightfully uninteresting and formulaic.

'Jane Arden' (by Monte Barrett and Russell E. Ross): Jane has been undercover, working with a jewel thief called the "Man With the Scar", for ages now, and in this story she gets him arrested. It's not great, but I'm just glad that this plot line is over.

'Reynolds of the Mounted' (by Art Pinajian): Indians are being killed by a mysterious person called the "Flying Death", and Reynolds is called in to investigate. There's a white criminal who is under suspicion, but the killer ends up being the Indian chief. As far as I can tell there is absolutely no motive for the killings, which is like the first rule for constructing a murder mystery.

'Rance Keane, the Knight of the West' (by Will Arthur): Rance and Pee Wee investigate a derailed train. Footprints around the tracks lead them to believe that a one-legged man is the culprit, but it turns out to be a guy who was wearing two right shoes. I was vaguely interested in the set-up, but the solution was blindingly obvious.

'Whispering Walls' (by A.L. Allen): Two cowboys seek shelter from a storm in a supposedly haunted ruin. While shooting rats in the walls, they find a box full of treasure. This story seemed to be setting up a contrast between city boy Roy and tough country boy Jack, but that goes nowhere, and what we actually get is a series of events that in no way coalesces into a story.

'Captain Fortune' (by Vernon Henkel): This story gets off to a cracking start, with a member of Fortune's crew bursting into a tavern to announce that the evil pirate Black Flint is terrorising the coast once again. Fortune quickly rounds up his crew, sails to Flint's island, and kills the pirate and his men. This story wastes no time, bouncing from one action scene to the next. It's major failing is that Flint barely appears before his death, but I enjoyed the breakneck pace.

'Slim and Tubby' (by John J. Welch): Benton is scheduled to fight a boxer named Simpson, who takes a dive to make Benton look bad. Everything is cleared up by the boxing commission without much effort, and no drama at all. It's also occurred to me that Slim and Tubby, despite being the title characters, have not done anything for months.

'Spin Shaw of the Naval Air Corps' (by Rex Smith): This is a new strip, in which Spin Shaw is a generic heroic pilot, pretty much the most common type of hero in the Golden Age so far.  On an island protected by the USA, Spin stops foreign agents from poisoning the local crops. It features a decent aerial dogfight, but is otherwise pretty dull.

Tuesday, September 20, 2011

November 1939: Feature Comics #28

Cover by Ed Cronin

'Captain Fortune in the Days of the Spanish Main' (by Vernon Henkel): Fortune gets into fight with some pirates in a tavern, and his crewman Pierre is killed. For the rest of the strip he chases the pirates and their leader Captain Clegg, then kills them for revenge. It's as rudimentary as it gets, but at least Fortune has a believable motivation.

'Ned Brant' (by Bob Zuppke): This month Ned is playing ice hockey, and loses the game for his team when he is sent off for punching another player. Isn't punching other players kind of the point of ice hockey these days? Anyway, this was not good.  The only thing I liked about it was that ice hockey hasn't really been touched on before this.

'Rance Keane, the Knight of the West' (by William A. Smith): Rance stops a gang of bank robbers who had staged a diversion to get all the men out of town while they committed their crimes. His new sidekick Pee Wee sleeps through the whole thing, which is hardly the best argument for his introduction.

'The Clock Strikes' (by George Brenner): When D.A. Dan Nolen spends a page promising his wife that he'll retire, there's only one possible outcome:



The Clock proves that Nolen's assistant was bribed to kill him, in a story that I got little enjoyment out of aside from the gleefully cliched death at the start.

'Jane Arden' (by Monte Barrett and Russell E. Ross): Jane is still undercover as a jewel thief's partner, but he's starting to suspect that she's double-crossing him. I honestly can't believe that this story is still going.

'The Dollman' (by Will Eisner): Dollman goes up against Dr. Rodent, a crook who is blowing up cargo ships with bombs carried by rats, then collecting the silver and gold from the bottom of the ocean. This is okay, and it does feature a scene of the Dollman fighting against said explosive-laden rats that looks great.

'Reynolds of the Mounted' (by Art Pinajian): Reynolds deals with some crooks who are smuggling weapons into Canada. So, so boring.

'Barrel Rolls and Tail Spins' (by A.L. Allen): This prose story begins promisingly, with the meeting of a cautious boy and a reckless pilot, but the second half devolves into cliche, with a gang of smugglers. The two halves of the story never really mesh together.

'Slim and Tubby' (by John J. Welch): Benton is booked into another boxing match for the money he needs to save the ranch. It's well worn material.

'Charlie Chan' (by Alfred Andriola): When heiress Donna Grant is kidnapped, Charlie must go undercover as a cook to infiltrate the gang. I was already thinking this story was too long when I got to the "to be continued" caption.

Monday, August 29, 2011

October 1939: Feature Comics #27

It's going to be a quick review today, because all I could find from Feature Comics #27 was the Doll Man story.  Looking at the cover below, it's weird that Doll Man debuts as the issue's headliner, yet he doesn't make the cover at all, not even as a little head shot.

Cover by creators unknown, possibly Ed Cronin

'The Doll Man' (by Jerry Iger and Will Eisner): This is the origin story of Doll Man, one of Quality's more popular super heroes. Scientist Darrel Dane invents a formula with which he can shrink to the size of a doll, and he uses his new found power to battle a crook who is blackmailing his fiancee. The plot itself isn't that interesting, but it really just serves as a backdrop against which Doll Man can show off his powers.  The most interesting bit comes after Dane first shrinks, and he goes temporarily insane and attacks his fiancee's father with a hypodermic needle. That's something I'd like to see expanded on, but I doubt it's going to happen. It's also never explained why the doll-sized Dane is so powerful, possessing the ability to punch out full-grown men. Nevertheless, despite the inauspicious debut, there are some hooks to hang some interesting stories on.

Sunday, August 21, 2011

September 1939: Feature Comics #26

Cover by Ed Cronin

'Jane Arden' (by Monte Barrett and Russell E. Ross): Jane, still on the trail of a notorious jewel thief, outwits him at a staged robbery to gain his confidence. I was on board for this story at the beginning, but at this point it needs to pull the finger out.

'Captain Fortune' (by Vernon Henkel): In the last issue Captain Fortune went ashore, and the mutinous Severish fired the ship's cannons into the town. This installment is all a big buildup to Fortune sneaking back onto his ship to confront Severish, and the result is probably the most anti-climactic one-panel fight scene ever.  In one panel they're squaring up, and in the very next Fortune has his sword through Severish's chest.  It's the "One Punch!" of the Golden Age, for all of you JLI fans out there.

'Big Top' (by Ed Wheelan): Everyone is distressed because Hal's plane disappeared last issue, but it turns out that he's okay, and he and Myra get married. I guess it's the old "throw complications at young lovers who want to get married" story, which has never been a favourite of mine, mainly because I think that marriage has no bearing at all on the legitimacy of a relationship.  So for me the dramatic stakes are virtually meaningless. (Also, I could not give two shits about any of the characters in here.) We're promised that next issue will bring us a "New and better Big Top". Ooh, maybe Neil Gaiman will be writing?

'Ned Brant' (by Bob Zuppke): Ned plays gridiron, gets clobbered, and the team wins the game for him. This story is followed by a subscription form, and on the basis of this story I say "No thank you, please do not ever send me any copies of Feature Comics."

'The Clock Strikes' (by George E. Brenner): The Clock has been framed for robbery, and I was all set to dismiss this one as another formulaic story. But when the Clock captures his framer and threatens to make a rat eat through his abdomen I certainly perked up. Nothing like a bit of hardcore torture to make a story memorable.

'Rance Keane, The Knight of the West' (by Will Arthur): Rance stops some crooks from forcing a rancher to sell to them. It's off to a bad start already, and to top it off Rance beats them by sending a letter to the marshal. It's almost like the creators are trying to personally annoy me at this point. The rancher, a guy named Pee Wee Lee who is fixated in his own moustache, joins Rance as his sidekick, but he hasn't shown much either way to indicate how his addition will affect the strip.  (Admittedly, he does have a cool moustache.)

'Reynolds of the Mounted' (by Art Pinajian): Reynolds goes up against an Indian tribe that is buying guns from a smuggler for an uprising against the mounties. The villain, Chief Red Hawk, really lacks commitment.  One minute he's all "We gonna kill them mounties!", but as soon as Reynolds is pointing a gun at his back he's "We only wanna live in peace!" He should be true to his Mountie-killing ways.

'Slim and Tubby' (by John J. Welch): After knocking out the champ last issue, Benton reluctantly becomes a boxer. After a few week's he's ready to chuck it in and return to being a cowboy, but there are some convenient shenanigans that result in him losing his ranch... UNLESS HE CAN RAISE $10,000 REAL QUICK! Cliche-riddled and boring.

'Cove of the Beasts' (by Robert M. Hyatt): In this prose story two kids and their uncle go to Skull Island looking for treasure. Instead they find a big guy with a bung leg, a scared daughter, and a hunch-backed servant named Ivan. I'm not sure where this is going, but it does have a mysterious vibe going for it. To be continued!

'Charlie Chan' (by Alfred Andriola): A rudimentary investigation into deaths in a mine is livened up quite a bit at the end when the culprit holes himself up in a barn and starts throwing dynamite at everyone. It's still fairly boring, but the end just about redeems it.

Tuesday, August 2, 2011

August 1939: Feature Comics #25

Cover by Ed Cronin

'Charlie Chan' (by Alfred Andriola): People are dying from gas in a gold mine in San Pedro, and Charlie Chan is called in by an old friend to investigate. The possibility of murder is raised, and a solid detective story emerges, but this one is to be continued in the next issue. And I honestly don't believe that the story is interesting enough to carry over like that.  I'll have forgotten the details by then.

'Captain Fortune' (by Vernon Henkel): Tyrone Fortune is captain of the Revenge, a ship crewed by cutthroats that is tasked with attacking pirates and the French. Fortune earns the enmity of a crewmember named Severish, and when they put into a Spanish port for repairs Severish opens fire with the cannons when Fortune goes ashore. This is a fairly dry adventure story, but it does have a decent cliffhanger.

'The Clock Strikes' (by George Brenner): The Clock investigates a member of a crime gang who has infiltrated the police commissioner's staff. Absolutely nothing of interest happens in this story.

'Rance Keane, the Knight of the West' (by Will Arthur): Clyde (an old friend of Rance's father) commits suicide, but Rance believes that he was murdered. The culprit is his business partner, which is a shame, because any mystery in which the guilty party is the first person under suspicion is a bit dodgy. This ends up as more of a howdunnit than a whodunnit, but even then we're not provided with the clues to the mystery before it's solved.

'Big Top' by Ed Wheelan: Hal and Myra continue to whinge and whine about him going to Hollywood and leaving her behind when what they really want is to be married. After he leaves, the story ends with Hal's ghost visiting Myra, and then a dramatic newspaper headline that we aren't shown.  I suppose the implication is that he died in a plane crash, which would be just desserts for all the romantic angst I had to endure.

'Ned Brant' (by Bob Zuppke and R.W. Depew): Ned Brant and his friends play football. Meanwhile, this gentle reader contemplates suicide.

'Slim and Tubby' (by John Welch): Last issue set up a boxing match between the champion Noyes and Benton (who I think is a cowboy on the ranch). In this issue they fight, and Benton predictably wins. It's not the worst rendition of this story that I've read.

'The Rules of the Game' (by A.L. Allen): Two boys enter a rodeo to try and win some prize money to help their destitute father. Feature Comics is really busting out some old chestnuts with this issue. It's an adequate telling of a well-worn story.

'Jane Arden' (by Monte Barrett and Russell E. Ross): Jane is still undercover, pretending to be a jewel thief to flush out "The Man With the Scar", himself a thief of some renown. It's okay.

'Reynolds of the Mounted' (by Art Pinajian): Reynolds takes on a guy who tried to murder his partner to get sole control of a gold mine. On the Mountie Scale (a special scoring system that ranges from -10 to -1, leaving it automatically below any other genre published) I rate this a -4.

I'm struggling to justify why I even read this comic.  I'm trying to cover the super-heroes as comprehensively as I can, so I suppose that the Clock is the reason.  But he sucks.  And there are no other strips in Feature Comics that I'm interested in.  Now that Movie Comics has been cancelled this is easily the worst comic that I'm reading.

Thursday, July 14, 2011

July 1939: Feature Comics #24

Cover by Ed Cronin

'Charlie Chan' (by Alfred Andriola): After the terrible first installment of this strip, 'Charlie Chan' redeems itself with a pretty decent story. Charlie is on a cruise ship trying to catch the infamous jewel thief Grissac, and there is no shortage of potential culprits. Normally I dislike it when a Golden Age comic introduces too many characters at once, but here I was able to follow things and keep track of everybody.  Perhaps I'm just happy because I picked out all the clues and pegged who Grissac was early on, but I quite enjoyed this.

'Rance Keane, the Knight of the West' (by Will Arthur): Rance Keane goes to see an old friend, who has returned from "The East" to run his father's ranch. But Rance figures out that it's an impostor, who has the real guy tied up in a shack. It's the standard "guy tries to steal other guy's ranch" routine, but it's well told, and the impostor angle isn't one that's been played much in the westerns so far.

'Jane Arden' (by Monte Barrett and Russell E. Ross): Crikey mick, everywhere I turn it's jewel thieves. Jane is hired to catch a jewel thief, and to do so she goes undercover as a crook to make contact with a notorious fence. This is a solid spy story.

'Big Top' (by Ed Wheelan): Hal wants to marry Myra, but the movie studio that he works for has a clause in his contract that he can't get married. The rest of the story is just them talking to the other circus folk about it, which isn't the most exciting thing in the world.

'The Clock Strikes' (by George E. Brenner): The Clock investigates a crook who has sold bad stocks, then murdered his customer after he complained to the police. This is one of those irritating stories where the good guy makes his plan and pulls it off with no difficulty whatsoever.  There's no dramatic tension at all.

'Gallant Knight' (by Vernon Henkel): Sir Neville's adventures take a fantastic turn, as he is kidnapped by a sexy witch in the forest and taken to toil in the mines of the Shadow World. By the end he has led a revolt and escaped. It could have been great, but it was lacking in that weird dream-like quality that the best Golden Age fantasy stuff has.  This is the last we see of 'Gallant Knight', so I assume he dies at some point during the Crusades.

'Slim and Tubby' (by John J. Welch): The ranch has boxing champ Davey Noyes as a guest, but after putting on a rowdy party he gets into a fight with local cowboy Benton. This is set-up for them to have a proper match in the next issue, but it didn't make me care who wins.

'Devil's Head' (by Robert M. Hyatt): In this prose story two brothers go sailing in a storm. Jed is burly and tough, while Derry is slighter and more sensitive. Jed is constantly at Derry for being a coward, but when their ship crashes Derry gives his life to save his brother and shows him what true courage is. This is actually really well done, and I did not see that end coming.

'Ned Brant' (by Bob Zuppke): Ned and his pals arrive at a gold mine, where his father and a couple of government agents meet them. It turns out that crooks are stealing gold from the mine, and Ned takes them down with his elite football skills. I'm developing an instant hatred for all of these sportsman adventurers.

'Reynolds of the Mounted' (by Art Pinajian): The criminal Jules Reynard escapes to wreak havoc, and Reynolds goes after him. The end is great, as Reynard fires his gun at Reynolds's plane, while Reynolds just flies the burning plane right into the guy. Hardcore.

Monday, June 27, 2011

June 1939: Feature Comics #23

Cover by Ed Cronin

'Charlie Chan' (by Alfred Andriola): Charlie Chan, famous Chinese detective and star of many movies, has come to Feature Comics. In this story he rescues an inventor who has created a formula for "dark light", a substance that can be used to take photos through solid objects. Not only is this tedious but every page has about twenty million panels, which makes it an ordeal to get through. At least Charlie is a distinctive character, although his inability to form a coherent sentence gets really irritating.

'Gallant Knight' (by Vernon Henkel): The armies of Navaria are summoned to aid Charlemagne in battle agains the Tartars, and Sir Neville rides with them. Most of the story involves an ambush and battle with Tartars, but it's not terribly exciting.

'The Clock Strikes' (by George Brenner): The Clock investigates the kidnapping of a millionaire, which is about as stock standard as plots get in the Golden Age. Brenner tries to liven it up by having police detective McDuff take the credit for the case, but it's so offhand that it doesn't matter.

'Jane Arden' (by J.P. McEvoy and J.H. Striebel): Jane Arden wraps up the case and uncovers the murderer, and there's some effective misdirection thrown in at the last minute.  But the artist is getting lazy, and using a lot of silhouettes. It makes it hard to figure out which character is which, a fairly vital thing when you're talking about a murder mystery.

'Reynolds of the Mounted' (by Art Pinajian): Reynolds rescues a girl who has been kidnapped in order to blackmail her father into giving up his ranch.  My hatred for ranches, cowboys and mounties has increased exponentially since I started this project.

'Rain Bird, Chapter II' (by Robert M. Hyatt): This prose story continues from last month, with Broken Bow on his way to see the Jugardillos to obtain the secret of rain. It turns out that they are strange, ugly little goblin creatures who play with lightning bolts, and Broken Bow must answer their riddles to get a bolt of his own. This is quite decent, with a sad ending that elevates it far higher than just about every other prose story I've read in this blog.

'Big Top' (by Ed Wheelan): This strip just continues to be all over the place. First it's about Red, a kid who is a clown but prefers riding horses. Then the circus puts on a benefit show for sick kids. Then it gets into some loose plot threads from the last story, as everyone finds out who was trying to get the circus closed down. If it could focus on one thing for mor than a few panels it might be passably awful instead of utterly awful.

'Rance Keane, The Knight of the West' (by Will Arthur): Rance takes on a gang of crooks who have robbed a dude ranch. So, so dull.

Monday, June 13, 2011

May 1939: Superman #1; Feature Comics #22

Cover by Joe Shuster

This is another momentous occasion: the first time in this project that I have read a comic devoted entirely to a single character.  I must say that it was very cathartic reading a comic entirely filled with super-hero stories. No detectives, no cowboys, no mounties, and no secret agents, just cover-to-cover Superman by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster. This is exactly the sort of comic that made me want to start this project in the first place.

It begins with another retelling of Superman's origin, although it skips the stuff on Krypton with Superman's parents from the newspaper strip.  There is a small retcon here once we get to Superman's arrival on Earth. In earlier versions of the story he is found by an unnamed "passing motorist", but here he is specifically found by Ma and Pa Kent. They still send him to an orphanage, but for the first time we see them returning to adopt him, and also get a glimpse into his childhood as his powers develop.  Superman's altruism has been taken for granted in earlier stories, but we see an important scene here as Ma and Pa Kent tell him that he must hide his true identity while using his powers to help people. The origin sequence ends with Clark at the graves of his foster parents.  It's a whole lot of new material that gives the character some added depth.

Next we see Clark Kent applying for a job at the Daily Star newspaper, and this is where the continuity of the comic books and the newspaper strips diverge. In the strips Clark is told that he can have the job only if he gets an interview with Superman.  In the comic book he has to get the scoop on a mob attacking the county jail before the editor will hire him. I could probably reconcile the two if I wanted, but at this point I'm reluctantly willing to declare the continuities separate and call it a day.

Once Clark Kent has his job we move into another plot, where the guy who was about to be lynched at the county jail tells Superman about a woman who has been wrongly sentenced to death, and tells him who the real culprit is. At this point it was starting to sound familiar to me, and that's because this is a set-up for the first Superman story from Action Comics #1. Superman finds the real murderer, a night club singer named Bea Carroll, and carries her away.

From there on the book is almost all reprints.  First up we get the Superman stories from Action Comics #1 and #2. To refresh your memories, Superman saves the woman from the electric chair, has a few other adventures unrelated to the story, then takes a crooked weapons manufacturer to South America and forces him to enlist in the army. With the new opening material, and the fact that Action Comics #1 leads right into issue #2, this is a very long and satisfying story. Even without that initial impact of seeing Superman for the first time it has a lot of energy and holds up quite well.

The story from Action Comics #3, in which Superman forces a mine owner to confront the poor conditions in his mine, doesn't fare quite so well. It hinges on the mine owner deciding to take his high society dinner party into a dangerous mine for a lark, and also on his guests all believing that it's a great idea. Such stupidity, even from wealthy twits, stretches credibility a little too far.

The story from Action Comics #4 also has its problems. It's the one where Superman masquerades as a footballer to expose a corrupt coach. But the opening with a hit-and-run motorist has no bearing on the plot, and Superman only stumbles on the football story by going through a train window for no apparent reason. I already remarked last time I read this on Superman's startling decision to drug the footballer he's posing as with a hypodermic needle, but I noticed this time that he keeps the guy sedated in bed for days. Modern day Superman would give this guy a lecture he'd never forget.

Siegel and Shuster love a good fan club, as the Junior Federal Men Club has shown, and now they're starting up the Superman of America. It's the usual stuff, with badges and a membership certificate, but what I'm interested in is Superman's Secret Code. Apparently he's going to have a secret message in Action Comics from now on, so I hope I can decipher it.

The issue finishes with a text story in which a detective tries to arrest Superman only to find Clark Kent instead. Kent spends the story quietly making fun of the guy and capturing a murderer as Superman when no one is looking. It's not bad, and more entertaining to me than most of the prose material has been.

Cover by Lank Leonard

It should be noted at this point that I was in a terrible mood while reading this comic, so the reviews might be excessively negative. You've been warned.

'Jane Arden' (by Monte Barrett and Russell E.Ross): Jane is still investigating the murder of Judge Stephens and looking for whoever hid his will. There's some effective misdirection from all sides, and enough legitimate suspects that I have no idea who did it. The problem is that I just don't care who did it.

'Lena Pry' (by Creators Unknown): Lena has been kidnapped by "ghosts" who are actually her neighbours. One of them wants to marry her, and one of the group coming to her rescue wants to marry her as well, but the only thing they value about her is her cooking ability. This would have no entertainment value if it weren't for the characters all talking like hillbillies.

'Rance Keane, The Knight of the West' (by Will Arthur): When Rance stumbles across a guy who is being eaten by coyotes, he rescues him and discovers that the man was left there to die by a guy named Moseby. Moseby had forced him to sign over his ranch, the usual western genre shenanigans that I'm already sick off. Needless to say, Rance hatches a plan to get Moseby put behind bars, and that's the story. And to think that I used to like westerns.

'Espionage: A Black X Story' (by Will Eisner): The Black X's Hindu servant Batu has been captured by a spy ring, and is being tortured, but he's able to contact the Black X via telepathy. The Black X comes to his rescue, and shatters the spy ring with gusto, just pummeling them all into submission. (They never should have talked smack about his monocle. It's rad.) There's not much to this story, but it's well paced and pretty good fun.

'Big Top' (by Ed Wheelan): I vaguely remember this one from last issue, but all I remember is that's it's about a circus, which is no help at all. It seems there's a rival owner sabotaging the circus. His accomplice is the announcer, who gets crushed by a falling beam and knocked unconscious. There's a banker who is working as a clown for some reason. And two characters want to get engaged. It's all a bit choppy, as none of these disparate plot threads seem to relate to each other at all.

'The Clock Strikes' (by Geo. E. Brenner): The Clock investigates the supposed suicide of the local District Attorney, and through some astute detective work manages to trace the murder back to the mayor, who was about to be exposed for graft. It's not bad, but I'm puzzled that The Clock only wears his mask in two panels, and we only see it from behind. For the rest of the strip he's just plain old Brian O'Brien, which makes his adventures seem a lot more banal.

'Ned Brant' (by Bob Zuppke and W. Depew): This another one that has slipped my mind completely. It's also incredibly disjointed. It starts with Ned fighting a guy for reasons I can't figure out. Then on the next page he's going camping with his pals, and by the end there are some shifty characters in the caravan next door. At this point I'm not even certain if this is a continuing story or a series of one page gags.

'Captain Cook of Scotland Yard' (by Stan Asch): Cook is on the trail of Koffler, a notorious jewel thief. This is okay, but the end is very ambiguous. Everyone acts like Koffler was blown up by his own bomb at the end, but it seems to me like he escaped. I guess the cops could just be wrong, and Koffler will be back, but it does make them look pretty stupid.

'Rain Bird' (by Robert M. Hyatt): In this prose story, two Indians are sent to the mysterious Jugardillo people to ask for rain. This is all set-up, establishing that Broken Bow is the brave one who was sent on the quest, and Weetah is his less brave companion. It's a relatively decent premise, and continues the trend of the continued text stories being better than their one-shot counterparts.

'Reynolds of the Mounted' (by Art Pinajian): Arg, Mounties. And not only is this a story about mounties, but it has one of my least favourite plot devices ever - the guy who first reported to the police about there being counterfeiters in the area turns out to be the counterfeiting ringleader! I can't for the life of me even figure out why he would do such a thing. It's baffling, and I hate it.

'Slim and Tubby' (by John Welch): Speaking of crap that makes no sense, in this story a girl named Judith falls in love with Roger after he becomes poor, but when it turns out he's still rich after all she runs off to start dating his fat buddy. Only in comics, folks.

'Gallant Knight' (by Vernon Henkel): The plot of this is pretty good; Princess Alice has been kidnapped by the rebels, and Sir Neville has been mistaken for a rebel by the king's men. So he taunts the king's men and leads them a merry chase to the rebel hideout, and while they're attacking it he sneaks in, kills the rebel leader and rescues Alice. But the pacing is super-fast, with too much of the action covered in narrative captions.

Monday, May 16, 2011

April 1939: Feature Comics #21

Cover by Ed Cronin

Momentous occasion time!  This is the first comic in this project that isn't somehow associated with National/DC.  Feature Comics #21 is the first comic published by Quality, who will go on to create a bunch of characters like the Blackhawks, Uncle Sam, and Plastic Man.  Obviously those characters are subsumed by DC much later, but at this point in time they're completely separate.

This begs the question, why is it issue #21 if this is the first Quality comic?  That's because this title existed at a different publisher, Eastern Color Press, under the title Feature Funnies.  A lot of the strips are continued from there, so I'm joining them mid-stream.

'Espionage' (by Will Erwin): The first non-humour feature in this mag is a spy strip starring The Black X, an American spy with an awesome monocle. The Black X has stolen documents that will expose a foreign spy, but he has to make it to Washington with the evidence before enemy agents catch up with him. What follows is a pretty tense cross-country chase sequence, with an effective twist ending. This is alright, and it ough to be, because Will Erwin is actually a pseudonym for legendary creator Will Eisner.

'Jane Arden' (by Monte Barrett and Russell E. Ross): I've come into the middle of this serial, in which a girl reporter is present at the murder of a judge who was about to read a will. The will has disappeared; who is the culprit?!?!?! It pains me greatly to see that this insidious plot device is in use outside of DC.  Wills, you guys.  I'm sick of them.

'Gallant Knight' (by Vernon Henkel): It's another strip I've joined mid-stream. A knight named Sir Neville and his princess companion have washed up near a fisherman's hut. The fisherman sells them out to a guy named Chopak who holds her to ransom, planning to raise an army and usurp the crown of France. This sort of medieval knight genre has fallen out of favour over at DC, so it's refreshing to see one here. And it's better than any of the ones I read over there, as well.

'Big Top' (by Ed Wheelan): Hey, it's Ed Wheelan, perpetrator of 'Secrets of the Tomb' over in Movie Comics. This story is about a circus that gets robbed for ten grand.  While the investigation goes on, a banker promises to invest money in the circus so long as they let him work as a clown. It's better than his Movie Comics work, but that is saying very, very little.

'Captain Cook of Scotland Yard' (by Stan Asch): This murder mystery story claims that there are clues in the first three panels that will help the reader to solve the case before Captain Cook. Unless I'm completely blind, there are none. (For the record, the butler and the chauffeur did it. Because they were left out of the will!)

'The Clock Strikes' (by George Brenner): The Clock, aka Brian O'Brien, is a masked crimefighter of sorts (although he only wears a mask in the opening title panel, not the story itself). In this story he visits the New York World's Fair (I can't escape this damned place) where he foils a robbery. I couldn't be more bored.

Apparently the Clock is the first masked crimefighter in comic books, having appeared in a whole lot of stuff before this issue.

'Lala Palooza' (by Rube Goldberg): This is a strip about two people who take over a hotel, and it's not particularly interesting. But some of you might recognise the name of the creator, who inspired the name of the Rube Goldberg device. You know how Wile E. Coyote would rig up some ridiculous contraption to capture the Road Runner? That's a Rube Goldberg device. And the top of every page here has a one-panel gag involving a different one each time.  They're quite amusing.

'Richard Manners, The Super Sleuth' (by Fran Frollo): Richard Manners and his buddy Mitch stop a robber who has been making his escapes in an airplane.  It's yet another detective strip where the principal characters are completely devoid of personality.

'Ned Brant' (by Bob Zuppke and R.W. Depew): This is a teenage humour strip, I guess. Brant wins a baseball game, gets in the school play and screws it up, and picks a fight with a guy who is talking about his girl. I've read one Ned Brant strip, and I already want him to die.

'The Mystery of Echo Island' (by John A. Thorne): This is a prose story about two kids who have been kidnapped, along with their inventor father.  They escape, rescue their dad, and beat the crooks using a robot. It's not nearly as exciting as it sounds.

'Reynolds of the Mounted' (by Art Pinajian): Oh no, mounties! In this story, Reynolds and his partners take on an eskimo witch doctor.  This is fairly average, which makes it the friggin Citizen Kane of mountie comics.